Matter of Shapiro v Torres
2017 NY Slip Op 06281 [153 AD3d 835]
August 23, 2017
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 27, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Bernard Shapiro et al.,Appellants,
v
Len Torres et al., Respondents.

Jaspan Schlesinger LLP, Garden City, NY (Maureen T. Liccione and Robert V. Guido ofcounsel), for petitioners/plaintiffs-appellants.

Robert Agostini, Corporation Counsel, Long Beach, NY, and Forchelli, Curto, Deegan,Schwartz, Mineo & Terrana, LLP, Uniondale, NY (Jeffrey D. Forchelli, William F.Bonesso, Richard A. Blumberg, and Danielle E. Tricolla of counsel), forrespondents/defendants-respondents (one brief filed).

In a hybrid proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, inter alia, to review a determination ofthe City Council of the City of Long Beach dated March 3, 2015, to award contracts for theconstruction of comfort stations along the City of Long Beach boardwalk, and action for ajudgment declaring that the construction of a structure known as the Lincoln Boulevard ComfortStation is a prohibited use of a public street and related injunctive relief, the petitioners/plaintiffsappeal, as limited by their brief, from so much of an order and judgment (one paper) of theSupreme Court, Nassau County (Mahon, J.), entered September 25, 2015, as, upon denying theirmotion for a preliminary injunction, in effect, determined that the construction of the structureknown as the Lincoln Boulevard Comfort Station is not a prohibited use of a public street, deniedthe petition, and dismissed the hybrid proceeding/action.

Ordered that the order and judgment is modified, on the law, by deleting the provisionthereof, in effect, dismissing the action, and adding thereto a provision declaring that theconstruction of the structure known as the Lincoln Boulevard Comfort Station is a permitted useof a public street; as so modified, the order and judgment is affirmed insofar as appealed from,with costs to the respondents/defendants.

In this hybrid proceeding and action, the petitioners/plaintiffs (hereinafter the petitioners)sought, inter alia, to review a determination of the City of Long Beach to award contracts for theconstruction of comfort stations along the city boardwalk as part of a plan to reconstruct theboardwalk and restroom facilities that had been destroyed by Hurricane Sandy. The comfortstation at issue would be installed in a "bump out" that extended into the southern end of LincolnBoulevard, opposite the ocean side of the boardwalk, adjacent to the petitioners' condominiumcomplex. The petitioners alleged that the City violated the mandates of the State EnvironmentalQuality Review Act (ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) and article 17 of the Charter of the City ofLong Beach (Charter of City of Long Beach § 330 [6]) and interfered with theireasement of light, air, and access. The Supreme Court, upon denying the petitioners' motion for apreliminary [*2]injunction, in effect, determined that theconstruction is not a prohibited use of a public street, denied the petition, and dismissed thehybrid proceeding and action. The petitioners appeal, and we modify.

"To establish standing under SEQRA, a petitioner must show (1) an environmental injurythat is in some way different from that of the public at large, and (2) that the alleged injury fallswithin the zone of interests sought to be protected or promoted by SEQRA" (Matter of Brummel v Town of N.Hempstead Town Bd., 145 AD3d 880, 881-882 [2016]). The alleged harm cannot be"too speculative and conjectural to demonstrate an actual and specific injury-in-fact" (Matter of Kindred v Monroe County,119 AD3d 1347, 1348 [2014]). Close proximity alone is insufficient to confer standingwhere there are no zoning issues involved, and general environmental concerns will not suffice(see Matter of Sun-Brite Car Wash v Board of Zoning & Appeals of Town of N.Hempstead, 69 NY2d 406, 410 [1987]; Matter of Kindred v Monroe County, 119 AD3d 1347 [2014];Matter of Save Our Main St. Bldgs. v Greene County Legislature, 293 AD2d 907 [2002];Matter of Oates v Village of Watkins Glen, 290 AD2d 758, 761 [2002]). Moreover, "[t]oqualify for standing to raise a SEQRA challenge, a party must demonstrate that it will suffer aninjury that is environmental and not solely economic in nature" (Matter of Mobil Oil Corp. vSyracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 76 NY2d 428, 433 [1990]). Here, the petitioners' allegedenvironmentally related injuries are too speculative and conjectural to demonstrate an actual andspecific injury-in-fact (see Matter of Brummel v Town of N. Hempstead Town Bd., 145AD3d at 881-882; Matter of Shelter Is.Assn. v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Shelter Is., 57 AD3d 907 [2008]).

"When lands adjoin private property an easement of light, air and access over such. . . property does not exist, under ordinary circumstances, merely because of theproximity of the lands to the private property" (St. Peter's Italian Church Syracuse v State ofNew York, 261 App Div 96, 97 [1941]). However, an owner of land abutting a highway orstreet possesses, as incident to his or her ownership, easements of light, air, and access,irrespective of whether the owner owns the fee of the highway or the street itself (see Matterof Scoglio v County of Suffolk, 85 NY2d 709, 712 [1995]; Regan v Lanze, 40 NY2d475, 482 [1976]; Donahue v Keystone Gas Co., 181 NY 313, 316 [1905]; Lahr vMetropolitan El. Ry. Co., 104 NY 268, 291 [1887]; Griefer v County of Sullivan,246 App Div 385 [1936], affd 273 NY 515 [1937]). Nevertheless, "[w]hen the fee of thehighway has been transferred to the State, the State may use the highway for any public purposenot inconsistent with or prejudicial to its use for highway purposes . . . [and] [t]hemere disturbance of the rights of light, air and access of abutting owners on such a highway bythe imposition of a new use, consistent with its use as an open public street, must be tolerated bythem and no right of action arises therefrom, although such use interferes with the enjoyment ofthe premises" (Perlmutter v Greene, 259 NY 327, 299-330 [1932] [citation omitted];see Sauer v City of New York, 206 US 536, 547-548 [1907]; Jones Beach Blvd.Estate, Inc. v Moses, 268 NY 362, 368 [1935]; Lahr v Metropolitan El. Ry. Co., 104NY at 291; Aero Drive-In v Town of Cheektowaga, 140 AD2d 932 [1988]). For example,the maintenance of trees on a street for the purposes of ornament and shade has been determinedto be a proper street use (see Donahue v Keystone Gas Co., 181 NY at 315).

Here, the proposed construction will not completely block the petitioners' ocean view norprevent the petitioners from using the public street. Rather, the length of the dead-end street willbe shortened and several public parking spaces will be removed. The turnaround will still beintact, although moved 23 feet to the north, and access to the petitioners' driveway and building'sentrance will not be impeded (see Perlmutter v Greene, 259 NY at 333). In addition, thedisputed comfort station will be open to, and for the purpose of, serving the public (cf.Peterson v City of New York, 260 NY 156, 161 [1932]).

Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly, in effect, determined that the construction is not aprohibited use of a public street, denied the petition, and dismissed the proceeding. Since this is,in part, a declaratory judgment action, the order and judgment should have included a provisiondeclaring that the construction is a permitted use of a public street (see Lanza v Wagner,11 NY2d 317 [1962]).

The petitioners' remaining contentions have been rendered academic by our determination.Rivera, J.P., Hall, Barros and Brathwaite Nelson, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.