| Matter of Westmorland v New York State & LocalRetirement Sys. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 05532 [129 AD3d 1402] |
| June 25, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Anne P. Westmorland, Petitioner, vNew York State and Local Retirement System, Respondent. |
Pope Law Firm, PLLC, Williamsville (Paul T. Buerger Jr. of counsel), forpetitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Julie M. Sheridan of counsel), forrespondent.
Egan Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of theComptroller which denied petitioner's application for additional pension servicecredits.
Between December 1969 and July 1980, petitioner was employed as a typist by theState University of New York at Buffalo. Petitioner retired due to illness on a tier 1ordinary disability pension effective July 24, 1980, at which point she had accumulatednearly 11 years of service credit. Petitioner's health subsequently improved, and shereturned to the university in 1985 as a keyboard specialist. Following her return,petitioner continued to receive her disability pension benefit—in addition to hersalary and within the parameters set forth in Retirement and Social Security Law§ 102.
Ten years later, by letter dated March 29, 1995, petitioner asked respondent toprovide her with her service credit to date. Respondent informed petitioner that she hadaccumulated 10 years, 7 months and 15 days of service credit between 1969 and 1980and, in conjunction therewith, expressly advised petitioner that she was not "receiv[ing]service credit for time worked after retirement while [she was] also receiving pensionbenefits." Eleven years later, by letter dated May 12, 2006, petitioner again wrote torespondent, this time inquiring as to whether she had in fact applied to be "restored tomembership" in respondent and, further, whether it was [*2]possible to retroactively obtain service credit for herpostretirement work. After being advised that she could not simultaneously collect herdisability pension benefit and be an active member of respondent earning service credit,petitioner commenced an action seeking to restore the service credit to which shebelieved she was entitled. Respondent's subsequent motion to dismiss for failure toexhaust administrative remedies was granted.
The matter eventually proceeded to an administrative hearing, at the conclusion ofwhich the Hearing Officer found, among other things, that petitioner was not entitled toadditional service credit. The Comptroller adopted the Hearing Officer's findings in thisregard, prompting petitioner to commence this CPLR article 78 proceeding to challengethe Comptroller's determination.
We confirm. "The Comptroller 'is charged with the responsibility of determiningservice credits for retirement purposes and his determination will be upheld if rationaland supported by substantial evidence' " (Matter of Cohen v New York State & Local Employees'Retirement Sys., 117 AD3d 1370, 1370 [2014], lv dismissed and denied24 NY3d 1028 [2014], quoting Matter of Williams v McCall, 283 AD2d 808,809 [2001]; see Matter ofRatzker v Office of the N.Y. State Comptroller [N.Y. State & Local RetirementSys.], 106 AD3d 1321, 1322 [2013], lv denied 22 NY3d 854 [2013]; Matter of Muccia v DiNapoli,69 AD3d 1291, 1292 [2010]; Matter of DeLuca v New York State & Local Employees'Retirement Sys., 48 AD3d 876, 877 [2008]). As the party seeking additionalservice credit, petitioner bore the burden of demonstrating her entitlement thereto (seeMatter of Cohen v New York State & Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 117AD3d at 1370; Matter of Ratzker v Office of the N.Y. State Comptroller [N.Y. State& Local Retirement Sys.], 106 AD3d at 1322-1323; Matter of DeLuca vNew York State & Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 48 AD3d at 877).
Retirement and Social Security Law § 102 governs postretirementemployment by disability pensioners and dictates, based upon the disability retiree's finalsalary (see Retirement and Social Security Law § 102 [f]) followinghis or her return to active service, whether membership in respondent is mandatory(see Retirement and Social Security Law § 102 [d]) or optional(see Retirement and Social Security Law § 102 [e]). Here, theevidence adduced at the hearing revealed that petitioner's salary upon returning to activeservice was such that membership in respondent was not mandatory and that, despiteexploring the possibility of enrolling in respondent, petitioner never actually exercisedher option to do so. Absent membership in respondent following her return to service in1985, and in light of her continued receipt of disability pension benefits, petitionersimply was not entitled to earn additional service credit.
Petitioner's related arguments on this point do not warrant extended discussion.Despite petitioner's protestations to the contrary, the Comptroller was not under anaffirmative duty to either apprise petitioner of all available options relating to herretirement benefits or ensure that she selected the most advantageous benefit (seeMatter of O'Neill v Regan, 114 AD2d 613, 614 [1985]; cf. Matter of Gorey v New YorkState Comptroller, 83 AD3d 1363, 1364 [2011]; Matter of Hutt v RetirementBd. of N.Y. State Teachers' Retirement Sys., 299 AD2d 679, 680 [2002]).[FN*]
[*3]Further, to the extent that petitioner contends that one ofrespondent's employees provided her with incomplete or erroneous advice regarding hermembership/benefit options upon returning to service, it is well settled that, except innarrow circumstances not present here (see Matter of Atlantic States Legal Found., Inc. v New York StateDept. of Envtl. Conservation, 119 AD3d 1172, 1173 [2014]), "estoppel is notavailable against a governmental agency in the exercise of its governmental functionsand respondent may not be estopped by the erroneous acts of its administrativeemployees" (Matter of Dear vNew York State & Local Retirement Sys., 115 AD3d 1141, 1143 [2014],lv denied 23 NY3d 905 [2014] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citationsomitted]). More to the point, estoppel cannot be invoked "to create rights to retirementbenefits to which there is no entitlement" (Matter of Bombace v Nitido, 117 AD3d 1375, 1376 [2014][internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Price v New York State & Local Employees'Retirement Sys., 107 AD3d 1212, 1216 [2013]). For all of these reasons, wefind the Comptroller's determination denying petitioner additional service credit to besupported by substantial evidence.
Peters, P.J., Garry and Lynch, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *:It bears repeating thatpetitioner was advised—in early 1995 and in no uncertain terms—that shewas not "receiv[ing] service credit for time worked after retirement while [she was] alsoreceiving pension benefits." It was not until May 2006—roughly 11 yearslater—that petitioner sought input from respondent regarding her "options" in thisregard.