| Matter of Haverstraw Owners Professionals & Entrepreneurs("H.O.P.E.") v Town of Ramapo Zoning Bd. of Appeals |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 04442 [151 AD3d 724] |
| June 7, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Haverstraw Owners Professionals andEntrepreneurs ("H.O.P.E.") et al., Appellants, v Town of Ramapo Zoning Board ofAppeals, by Charlene Weaver, as Chairperson, Respondent. Mt. Ivy Partners, LLC, NonpartyRespondent. |
Stepanovich Law, PLC, Nanuet, NY (Stephen Cole-Hatchard of counsel), for appellants.
Michael Klein, Town Attorney, Suffern, NY (Michael Specht of counsel), for respondent,and Freeman & Loftus, RLLP, New City, NY (Ira M. Emanuel of counsel), fornonparty-respondent (one brief filed).
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Town ofRamapo Zoning Board of Appeals dated October 25, 2012, which, after a hearing, granted theapplication of Mt. Ivy Partners, LLC, for several area variances, the petitioners appeal from ajudgment of the Supreme Court, Rockland County (Loehr, J.), dated March 31, 2015, whichdenied the petition and dismissed the proceeding.
Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, with costs.
At a public meeting held on October 25, 2012, the Town of Ramapo Zoning Board ofAppeals (hereinafter the Board), after two public hearings, adopted a resolution granting theapplication of Mt. Ivy Partners, LLC (hereinafter Mt. Ivy), for several area variances. Thereafter,the petitioners commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review thedetermination, alleging that because there was no public discussion, deliberation, orconsideration by the Board at the meeting before it adopted the proposed resolution, the Boardviolated the Open Meetings Law (see Public Officers Law § 100 etseq.).
The Supreme Court properly denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding. "In enactingthe Open Meetings Law, the Legislature sought to ensure that 'public business be performed in anopen and public manner and that the citizens of this state be fully aware of and able to observethe performance of public officials and attend and listen to the deliberations and decisions that gointo the making of public policy' " (Matter of Perez v City Univ. of N.Y., 5 NY3d 522, 528 [2005],quoting Public Officers Law § 100). The term "Meeting" is defined as "the officialconvening of a public body for the purpose of conducting public business" (Public Officers Law§ 102 [1]). "The statute does not apply only to formal or regular meetings, but toany gathering or meeting of a quorum of a public body for the purpose of transacting publicbusiness" (Matter of Tri-Village Publs. v St. Johnsville Bd. of Educ., 110 AD2d 932, 933[1985]; see Public Officers Law § 102 [2]).
[*2] The petitioners failed to satisfy their burden of establishingthat the Board violated the Open Meetings Law in adopting the October 25, 2012, resolutiongranting Mt. Ivy's application for area variances (see Matter of Halperin v City of New Rochelle, 24 AD3d 768, 777[2005]; Matter of Ramapo HomeownersAssn. v Town of Ramapo, 2 AD3d 529 [2003]; Mobil Oil Corp. v City of SyracuseIndus. Dev. Agency, 224 AD2d 15, 30 [1996]). The Board conducted two public hearings onthe subject of the area variances. Between the close of the public hearing and the next publicmeeting at which the subject determination was made, the Board's counsel prepared a draftwritten determination. At the public meeting on October 25, the Board considered the proposeddraft and ultimately made a determination. The petitioners do not allege or present any evidencethat a quorum met or consulted with its counsel outside of a public meeting, or that thesediscussions, if any, were part of an effort to thwart public scrutiny of their process in deliberateviolation of the Open Meetings Law (see Matter of MCI Telecom. Corp. v Public Serv.Commn. of State of N.Y., 231 AD2d 284, 290-291 [1997]; Mobil Oil Corp. v City ofSyracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 224 AD2d at 30). Accordingly, no violation of the OpenMeetings Law occurred (see Public Officers Law § 102 [1]; Matter of Gedney Assn. v City of WhitePlains, 147 AD3d 938, 938 [2017]; Matter of Braunstein v Board of Zoning Appeals of the Town ofCopake, 100 AD3d 1091 [2012]; Matter of Tri-Village Publs. v St. Johnsville Bd. ofEduc., 110 AD2d 932 [1985]). Dillon, J.P., Cohen, Duffy and Connolly, JJ., concur.