| Leonard v Planning Bd. of Town of Union Vale |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 01157 [136 AD3d 873] |
| February 17, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| E. Deane Leonard et al., Appellants, v PlanningBoard of Town of Union Vale, Respondent. |
Steven Habiague, Poughquag, NY, for appellants.
Terry Rice, Suffern, NY, for respondent.
In a hybrid action, inter alia, to recover damages pursuant to 42 USC§ 1983, and proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to reviewdeterminations of the defendant/respondent dated March 21, 2012, and April 18, 2012,inter alia, rejecting an application of the plaintiffs/petitioners for preliminary platapproval, the plaintiffs/petitioners appeal (1) as limited by their brief, from so much of anorder of the Supreme Court, Dutchess County (Rosa, J.), dated November 8, 2013, as,upon reargument, granted that branch of the defendant/respondent's motion which waspursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the third cause of action, alleging a violation ofconstitutional rights pursuant to 42 USC § 1983; and (2) from an order ofthe same court, dated February 18, 2014, which denied their motion for leave to renewtheir opposition to that branch of the defendant/respondent's motion which was pursuantto CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the third cause of action, alleging a violation ofconstitutional rights pursuant to 42 USC § 1983.
Ordered that the order dated November 8, 2013, is affirmed insofar as appealedfrom; and it is further,
Ordered that the order dated February 18, 2014, is affirmed; and it is further,
Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the defendant/respondent.
In 1987, in connection with a proposal to subdivide a 950-acre parcel of real propertythen owned by the plaintiffs/petitioners E. Deane Leonard and Steven Habiague in theTown of Union Vale, the Planning Board of the Town of Union Vale (hereinafter thePlanning Board) issued a negative declaration pursuant to the State EnvironmentalQuality Review Act (ECL art 8). Thereafter, those plaintiffs/petitioners sought andreceived approval from the Planning Board to subdivide a portion of the property, whichwas developed. In 2012, Habiague, Leonard, and the plaintiff/petitioner Robert O.Dryfoos, to whom a portion of the property had been sold, applied for preliminary platapproval to subdivide the remainder of the parcel. The application relied upon the 1987negative declaration. The Planning Board, in a resolution adopted on April 18, 2012,determined, inter alia, that the 1987 negative declaration was inapplicable to the subjectapplication and, thus, that the application was incomplete.
[*2] The plaintiffs/petitioners commenced this hybridaction/proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, seeking, inter alia, damages pursuant to42 USC § 1983, on the ground that the Planning Board's determinationconcerning the negative declaration violated their substantive due process rights. TheSupreme Court, upon reargument, granted that branch of the Planning Board's motionwhich was pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the third cause of action, alleging aviolation of constitutional rights pursuant to 42 USC § 1983. Thereafter, theSupreme Court denied the plaintiffs/petitioners' motion for leave to renew theiropposition to that branch of the Planning Board's motion.
"In the land-use context, 42 USC § 1983 protects against municipalactions that violate a property owner's rights to due process" (Bower Assoc. v Town of PleasantVal., 2 NY3d 617, 626 [2004]). In order to establish a violation of substantivedue process rights in this context, plaintiffs are required to establish "a cognizable orvested property interest, not the mere hope of one" (Sonne v Board of Trustees of Vil. of Suffern, 67 AD3d192, 201 [2009]; see Bower Assoc. v Town of Pleasant Val., 2 NY3d at 627;Zahra v Town of Southold, 48 F3d 674, 680 [2d Cir 1995]). Here, in order toestablish a cognizable property right, the plaintiffs/petitioners were required to establish a" 'legitimate claim of entitlement' " to have the 1987 negative declarationapplied to their present application for preliminary plat approval (Zahra v Town ofSouthold, 48 F3d at 680, quoting RRI Realty Corp. v Incorporated Vil. ofSouthampton, 870 F2d 911, 915 [2d Cir 1989]; see Crowley v Courville, 76F3d 47, 51-52 [2d Cir 1996]; see also Town of Orangetown v Magee, 88 NY2d41, 51 [1996]). Because the Planning Board's discretion in this respect was not "sonarrowly circumscribed" that application of the 1987 negative declaration to the presentproject was "virtually assured," the plaintiffs/petitioners failed to allege a cognizableproperty interest (Bower Assoc. v Town of Pleasant Val., 2 NY3d at 629;see 6 NYCRR 617.7 [e], [f]; Crowley v Courville, 76 F3d at 52; RRIRealty Corp. v Incorporated Vil. of Southampton, 870 F2d at 919). Accordingly, theSupreme Court properly, upon reargument, granted that branch of the Planning Board'smotion which was to dismiss the third cause of action.
The Supreme Court did not improvidently exercise its discretion in denying theplaintiffs/petitioners' motion for leave to renew their opposition to that branch of thePlanning Board's motion which was to dismiss the third cause of action since the newfacts asserted on the renewal motion would not have changed the prior determination andthe plaintiffs/petitioners did not offer a reasonable justification for their failure to submitthose facts in connection with the Planning Board's initial motion to dismiss (see Kamdem-Ouaffo v Pepsico,Inc., 133 AD3d 828 [2015]; Matter of Grande v City of New York, 133 AD3d 752[2015]; Ayala v Gonzalez,129 AD3d 874 [2015]).
Finally, the plaintiffs/petitioners request, as an alternative to dismissal, that we staythe action pending the disposition of a related federal action. Inasmuch as theplaintiffs/petitioners did not argue in the Supreme Court that a stay would be appropriateas an alternative to dismissal, their contention regarding a stay is not properly before us(see Metropolitan Steel Indus.,Inc. v Tully Constr. Co., Inc., 55 AD3d 363, 364 [2008]; Rodrigues v City ofNew York, 193 AD2d 79, 88 [1993]; see also Gayz v Kirby, 41 AD3d 782, 783 [2007]). Balkin,J.P., Dickerson, Miller and Hinds-Radix, JJ., concur.