Matter of Thomas v Town of Southeast, N.Y.
2019 NY Slip Op 00446 [168 AD3d 955]
January 23, 2019
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 6, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Timothy Thomas, Petitioner,
v
Townof Southeast, New York, Respondent.

Wolin & Wolin, Jericho, NY (Alan E. Wolin of counsel), for petitioner.

Gaines, Novick, Ponzini, Cossu & Venditti, LLP, White Plains, NY (Denise M. Cossuand James A. Randazzo of counsel), for respondent.

Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Town Board of therespondent, Town of Southeast, New York, dated December 11, 2015. The determinationadopted the findings of a hearing officer dated December 8, 2015, made after a hearing pursuantto Civil Service Law § 75, that the petitioner was guilty of certain charges ofmisconduct, and terminated the petitioner's employment as a road maintenance equipmentoperator.

Adjudged that the determination is confirmed, the petition is denied, and the proceeding isdismissed on the merits, with costs.

The petitioner was employed by the Highway Department (hereinafter the highwaydepartment) of the respondent, the Town of Southeast, New York, as a road maintenanceequipment operator. The petitioner was accused of committing various acts of misconduct overthe course of approximately 10 months from March 2014 through January 2015. The allegationsincluded multiple instances of disobeying the orders of a superior, including one instance inwhich the petitioner's failure to follow the directions of the highway department Superintendent(hereinafter the superintendent) allegedly placed the petitioner, a coworker, and the generalpublic in danger; being absent from work for two days without obtaining prior approval; andthreatening and physically confronting the superintendent on January 16, 2015, in the garage ofthe highway department.

The petitioner was charged with 12 counts of misconduct. At an administrative hearing, thepetitioner denied the charges alleged. The superintendent and multiple highway departmentemployees testified, and camera surveillance footage, as well as audio recorded by the petitioner,were admitted as evidence. At the conclusion of the hearing, the hearing officer found thepetitioner guilty of charges 4, 5, 6, 8, 11, and 12. He recommended termination of the petitioner'semployment given the nature of the incidents, the petitioner's lack of credibility and lack ofremorse, and his previous disciplinary suspension of five days for harassing a co-worker andimproper performance of his duties, as well as previous reprimands. The Town Board adoptedthe hearing officer's report and recommendation and terminated the petitioner's employment. Thepetitioner thereafter commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review theTown's determination.

In an employee disciplinary case, judicial review of factual findings made after a hearingpursuant to Civil Service Law § 75 is limited to consideration of whether thatdetermination was supported by substantial evidence (see CPLR 7803 [4]; 300Gramatan Ave. Assoc. v State Div. of Human Rights, 45 NY2d 176, 179-180 [1978]; Matter of Owens v County of Dutchess,162 AD3d 1040, 1041 [2018]; Matter of Harris v City of Poughkeepsie, 162 AD3d 663, 665[2018]; Matter of Argenti v Town ofRiverhead, 131 AD3d 1053, 1054 [2015]). "When there is conflicting evidence ordifferent inferences may be drawn, 'the duty of weighing the evidence and making the choicerests solely upon the [administrative agency]. The courts may not weigh the evidence or reject thechoice made by [such agency] where the evidence is conflicting and room for choiceexists' " (Matter of Grimaldi vGough, 114 AD3d 679, 680 [2014], quoting Matter of Berenhaus v Ward, 70NY2d 436, 444 [1987]). Here, any credibility issues were resolved by the hearing officer (see Matter of Reed v Raynor, 151AD3d 730, 730 [2017]), and substantial evidence in the record supports the determinationthat the petitioner was guilty of the misconduct alleged in charges 4, 5, 6, 8, 11, and 12 (seeMatter of Owens v County of Dutchess, 162 AD3d at 1041; Matter of Harris v City ofPoughkeepsie, 162 AD3d at 665).

A court may set aside an administrative penalty only if it is so disproportionate to the offenseas to be shocking to one's sense of fairness (see Matter of Waldren v Town of Islip, 6 NY3d 735, 736 [2005];Matter of Harris v City of Poughkeepsie, 162 AD3d at 665). "That reasonable mindsmight disagree over what the proper penalty should have been does not provide a basis for. . . refashioning the penalty" (City School Dist. of the City of N.Y. v McGraham, 17 NY3d 917,920 [2011]; see Matter of Bolt v NewYork City Dept. of Educ., 30 NY3d 1065, 1068 [2018]). Here, the penalty of dismissalis not so disproportionate to the offenses as to be shocking to one's sense of fairness, especially inlight of the number of incidents and the petitioner's prior disciplinary record (see Matter ofArgenti v Town of Riverhead, 131 AD3d at 1054; Matter of Lauria v County ofDutchess, 306 AD2d 532, 532 [2003]).

The petitioner's remaining contention is without merit. Scheinkman, P.J., Leventhal, Malteseand Brathwaite Nelson, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.