Matter of Bruso v Clinton County
2016 NY Slip Op 03577 [139 AD3d 1169]
May 5, 2016
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 29, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of Zetra Bruso, Petitioner, v ClintonCounty et al., Respondents.

Steven A. Crain and Daren J. Rylewicz, Civil Service Employees Association,Albany (Aaron E. Kaplan of counsel), for petitioner.

Lemire, Johnson & Higgins, LLC, Malta (Bradley J. Stevens of counsel), forrespondents.

Clark, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (partially transferred to this Courtby order of the Supreme Court, entered in Clinton County) to review a determination ofrespondent County Administrator of the County of Clinton terminating petitioner'semployment.

Petitioner was employed by respondent Clinton County as a registered nurse atrespondent Clinton County Nursing Home. In December 2012, the administrator of thenursing home brought charges against petitioner pursuant to Civil Service Law§ 75. At a hearing on those charges, petitioner attempted to admit intoevidence a "Medication and Treatment Misadventures Form" (hereinafter the form), aninternal quality assurance document used by the nursing home to identify and addresserrors in medicating its residents, as well as a resident's narcotics prescription that wasattached to the form. As a result, in April 2013, the administrator of the nursing homebrought two additional charges against petitioner, which included three specifications ofalleged misconduct and incompetence. As relevant here, petitioner was alleged to haveknowingly possessed the form and the attached prescription without authorization fromthe nursing home.

Following a hearing on the April 2013 charges, a Hearing Officer found that all threespecifications were supported by substantial evidence and recommended termination ofpetitioner's employment. Respondent Michael E. Zurlo, the Clinton CountyAdministrator, accepted the Hearing Officer's findings and recommendation andconcluded that termination of [*2]petitioner'semployment was the appropriate penalty.[FN*] Petitioner then commenced thisproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 seeking, among other things, to annul Zurlo'sdetermination. Supreme Court dismissed two of the specifications as untimely underCivil Service Law § 75 (4) and transferred the proceeding to this Court(see CPLR 7804 [g]).

We first address petitioner's argument that the determination should be annulledbecause the Hearing Officer was biased. "Because hearing officers are presumed to befree from bias, an appearance of impropriety is insufficient to set aside an administrativedetermination; [the] petitioner must provide factual support for his [or her] claim of biasand prove that the outcome flowed from that bias" (Matter of Compasso v Sheriff of Sullivan County, 29 AD3d1064, 1065 [2006]; accordMatter of Zlotnick v City of Saratoga Springs, 122 AD3d 1210, 1212-1213[2014]). Although the Hearing Officer presided over the hearing on the December 2012charges, petitioner failed to overcome the presumption and establish that the HearingOfficer prejudged the matter (see Matter of Compasso v Sheriff of SullivanCounty, 29 AD3d at 1065). We are similarly unpersuaded by petitioner's contentionthat the Hearing Officer improperly considered evidence outside of the record.

Additionally, we are satisfied that Zurlo's determination was independent and fullyinformed. In evaluating whether an administrative determination is informed, courtsaccord the determination a presumption of regularity and will not disturb it absent "aclear revelation that the administrative body made no independent appraisal and reachedno independent conclusion" (Matter of Taub v Pirnie, 3 NY2d 188, 195 [1957][internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Monahan v Delaware-Chenango-Madison-Otsego Bd.of Coop. Educ. Servs., 27 AD3d 995, 996 [2006]; Matter of Nehorayoff vFernandez, 191 AD2d 833, 835 [1993]). The record reveals that the hearingtranscript and exhibits were made available to Zurlo and that he reviewed the posthearingbriefs submitted by the parties, as well as the findings, conclusions and recommendationof the Hearing Officer. Contrary to petitioner's assertion, Zurlo was not required to readthe entirety of the hearing transcript (see Matter of Perryman v Village of Saranac Lake, 64 AD3d830, 835-836 [2009];Matter of McKinney v Bennett, 31 AD3d 860, 861 [2006]).

As for petitioner's challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence supporting Zurlo'sdetermination that petitioner was guilty of the remaining charge, our standard of reviewis whether the determination is supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Longton v Village ofCorinth, 57 AD3d 1273, 1274 [2008], lv denied 13 NY3d 709 [2009];Matter of Agnew v NorthColonie Cent. School Dist., 14 AD3d 830, 831 [2005]). "[T]his Court will not'second guess the credibility determinations of the administrative factfinder' "(Matter of McKinney v [*3]Bennett, 31 AD3d at861, quoting Matter of StephenFF. v Johnson, 23 AD3d 977, 978 [2005]; see Matter of Perryman v Villageof Saranac Lake, 64 AD3d at 835).

Here, it is undisputed that the form and the attached prescription containedconfidential information relating to one of the nursing home's residents, including theresident's name, address, provider and prescribed medication. The administrator of thenursing home and a staff nurse testified that they were unable to locate the original formand that they had not given petitioner permission to remove the document from thenursing home. Although petitioner's former attorney testified that the administrator gavehim a file of documents and that the form was included in that file, the administratoraffirmatively testified that she reviewed the contents of the file before turning it over topetitioner's attorney and that the form was not in it. Additionally, petitioner's attorneyadmitted that page two of the form was not included in the file and that petitionerprovided that page to him later. Further, the parties jointly admitted into evidenceportions of petitioner's testimony at the hearing on the December 2012 charges in whichshe gave varying accounts as to how she came into possession of the form. In oneversion, petitioner testified that the form was not produced by the nursing home inresponse to her document requests and that she kept the form for herself. This evidencepresented a credibility issue for the Hearing Officer, one that she resolved in favor ofrespondents. Accepting the credibility determinations of the administrative factfinder, weconclude that substantial evidence supports the determination that petitioner knowinglypossessed the form and the attached prescription without permission in violation of thenursing home's policies. We do not find that termination of petitioner's employment is sodisproportionate to the offense as to be shocking to one's sense of fairness (see Matter of Conde v Kelly,118 AD3d 534, 535-536 [2014]).

To the extent that petitioner's arguments have not been expressly addressed herein,we have examined them and found them to be without merit.

Garry, J.P., Egan Jr., Lynch and Devine, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinationis confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote *:At the time of thisdetermination, Zurlo had already concluded that petitioner was guilty of several of theDecember 2012 charges and terminated her employment. We note that, in a decisiondecided herewith (Matter of Bruso v County of Clinton, 139 AD3d 1169 [2016]), we concluded that, at the time of his determination of the December 2012charges, Zurlo was not authorized to review the record and the Hearing Officer'srecommendation and render a determination on those charges. However, the sameconcern is not present here, as Zurlo was vested with the power to review the presentrecord and render a determination on the April 2013 charges at the time that he did so.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.