Matter of Nitti v County of Tioga
2017 NY Slip Op 02868 [149 AD3d 1332]
April 13, 2017
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 31, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Valerie Nitti, Petitioner,
v
County ofTioga et al., Respondents, et al., Respondents.

The Law Office of Ronald R. Benjamin, Binghamton (Ronald R. Benjamin of counsel), forpetitioner.

The Law Firm of Frank W. Miller, East Syracuse (Charles C. Spagnoli of counsel), forrespondents.

Rose, J. Combined proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 and action for declaratoryjudgment (transferred to this Court by order of the Supreme Court, entered in Tioga County) to,among other things, review a determination of respondents County of Tioga and Gail Bartonterminating petitioner's employment.

Petitioner was employed by respondent County of Tioga as the Director of Employment andTransitional Supports, an office in the County's Department of Social Services (hereinafter DSS).As part of her job duties, petitioner oversaw all of the County's public assistance programs,including the Medicaid program and fraud unit. In November 2013, DSS's Commissionerbrought disciplinary charges against petitioner alleging that she, among other things, made threefalse statements to a subordinate employee and to the Commissioner about her friend's Medicaidapplication. Following a Civil Service Law § 75 hearing, a Hearing Officer foundthat the evidence supported these specifications and recommended termination of petitioner'semployment. Respondent Gail Barton, DSS's Deputy Commissioner, adopted the HearingOfficer's findings and recommendations as to the three specifications and concluded thattermination of petitioner's employment was the appropriate penalty. Petitioner then commencedthis combined proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgmentseeking, among other things, to annul Barton's determination. Ultimately, the matter was [*2]transferred to this Court inasmuch as the petition/complaintarguably raised the issue of substantial evidence (see CPLR 7804 [g]). Petitioner hasabandoned that argument, however, by failing to raise it in her brief (see Matter of Macedonio v Annucci,142 AD3d 1215, 1215 n [2016]; Matter of Community Related Servs., Inc. v Carpenter-Palumbo, 84AD3d 1450, 1451 n [2011], lv denied 17 NY3d 717 [2011]).

Instead, petitioner contends that the Hearing Officer violated her due process rights byfinding her guilty of uncharged conduct, namely, that she deliberately committed fraud by tryingto obtain Medicaid benefits for her friend when she knew—and attempted toconceal—that the friend was not financially eligible for the benefits. While it is certainlytrue that a disciplinary hearing must be limited to the charges as made (see Matter of Murrayv Murphy, 24 NY2d 150, 157 [1969]; Mayo v Personnel Review Bd. of Health & Hosps. Corp., 65 AD3d470, 472-473 [2009]; Matter of Benson v Board of Educ. of Washingtonville Cent.School Dist., 183 AD2d 996, 997 [1992], lv denied 80 NY2d 756 [1992]), a reviewof the Hearing Officer's written recommendations reveals that, although he "note[d]" his beliefthat petitioner's intent was to submit a fraudulent Medicaid application given her friend's"obvious lack of financial eligibility," the ultimate recommendations of guilt were limited solelyto the evidence of petitioner's charged misconduct. In fact, the Hearing Officer made clear thathis findings of guilt were based upon the evidence that petitioner lied about who signed theMedicaid application and her "false representations" to her subordinate and the Commissioner. Inany event, a review of Barton's determination—which is the only determination that madean actual finding of guilt—demonstrates that Barton was careful to confine her findings ofguilt and rationale for terminating petitioner to the accusations as set forth in the notice ofcharges. Accordingly, we cannot agree with petitioner that she was found guilty based uponconduct outside the scope of the notice of charges (see Matter of Rounds v Town of Vestal, 15 AD3d 819, 822-823[2005]; compare Mayo v Personnel Review Bd. of Health & Hosps. Corp., 65 AD3dat 472-473; Matter of Brown v Saranac Lake Cent. School Dist., 273 AD2d 785, 785[2000]).

As to the penalty, in light of the responsibilities inherent in petitioner's high-level position inwhich she supervised approximately 45 employees, "[w]e do not find that termination ofpetitioner's employment is so disproportionate to the offense[s] as to be shocking to one's senseof fairness" (Matter of Bruso v ClintonCounty, 139 AD3d 1169, 1172 [2016]). The parties' remaining contentions concerningthe CPLR article 78 proceeding, to the extent that they have not been rendered academic by ourdecision, have been considered and determined to be lacking in merit. Finally, petitioner's requestfor declaratory relief is not authorized in a transferred proceeding pursuant to CPLR 7804 (g)and, therefore, that part of the matter must be remitted to Supreme Court for the entry of anappropriate judgment thereon (seeMatter of Ellison v Annucci, 142 AD3d 1233, 1234-1235 [2016]; Matter of Watson v New York State Dept.of Corr. & Community Supervision, 108 AD3d 817, 818 [2013], lvdismissed 22 NY3d 914 [2013], lv denied 23 NY3d 902 [2014]).

Peters, P.J., Lynch, Devine and Mulvey, JJ., concur. Adjudged that (1) the action fordeclaratory judgment is severed and said matter remitted to the Supreme Court for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision, and (2) the determination is confirmed,without costs, and petition dismissed to that extent.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.