Matter of Town of Irondequoit v County of Monroe
2019 NY Slip Op 06235 [175 AD3d 846]
August 22, 2019
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, October 2, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Town of Irondequoit et al.,Respondents,
v
County of Monroe et al., Appellants.

Michael E. Davis, County Attorney, Rochester (Matthew D. Brown of counsel), forrespondents-defendants-appellants.

Harter Secrest & Emery LLP, Rochester (Edward F. Premo, II, of counsel), forpetitioner-plaintiff-respondent Town of Irondequoit.

Gordon & Schaal, LLP, Rochester (Kenneth W. Gordon of counsel), forpetitioner-plaintiff-respondent Town of Brighton.

Sarah B. Brancatella, Associate counsel, Albany, for State of New York Association ofTowns, amicus curiae.

Appeal from a judgment (denominated order and judgment) of the Supreme Court, MonroeCounty (J. Scott Odorisi, J.), entered November 9, 2017, in a CPLR article 78 proceeding and adeclaratory judgment action. The judgment denied the motion of respondents-defendants todismiss the petition-complaint and granted the petition-complaint.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is reversed on the law without costs,the motion is granted, and the petition-complaint is dismissed.

Memorandum: Respondents-defendants (County respondents) appeal in this hybrid CPLRarticle 78 proceeding and declaratory judgment action from a judgment that, inter alia, grantedthe petition-complaint of petitioners-plaintiffs (Town petitioners), denied the Countyrespondents' motion to dismiss the petition-complaint, compelled the County respondents toguarantee and credit the maintenance, repair, and demolition charges assessed by the Townpetitioners on certain properties located within their boundaries (maintenance charges), anddeclared that the County respondents are legally obligated to guarantee and credit those charges.We reverse.

As a preliminary matter, we note that this is properly only a CPLR article 78 proceedinginasmuch as the relief sought by the Town petitioners is available under CPLR article 78 withoutthe necessity of a declaration (see generally CPLR 7801; Matter of Level 3 Communications, LLC vChautauqua County, 148 AD3d 1702, 1703 [4th Dept 2017], lv denied 30 NY3d913 [2018]).

We further conclude that the County respondents failed to preserve their constitutionalchallenge to the local laws of the Town petitioners inasmuch as they failed to raise that challengein Supreme Court (see Matter of Townof Rye v New York State Bd. of Real Prop. Servs., 10 NY3d 793, 795 [2008]). Weagree with the County respondents, however, that RPTL 936 does not require them to credit theTown petitioners for the amount of the unpaid maintenance charges or to guarantee thoseamounts.

With respect to the maintenance charges, Town Law § 64 (5-a) provides that atown may "require the owners of land to cut, trim or remove from the land owned by them brush,grass, rubbish, or weeds, or to spray poisonous shrubs or weeds on such land." If a landownerfails to comply, the town may perform such work and place a "lien and charge" on the realproperty for the "total expense" incurred by the town for that work (id.). Pursuant toTown Law § 130 (16), towns are also permitted to "[p]rovid[e] for the removal orrepair of buildings in business, industrial and residential sections that, from any cause, may nowbe or shall hereafter become dangerous or unsafe" and to assess the cost of such service againstthe land on which the building is situated (see § 130 [16] [g]).

Section 936 (1) of the RPTL provides that the county guarantees the town's "taxes" bycrediting the town "with the amount of . . . unpaid delinquent taxes." The questionraised on this appeal is whether the maintenance charges are "taxes" for the purposes of RPTL936 and thus whether the County respondents must credit the Town petitioners for the amount ofany such charge that goes unpaid or is delinquent.

The maintenance charges are assessed against individual properties for their benefit and thusdo not fall within the general definition of "tax," which instead contemplates " 'publicburdens imposed generally for governmental purposes benefiting the entire community' "(Matter of Piccolo v New York StateTax Appeals Trib., 108 AD3d 107, 112 [3d Dept 2013]; see Watergate II Apts. vBuffalo Sewer Auth., 46 NY2d 52, 58 [1978]; see generally RPTL 102 [20]). Nor dothose charges constitute "special ad valorem levies" as defined by RPTL 102 (14). A" '[s]pecial ad valorem levy' " is "a charge imposed upon benefited real propertyin the same manner and at the same time as taxes for municipal purposes to defray the cost,including operation and maintenance, of a special district improvement or service" (id.).Although the definition of "tax" does, in certain enumerated circumstances, include "special advalorem levies" (RPTL 102 [20]), the maintenance charges are not special ad valorem leviesbecause they are not used to defray the cost of a "special district improvement or service" (RPTL102 [14]). Maintenance charges also are not assessed "ad valorem" because the amount of thecharge is not based on property value but is instead based on the actual expense to the town.Moreover, assuming, arguendo, that the charges are "special assessments" as defined by RPTL102 (15), we note that the definition of "tax" specifically excludes "special assessments" (RPTL102 [20]).

We further agree with the County respondents that section 10 of the Monroe County Tax Actdoes not expand the County respondents' obligations under RPTL 936, i.e., it does not requirethem to guarantee or credit the maintenance charges. Additionally, although Municipal HomeRule Law § 10 (1) permits towns to collect the maintenance charges, we disagreewith the Town petitioners that the Municipal Home Rule Law renders those charges "taxes"under RPTL 936. Similarly, although Irondequoit Town Code §§ 94-9 and104-14 provide that the maintenance charges shall be "collected in the same manner" as othertown charges and special ad valorem levies, that describes the procedure for collecting thecharges and does not address whether they must be guaranteed pursuant to RPTL 936.

All concur except NeMoyer and Troutman, JJ., who dissent in part and vote to modify inaccordance with the following memorandum.

NeMoyer and Troutman, JJ. (dissenting in part). We respectfully dissent in part. We agreewith the majority that this is properly only a CPLR article 78 proceeding. Unlike the majority,however, we conclude that, when a town exercises its statutory authority to assess maintenance,repair, and demolition charges against real property (see Town Law§§ 64 [5-a]; 130 [16]), such charges must be guaranteed by the county "in thesame manner" as property taxes and special ad valorem levies (§ 64 [5-a]; seegenerally RPTL 936). Therefore, we would modify the judgment by dismissing thepetition-complaint insofar as it seeks declaratory relief and by vacating the declaration, and wewould otherwise affirm.

A brief overview of New York State's property tax collection scheme is necessary tounderstand the issue. Under that scheme, the county guarantees the town's property taxes andcredits the town with the amount of any "unpaid delinquent taxes" (RPTL 936 [1]). In turn, thecounty retains the sole power to commence tax foreclosure proceedings against real property"which remain[s] subject to delinquent tax liens" (RPTL 1123 [1]). The power to foreclose hasits advantages. A county, for example, may "take title to privately-held property for thenonpayment of property taxes even where the taxes owing represent only a small fraction of thevalue of the land," and may thereby "realize a substantial windfall" in a tax foreclosureproceeding (Matter of Foreclosure ofTax Liens, 165 AD3d 1112, 1122 [2d Dept 2018]; see RPTL 1100 etseq.). The statute thus incorporates a trade-off. The town lacks recourse against defaulters,but is guaranteed to recover its delinquent taxes from the county. The county accepts thedeficiency, but may reap a windfall in collecting delinquent taxes.

The question here is whether the definition of "delinquent taxes" encompasses maintenance,repair, and demolition charges assessed by a town against real property (see Town Law§§ 64 [5-a]; 130 [16]). We agree with the majority that such charges are,strictly speaking, not taxes. Rather, they are more appropriately classified as " '[s]pecialassessment[s]' " (RPTL 102 [15]; see generally Lane v City of Mount Vernon, 38NY2d 344, 347-348 [1976]), which are excluded from the strict definition of a "tax" (RPTL 102[20]).

The RPTL, however, expressly contemplates that special assessments, under somecircumstances, are to be treated as taxes for purposes of property tax collection. The term"delinquent tax," when used in article 11 of the RPTL, entitled "Procedures for Enforcement ofCollection of Delinquent Taxes," includes an unpaid "special assessment or other charge imposedupon real property by or on behalf of a municipal corporation . . . relating to anyparcel which is included in the return of unpaid delinquent taxes prepared pursuant to [RPTL936]" (RPTL 1102 [2]). Moreover, special assessments may be used to finance publicimprovements (see Town Law § 231 et seq.) and, if the town isunable to collect such assessments, the tax roll listing the unpaid assessments is then transmittedto the county "and collection thereof shall be enforced in the manner provided by law for thecollection of unpaid town taxes" (§ 243). Likewise, maintenance, repair, anddemolition charges are to be "collected in the same manner and at the same time as other towncharges" (§ 64 [5-a]). Indeed, counsel for the State Board of Equalization andAssessment, citing the same provisions, opined long ago that maintenance, repair, and demolitioncharges assessed by the town against real property are "in the same nature" as taxes, and thus theyare guaranteed by the county pursuant to RPTL 936 (9 Ops Counsel SBEA No. 55 [1990]). Thathas been the law in this State for decades.

If the rule proposed by the majority were to stand, towns would almost never be able torecoup their costs for maintaining, repairing, or demolishing blighted properties. Although thelegislature has given towns the power to place a "lien and charge" on real property for the "totalexpense" of performing such necessary work (Town Law § 64 [5-a]; see§ 130 [16] [g]), in practice, towns would lack the ability to enforce the liens orcollect the charges from defaulting owners, forcing the towns to accept the deficiency. In ourview, such a rule is not consistent with the statutory scheme, nor is it consistent with historicalpractices, nor is it good policy. Present—Centra, J.P., Peradotto, Carni, NeMoyer andTroutman, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.