| Matter of Dayannie I.M. (Roger I.M.) |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 02654 [138 AD3d 747] |
| April 6, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Dayannie I.M., a Child Alleged to beAbused and Neglected. Suffolk County Department of Social Services, Respondent;Roger I.M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Eyllen I.M., a Child Allegedto be Abused and Neglected. Suffolk County Department of Social Services,Respondent; Roger I.M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 2.) In the Matter of Hillary I.M., aChild Alleged to be Abused and Neglected. Suffolk County Department of SocialServices, Respondent; Roger I.M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 3.) In the Matter of KeyriI.M., a Child Alleged to be Abused and Neglected. Suffolk County Department of SocialServices, Respondent; Roger I.M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 4.) In the Matter ofJackzenny I.M., a Child Alleged to be Abused and Neglected. Suffolk CountyDepartment of Social Services, Respondent; Roger I.M., Appellant. (Proceeding No.5.) |
Gina M. Scelta, Huntington, NY, for appellant.
Dennis M. Brown, County Attorney, Central Islip, NY (Randall J. Ratje of counsel),for respondent.
McGuire & Pelaez, P.C., Central Islip, NY (Mary C. Pelaez of counsel),attorney for the children Dayannie I. M., Hillary I. M., Keyri I. M., and Jackzenny I.M.
Lynn Poster-Zimmerman, Huntington, NY, for the child Eyllen I. M.
Appeal from an order of fact-finding of the Family Court, Suffolk County (CarenLoguercio, J.), dated July 11, 2014. The order, after a fact-finding hearing, found that thefather abused and neglected the child Eyllen I.M., and derivatively abused and neglectedthe children Dayannie I.M., Hillary I.M., Keyri I.M., and Jackzenny I.M.
Ordered that the order of fact-finding is affirmed, without costs ordisbursements.
[*2] The petitioner establishedby a preponderance of the evidence that the appellant sexually abused and neglected hisdaughter Eyllen I.M. The evidence adduced at the fact-finding hearing established thatEyllen I.M. made consistent, detailed, and explicit out-of-court statements to a childprotective agency caseworker, a detective, and a school social worker, describingincidents of sexual abuse by the appellant (see Matter of Melody H. [Dwayne H.], 121 AD3d 686, 687[2014]; Matter of Jada A.[Robert W.], 116 AD3d 769, 770 [2014]). The record supports the FamilyCourt's determination that the testimony of the petitioner's child sexual abuse expert, whoconcluded that Eyllen I.M. exhibited behavior indicative of sexual abuse, as well as theappellant's written confession to the police that he sexually abused Eyllen I.M.,sufficiently corroborated Eyllen I.M.'s out-of-court statements of sexual abuse (see Matter of Joshua J.P. [AlquiberR.], 127 AD3d 1200 [2015]; Matter of Alexis S. [Edward S.], 115 AD3d 866, 867[2014]; Matter of Emani W.[Owana E.], 107 AD3d 815, 816 [2013]; Matter of Kassandra V. [Sylvia L.], 90 AD3d 940, 941[2011]; Matter of TristanR., 63 AD3d 1075, 1077 [2009]). Although the appellant and the mother of thesubject children disputed the allegations, there is no basis in the record to disturb theFamily Court's assessment of the witnesses' credibility (see Matter of Victoria P. [VictorP.], 121 AD3d 1006, 1006-1007 [2014]; Matter of Joshua P. [David J.], 111 AD3d 836, 838[2013]).
Although Eyllen I.M. recanted her allegations of sexual abuse, " '[a] child'srecantation of allegations of abuse does not necessarily require [the] Family Court toaccept the later statements as true because it is accepted that such a reaction is commonamong abused children' " (Matter of Tristan R., 63 AD3d 1075, 1077 [2009], quotingMatter of Kayla N., 41AD3d 920, 922 [2007]; seeMatter of Luis N.P. [Alquiber R.], 127 AD3d 1201, 1202 [2015]; Matter of Charlie S. [Rong S.],82 AD3d 1248, 1249 [2011]). "Rather, 'recantation of a party's initial statementsimply creates a credibility issue which the trial court must resolve' " (Matterof Tristan R., 63 AD3d at 1077, quoting Matter of Kayla N., 41 AD3d at922). The Family Court did not err in rejecting Eyllen I.M.'s out-of-court recantation,particularly in light of the expert testimony that it was a false recantation, and that EyllenI.M. may have been pressured to recant because the appellant was placed in jail after herdisclosure (see Matter of Melody H. [Dwayne H.], 121 AD3d at 687; Matter of Stephanie R., 21AD3d 417, 417-418 [2005]).
Moreover, the Family Court's determination that the appellant derivatively abusedand neglected the children Dayannie I.M., Hillary I.M., Keyri I.M., and Jackzenny I.M.was supported by a preponderance of the evidence. While a finding of sexual abuse ofone child does not, by itself, establish that other children in the household have beenderivatively abused or neglected (see Matter of Monica C.M. [Arnold A.], 107 AD3d 996,997 [2013]; Matter of Amoya S.[Henry C.—Syvonne C.], 100 AD3d 641, 642 [2012]; Matter of Mindy W. [GavrielW.], 93 AD3d 803, 804 [2012]; Matter of Abigail S., 21 AD3d 380, 381 [2005]), theappellant's sexual abuse of Eyllen I.M., which occurred while other children were presentin the home, evinced a flawed understanding of his duties as a parent and impairedparental judgment sufficient to support the Family Court's finding of derivative abuseand neglect (see Family Ct Act § 1046 [a] [i]; see generally Matter of Leah R.[Miguel R.], 104 AD3d 774, 774 [2013]; Matter of Monica C.M. [Arnold A.], 107 AD3d 996, 997[2013]; Matter of Trenasia J.[Frank J.], 107 AD3d 992, 993-994 [2013], affd 25 NY3d 1001 [2015];Matter of Aliyah G. [ArlenieG.], 95 AD3d 885, 887 [2012]; Matter of Rosy S., 54 AD3d 377, 378 [2008]). Althoughthe child Jackzenny I.M. was born after the sexual abuse occurred, the conduct wassufficiently " 'proximate in time to the derivative proceeding that it canreasonably be concluded that the condition still exist[ed]' " (Matter of Jeremiah I.W. [RogerH.W.], 115 AD3d 967, 969 [2014], quoting Matter of Elijah O. [Marilyn O.], 83 AD3d 1076, 1077[2011]; see Matter of Jamarra S.[Jessica S.], 85 AD3d 803, 804 [2011]; Matter of Baby Boy W., 283AD2d 584, 585 [2001]).
To the extent the appellant raises arguments related to the Family Court's subsequentorder of fact-finding and disposition dated August 22, 2014, those contentions are notproperly before this Court, as the appellant did not appeal from that order (seeCPLR 5515 [1]; Matter ofIdhailia P. [Philip S.P.], 95 AD3d 1333, 1335 [2012]). Chambers, J.P., Sgroi,Roman and Duffy, JJ., concur.