Matter of Newbill v Town of Hempstead
2017 NY Slip Op 01049 [147 AD3d 1191]
February 9, 2017
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 29, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Jeffrey Newbill, Appellant,
v
Town ofHempstead, Respondent. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

Grey & Grey, LLP, Farmingdale (Sanjai Doobay of counsel), for appellant.

Cherry, Edson & Kelly, LLP, Melville (David W. Faber of counsel), for Town ofHempstead, respondent.

Egan Jr., J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed October 26,2015, which ruled, among other things, that the employer was entitled to reimbursement forwages paid to claimant during the period of disability.

Claimant, a sanitation crew chief, injured his right ankle and foot when he slipped at work onAugust 15, 2013. His claim was later established and he was awarded disability benefits. Asrelevant here, the self-insured employer paid claimant his full weekly wages from August 16-17,2013 and from August 19, 2013 to September 25, 2013. In November 2013, the employer filed arequest for reimbursement for those time periods, attesting that it had paid claimant advancedwages of $8,218.80 during that time. The Workers' Compensation Law Judge determined thatclaimant had a permanent partial disability with a 20% schedule loss of use of his right foot,entitling him to 41 weeks of benefits totaling $32,931.61, less payments made. The Workers'Compensation Law Judge also granted the employer's request for reimbursement against thatschedule award for the $8,218.80 in wages paid to claimant. The Board affirmed, and claimantappeals.

We affirm. Workers' Compensation Law § 25 (4) (a) provides that, "[i]f theemployer has made advance payments of compensation, or has made payments to an employee inlike [*2]manner as wages during any period of disability, [theemployer] shall be entitled to be reimbursed out of an unpaid instal[l]ment or instal[l]ments ofcompensation due, provided [the employer's] claim for reimbursement is filed before [an] awardof compensation is made." "[R]eimbursement must be awarded to the employer unless suchreimbursement would achieve a disproportionate result, either to the employer or employee" (Matter of Mott v Central N.Y. PsychiatricCtr., 113 AD3d 911, 911 [2014] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]), whichpresents a question of fact for the Board (see Matter of Monteleone v Town of N. Castle, 73 AD3d 1422,1423 [2010]). Claimant does not dispute that the employer paid him wages for the period of hisdisability prior to the schedule award and that the employer filed a timely claim forreimbursement with the Board as required by Workers' Compensation Law § 25 (4)(a) (compare Matter of Iamiceli v American Tel. & Tel., 189 AD2d 1040,1040-1041 [1993]). Claimant challenges the Board's reimbursement directive upon the groundthat the reimbursement here covers a period of time when there were no awards of compensationmade,[FN*] arguing that, asa result, the employer is not entitled to reimbursement of wages paid to claimant during thoseperiods of time and that the amount of reimbursement should be reduced.

However, under settled law, where, as here, a claimant ultimately receives a schedule loss ofuse award, "an employer has the right to reimbursement for the full amount of wages paid duringa claimant's period of disability from the claimant's schedule award of worker[s'] compensationbenefits" (Matter of Hendrick v City of Albany Police Dept., 227 AD2d 808, 808 [1996];accord Matter of Burke v Verizon Servs.Group, 87 AD3d 1237, 1238 [2011]; Matter of Monteleone v Town of N. Castle,73 AD3d at 1423). Unlike an award of weekly compensation for a disability, which is based uponthe actual period during which an employee is disabled from earning full wages, liability for aschedule award arises as of the date of the accident, and the weekly rate and number of weeksspecified in the schedule are merely the measure by which the total amount of the award iscalculated; while the decisions often list the schedule award as covering certain dates, theschedule award "is not allocable to any particular period of disability" (Matter of LaCroix v Syracuse Exec. AirServ., Inc., 8 NY3d 348, 356 [2007] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Cruz v City of N.Y. Dept. ofChildren's Servs., 123 AD3d 1390, 1391 [2014], lv denied 26 NY3d 905 [2015])and is " 'independent of the time an employee actually loses from work' "(Matter of LaCroix v Syracuse Exec. Air Serv., Inc., 8 NY3d at 356, quoting Matterof Landgrebe v County of Westchester, 57 NY2d 1, 6 [1982]; see Workers'Compensation Law § 15 [3]; Matter of Briggs v Village of Hamilton, 136AD2d 442, 444 [1988]). Inasmuch as claimant received a schedule award compensating him forthe partial loss of use of his right foot, the Board was correct in finding that the employer wasentitled to full reimbursement out of that award for all of its advanced payment of wages toclaimant during that time (see Workers' Compensation Law § 25 [4] [a]).The fact that a temporary disability award was denied during part of that period based uponmissing medical evidence in the Board's record is not relevant to the employer's entitlement toreimbursement.

[*3] Peters, P.J., McCarthy, Roseand Mulvey, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Prior to the schedule award, theemployer was directed to make payments at a temporary total disability rate for specified periodsin 2013 and 2014. No compensation awards were made for the periods of August 16-17, 2013and August 19, 2013 to September 5, 2013 due to the lack of medical evidence. The employerlater requested reimbursement for the periods of August 16-17, 2013 and August 19-25, 2013,less one holiday, periods in which claimant was paid his full salary.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.