People v Maslowski
2020 NY Slip Op 06146 [187 AD3d 1211]
October 28, 2020
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 4, 2019


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Appellant,
v
Bartosz Maslowski, Respondent.

Melinda Katz, District Attorney, Kew Gardens, NY (John M. Castellano, Joseph N.Ferdenzi, and Edward D. Saslow of counsel), for appellant.

Janet E. Sabel, New York, NY (Jonathan Garelick of counsel), for respondent.

Appeal by the People from an order of the Supreme Court, Queens County (Ronald D.Hollie, J.), dated August 3, 2018, which granted the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 30.30 todismiss the indictment on the ground that he was deprived of his statutory right to a speedytrial.

Ordered that the order is affirmed.

On August 5, 2016, the defendant was arraigned on a misdemeanor complaint charging himwith assault in the third degree (Penal Law § 120.00 [1]), a class A misdemeanor,and harassment in the second degree (Penal Law § 240.26 [1]), a violation. Thecomplaint was signed by a detective and alleged that the detective "[was] informed by thecomplainant . . . that [on May 15, 2016,] the defendant . . . did punchand kick [the complainant] about the face and body causing bruises." On August 26, 2016, thePeople filed a statement of readiness and a supporting deposition of the complainant, indicatingthat he had "read the accusatory instrument . . . and that the facts therein stated to beon information furnished by [him] are true upon [his] personal knowledge." On January 26,2017, the People filed a superseding misdemeanor complaint together with a certificate oftranslation, stating that on January 26, 2017, the complaint and the supporting deposition weretranslated to the complainant in Polish.

The defendant subsequently moved pursuant to CPL 30.30 to dismiss the accusatoryinstrument on the ground that the People failed "to file a valid information with non-hearsay"within 90 days of the commencement of the action (see CPL 30.30 [1] [b]). Thedefendant argued, among other things, that the complainant's supporting deposition wasinsufficient to convert the misdemeanor complaint into an information without an accompanyingcertificate of translation and that, therefore, the People's statement of readiness, made prior toJanuary 26, 2017, was illusory. The People opposed the motion, arguing that a certificate oftranslation was not necessary to convert the complaint into an information and that thesupporting deposition was facially sufficient inasmuch as there was no indication within the fourcorners of the instrument that the complainant had not read or understood it.

In an order dated November 30, 2017, the Criminal Court granted the defendant's motion,concluding that 118 days were chargeable to the People for the period between August 5, 2016,the date of the defendant's arraignment, and January 26, 2017, the date the supersedingmisdemeanor complaint and certificate of translation were filed, plus an additional day for a totalof 119 days, which exceeded the 90-day speedy trial period under CPL 30.30 (1) (b) (seeCPL 30.30 [1] [b]; People vMaslowski, 58 Misc 3d 592 [Crim Ct, Queens County 2017]). In reaching thatdetermination, the court found that "every allegation of the initial accusatory instrument washearsay" and that a certificate of translation "was a necessary prerequisite for conversion of the[complaint] to an information." The court stated that, "in later filing a [certificate of translation]along with a superseding information, the People conceded their actual knowledge, andconstructive knowledge since the start of this prosecution, that the complainant was incapable ofconfirming the veracity and accuracy of the English-written hearsay allegations attributed to himin the accusatory instrument without the benefit of a Polish translation." The court alsoemphasized that a complaint filed with the New York City Police Department regarding theincident, as well as the complainant's hospital records, indicated that the complainant spokePolish, was not proficient in English, and required an interpreter, thus "underscor[ing] thePeople's constructive knowledge of the complainant's lack of proficiency in English."

The People did not file an appeal from that order but, instead, presented the case to a grandjury, which returned an indictment charging the defendant with assault in the second degree, aclass D felony. The defendant was arraigned on the indictment on January 31, 2018.

Thereafter, the defendant filed a second motion pursuant to CPL 30.30 to dismiss theindictment, arguing that a total of 196 days were chargeable to the People since August 5, 2016,the date the first accusatory instrument was filed, which exceeded the six-month statutory speedytrial period applicable to felonies (see CPL 30.30 [1] [a]). The People opposed themotion, arguing that, at most, they were chargeable with a total of 105 days since August 5,2016, and that the Criminal Court "erroneously charged the People with 118 days of 30.30 timebased on failing to file a supporting deposition with a certificate of translation."

By order dated August 3, 2018, the Supreme Court granted the defendant's motion, finding,in relevant part, that the prior determination of the Criminal Court was "the law of the case," andthat the People were also chargeable with an additional 77 days, for a total of 196 days, whichexceeded the speedy trial time allotted under CPL 30.30 (1) (a). On appeal, the People challengethe Supreme Court's application of the law of the case doctrine, and the determination that theywere chargeable for the period between August 26, 2016, and January 26, 2017.

"Law of the case is a judicially crafted policy that expresses the practice of courts generallyto refuse to reopen what has been decided, [and is] not a limit to their power. As such, law of thecase is necessarily amorphous in that it directs a court's discretion, but does not restrict itsauthority" (People v Cummings, 31NY3d 204, 208 [2018] [internal quotation marks omitted]; see People v Evans, 94NY2d 499, 504 [2000]). "To be sure, 'the law of the case doctrine is designed to eliminate theinefficiency and disorder that would follow if courts of coordinate jurisdiction were free tooverrule one another in an ongoing case' " (People v Cummings, 31 NY3d at 208,quoting People v Evans, 94 NY2d at 504). The doctrine " 'contemplates that theparties had a "full and fair" opportunity to litigate the initial determination' " and"serves as 'a concept regulating pre-judgment rulings made by courts of coordinatejurisdiction in a single litigation' " (People v Bilsky, 95 NY2d 172, 175 [2000],quoting People v Evans, 94 NY2d at 502, 503). Contrary to the People's contention, itwas not an improvident exercise of discretion for the Supreme Court to apply the law of the casedoctrine and decline to reconsider the issue of whether the People were chargeable with 118 daysfor the period between August 26, 2016, and January 26, 2017 (see People v Lin Chen, 21 Misc 3d1123[A], 2008 NY Slip Op 52153[U], *2 [Sup Ct, Kings County 2008]; People v Osorio, 2 Misc 3d 499,502-503 [Sup Ct, Bronx County 2003], affd 39 AD3d 400 [2007]; People vMurry, 168 Misc 2d 615, 616 [Sullivan County Ct 1996]; see generally People vLeon, 264 AD2d 784, 785 [1999]; People v Guin, 243 AD2d 649, 650 [1997]).

In any event, we agree with the defendant that, under the circumstances of this case,"[w]ithout a certificate or affidavit of translation, the Criminal Court complaint could not beconverted into an information" (People vRodriguez-Alas, 65 Misc 3d 914, 923 [Crim Ct, Bronx County 2019]; see People v Zamora, 63 Misc 3d1208[A], 2019 NY Slip Op 50443[U], *3 [Crim Ct, Kings County 2019]; People v Reyes, 60 Misc 3d 245,249-250 [Crim Ct, Queens County 2018]; People v Hernandez, 47 Misc 3d 51, 53-54 [App Term, 2d Dept,9th & 10th Jud Dists 2015]; Peoplev Benitez, 15 Misc 3d 1122[A], 2007 NY Slip Op 50798[U], *2 [Crim Ct, KingsCounty 2007]; cf. Matter of ShaquanaS., 9 AD3d 466, 466-467 [2004]; People v Rosario, 44 Misc 3d 1204[A], 2014 NY Slip Op 51017[U][Crim Ct, NY County 2014]; People vAntonovsky, 41 Misc 3d 44, 47 [App Term, 2d Dept, 2d, 11th & 13th Jud Dists2013]; People v Maceda, 40 Misc 3d 1213[A], 2013 NY Slip Op 51174[U], *3 [Crim Ct,Queens County 2013]). "In order for an information to be facially sufficient, it (and/or anysupporting depositions accompanying it) must allege nonhearsay allegations of fact of anevidentiary character that establish, if true, every element of the offense charged" (People v Lamendola, 57 Misc 3d153[A], 2017 NY Slip Op 51598[U], *2 [App Term, 2d Dept, 9th & 10th Jud Dists2017]; see CPL 100.15 [3]; 100.40 [1] [c]). "Without a fully converted, facially sufficientinformation, any statement of readiness by the People is illusory and ineffective" (People v Johnson-McLean, 65 Misc 3d1232[A], 2019 NY Slip Op 51941[U], *3 [Crim Ct, Bronx County 2019]). Here, where thecertificate of translation clearly indicated that the original complaint and supporting deposition,which were filed on August 26, 2016, were not translated for the complainant until January 26,2017, the People's statement of readiness made prior to that date was illusory and ineffective tostop the running of the speedy trial clock (see People v Rodriguez-Alas, 65 Misc 3d at924; cf. People v Badalov, 42 Misc3d 1235[A], 2014 NY Slip Op 50368[U], *3 [Crim Ct, Kings County 2014]; People vHonshj, 176 Misc 2d 170, 175-176 [Crim Ct, Kings County 1998]).

Accordingly, inasmuch as the People were chargeable with a total of 196 days, we agree withthe Supreme Court's determination granting the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 30.30 todismiss the indictment on the ground that he was deprived of his statutory right to a speedy trial.Austin, J.P., Cohen, Duffy and Iannacci, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.