Matter of Regan v DiNapoli
2016 NY Slip Op 00415 [135 AD3d 1225]
January 21, 2016
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 4, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of C. Murray Regan,Appellant,
v
Thomas P. DiNapoli, as State Comptroller,Respondent.

Law Office of Christen Archer Pierrot, East Aurora (Christen Archer Pierrot ofcounsel), for appellant.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondent.

Rose, J. Appeal from an order and judgment of the Supreme Court (O'Connor, J.),entered July 1, 2014 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in aproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, to review a determination of respondentdenying petitioner credit for certain years of service.

Petitioner worked as a teacher and, in that capacity, he was a member of the NewYork State Teachers' Retirement System (hereinafter TRS) for over 30 years when, inJanuary 1998, he also began to serve as an elected town supervisor. In this latter capacity,he was also a member of the New York State and Local Retirement System (hereinafterLRS). After being advised by a representative of the LRS that he could retire fromteaching and continue to accrue service credit in the LRS "[a]s long as [he] continue[d]as an elected official," petitioner retired from teaching in July 1998 and began collectinghis pension from the TRS while continuing to earn a town supervisor's salary. In 2001,petitioner lost his bid for reelection as town supervisor and applied to the LRS forretirement benefits. The LRS rejected his application, finding that he had not yet accruedthe required minimum amount of service credit. In 2004, petitioner regained electiveoffice, this time as a village justice. He served for eight years in this new position, all thewhile receiving both his TRS pension and a village justice's salary. During this timeperiod, the LRS sent him annual updates indicating, among other things, that he was alsoaccruing service credit.

[*2] When petitionerdecided not to seek reelection for his position as a village justice for the term starting in2012, he again applied to the LRS for retirement benefits and, again, the LRS rejectedhis application. The LRS explained to petitioner that he remained ineligible forretirement benefits and its prior advice and updates had been erroneous because, uponacceptance of his position as an elected village justice in 2004, he had not suspendedreceipt of his TRS pension benefits and, therefore, he did not resume accruing servicecredit in the LRS. After exhausting his administrative remedies in an unsuccessfulattempt to overturn the denial of his application for additional LRS service credit,petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding. Supreme Court dismissed thepetition, prompting this appeal.

Petitioner argues that Civil Service Law § 150 permits him to receiveboth his TRS pension benefits and his salary as an elected official while simultaneouslyaccruing service credit toward an LRS pension. However, based upon our review of thelanguage of the statute and the legislative intent behind it (see Matter of Grella v Hevesi,38 AD3d 113, 116 [2007]), we cannot agree. As relevant here, Civil Service Law§ 150 generally prohibits receipt of both a public pension and a salary as apublic official or employee, but also provides an exception for public pensioners whobecome elected officials—such as petitioner. It states that "if any personsubsequent to his or her retirement from [public employment] . . . shallaccept any . . . [public] employment . . . , except. . . an elective public office, any [public] pension or annuityawarded or allotted to him or her upon retirement . . . shall be suspendedduring such service or employment and while such person is receiving any salary oremolument therefor" (Civil Service Law § 150 [emphasis added]).

While we agree that this exception allowed petitioner to receive a salary as an electedofficial without suspending his TRS pension benefits, we note that Civil Service Law§ 150 makes no express mention of service credit and, instead, refers onlyto pension benefits that have already been "awarded or allotted." The statute makes noreference whatsoever to the accrual of any future benefits. Similarly, the legislativehistory indicates that the original purpose behind the exception for public pensionerswho subsequently become elected officials was to encourage continued civic engagementby "allow[ing] a retired public employee to seek elected public office and continue toreceive his/her public pension benefits" (Assembly Sponsor's Mem in Support, BillJacket, L 1995, ch 211 at 7 [emphasis added]). Thus, in our view, the statute allowspublic pensioners to continue receiving the benefits they have already earned while alsoserving in paid elective office, but it does not provide for the accrual of additional creditfor new or greater pension benefits.

Further, petitioner's argument regarding the meaning of Civil Service Law§ 150 ignores Retirement and Social Security Law § 40 (c)(9), which provides that a retired public employee entitled to public pension benefits whosubsequently accepts a new public service position is considered to be an active memberof the retirement system only if the pension benefits to which he or she is entitled aresuspended during his or her active membership. Respondent based his denial ofpetitioner's application for additional service credit, in part, upon his reasonableinterpretation of this provision to mean that, because petitioner did not suspend his TRSpension benefits during his tenure as an elected village justice, he was not an activemember of the LRS during that time period and, accordingly, did not accrue additionalLRS service credit. Deferring to respondent's reasonable interpretation of this provision(see e.g. Matter of Brandt vDiNapoli, 126 AD3d 1165, 1166-1167 [2015], lv denied 26 NY3d 904[2015]), and based upon our own reading of Civil Service Law § 150(see e.g. Matter of Grella v Hevesi, 38 AD3d at 116), we agree with SupremeCourt's determination that respondent correctly denied petitioner's request for additionalservice credit.

[*3] Petitioner alternativelyargues that respondent should be equitably estopped from denying him additional servicecredit because his career decisions were based, in part, upon incomplete advice anderroneous information provided by LRS employees regarding his ability to earn suchcredit. However, the doctrine of equitable estoppel generally cannot be invoked against astate agency unless " 'there has been a showing of fraud, misrepresentation,deception, or similar affirmative misconduct, along with reasonable reliancethereon' " (Matter ofAtlantic States Legal Found., Inc. v New York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation,119 AD3d 1172, 1173 [2014], quoting Stone Bridge Farms, Inc. v County of Columbia, 88 AD3d1209, 1212 [2011]). While the LRS readily conceded that mistakes were maderegarding the information provided to respondent, we find no evidence in the record thatany of those mistakes rise above the level of "erroneous advice [given] by a governmentemployee[,] [which] does not constitute the type of unusual circumstance contemplatedby the exception" (Matter of Grella v Hevesi, 38 AD3d at 117; see Matter of Westmorland v NewYork State & Local Retirement Sys., 129 AD3d 1402, 1404-1405 [2015];Matter of Atlantic States Legal Found., Inc. v New York State Dept. of Envtl.Conservation, 119 AD3d at 1173).

Petitioner's further contention that respondent's denial of his application foradditional service credit violates NY Constitution, article V, § 7 is raisedfor the first time on appeal and, thus, is unpreserved for our review. Even if this issuewere preserved, we would find it to be academic because petitioner had no right orentitlement to the additional service credit he claims. We have examined petitioner'sremaining arguments and find them to be without merit.

Lahtinen, J.P., Garry, Lynch and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order andjudgment is affirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.