Matter of Marine Holdings, LLC v New York City Commn. onHuman Rights
2016 NY Slip Op 02369 [137 AD3d 1284]
March 30, 2016
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 27, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of Marine Holdings, LLC, Doing Businessas Marine Terrace Associates, LLC, et al., Appellants,
v
New York CityCommission on Human Rights, Respondent, et al.,Respondent.

Herrick, Feinstein LLP, New York, NY (Avery S. Mehlman and Jonathan L. Adlerof counsel), for petitioners-appellants.

Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York, NY (Francis Caputo andMichael J. Pastor of counsel), for respondent-respondent.

In a proceeding pursuant to the Administrative Code of the City of New York§ 8-123 and CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the New YorkCity Commission on Human Rights dated April 24, 2012, which found that thepetitioners unlawfully discriminated against the complainant on the basis of a disability,awarded the complainant damages for mental anguish in the sum of $75,000, andimposed a civil penalty in the sum of $125,000, the petitioners appeal (1) from a decisionof the Supreme Court, Queens County (Sampson, J.), dated March 14, 2013, and (2), aslimited by their brief, from so much of a judgment of the same court dated December 11,2013, as granted the petition only to the extent of reducing the award of damages formental anguish from the sum of $75,000 to the sum of $60,000, and otherwise confirmedthe determination, denied the petition, dismissed the proceeding, and granted the, ineffect, cross petition of the New York City Commission on Human Rights to enforce thedetermination to the extent of directing enforcement of the determination asmodified.

Ordered that the appeal from the decision is dismissed, as no appeal lies from adecision (see Schicchi v J.A. Green Constr. Corp., 100 AD2d 509, 509-510[1984]); and it is further,

Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, thepetition is granted in its entirety, the, in effect, cross petition is denied in its entirety, andthe determination is annulled in its entirety; and it is further,

Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the petitioners.

The complainant filed a complaint with the New York City Commission on HumanRights (hereinafter the Commission), alleging that the petitioners, which owned andmanaged an apartment complex in which the complainant lived, had discriminatedagainst the complainant on the basis of a disability by denying her request to install ahandicapped accessible entrance to her [*2]apartment.After a hearing, an administrative law judge found that the petitioners did not unlawfullydiscriminate against the complainant on the basis of a disability, as the petitioners hadestablished that it would be structurally infeasible to install a handicapped accessibleentrance to the complainant's apartment. In a determination dated April 24, 2012, theCommission rejected the finding of the administrative law judge, found that thepetitioners unlawfully discriminated against the complainant on the basis of a disability,awarded the complainant damages for mental anguish in the sum of $75,000, andimposed a civil penalty in the sum of $125,000. The petitioners then commenced thisproceeding pursuant to the Administrative Code of the City of New York§ 8-123 and CPLR article 78 to review the Commission's determination.The Supreme Court granted the petition to the extent of reducing the award of damagesfor mental anguish from the sum of $75,000 to the sum of $60,000, but otherwiseconfirmed the determination, denied the petition, dismissed the proceeding, and grantedthe Commission's, in effect, cross petition to enforce the determination to the extent ofdirecting enforcement of the determination as modified. The petitioners appeal.

Administrative Code of the City of New York § 8-107 (15) (a) requirescertain "covered entit[ies]" to make "reasonable accommodation" to enable persons withdisabilities to enjoy certain rights. "Reasonable accommodation" is defined as "suchaccommodation that can be made that shall not cause undue hardship in the conduct ofthe covered entity's business" (Administrative Code of City of NY § 8-102[18]). In a proceeding to review a determination of the Commission finding that acovered entity unlawfully discriminated against a complainant, the Commission's finding"shall be conclusive if supported by substantial evidence on the record considered as awhole" (Administrative Code of City of NY § 8-123 [e]; see Matter of ISS Action Sec. vNew York City Commn. on Human Rights, 114 AD3d 943, 944 [2014];Matter of Brooklyn Hosp. Med. Ctr. v DeLeon, 208 AD2d 624 [1994]).

"Substantial evidence means such relevant proof as a reasonable mind may accept asadequate to support a conclusion or ultimate fact" (Matter of Bottom v Annucci, 26 NY3d 983, 984-985[2015] [internal quotation marks omitted]). "More than seeming or imaginary, it is lessthan a preponderance of the evidence, overwhelming evidence or evidence beyond areasonable doubt" (300 Gramatan Ave. Assoc. v State Div. of Human Rights, 45NY2d 176, 180-181 [1978]). "Essential attributes are relevance and a probativecharacter. Marked by its substance—its solid nature and ability to inspireconfidence, substantial evidence does not rise from bare surmise, conjecture, speculationor rumor" (id. at 180 [citations omitted]). "A court reviewing the substantiality ofthe evidence upon which an administrative agency has acted exercises a genuine judicialfunction and does not confirm a determination simply because it was made by such anagency" (id. at 181).

Here, the record did not contain any substantial evidence rebutting the petitioners'showing that it would be structurally infeasible to install a handicapped accessibleentrance to the complainant's apartment (see Matter of Schulman v State Div. ofHuman Rights, 239 AD2d 588, 590 [1997]; Matter of Concord Vil. Owners vCity of N.Y. Commn. on Human Rights, 199 AD2d 388, 389 [1993]; Matter ofState Div. of Human Rights v Fairway Apts. Corp., 39 AD2d 761, 761-762 [1972],affd 33 NY2d 754 [1973]). Accordingly, the petition should have been granted inits entirety, the determination should have been annulled in its entirety, and theCommission's, in effect, cross petition to enforce the determination should have beendenied in its entirety. Leventhal, J.P., Dickerson, Roman and Maltese, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.