People v McFadden
2020 NY Slip Op 07759 [189 AD3d 2086]
December 23, 2020
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 3, 2021


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
Duwayne McFadden, Appellant.

Frank H. Hiscock Legal Aid Society, Syracuse (Nathaniel V. Riley of counsel), fordefendant-appellant.

William J. Fitzpatrick, District Attorney, Syracuse (Bradley W. Oastler of counsel), forrespondent.

Appeal from a judgment of the Onondaga County Court (Matthew J. Doran, J.), renderedApril 25, 2018. The judgment convicted defendant upon a jury verdict of burglary in the thirddegree.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed.

Memorandum: On appeal from a judgment convicting him upon a jury verdict of burglary inthe third degree (Penal Law § 140.20), defendant contends that County Courtabused its discretion in failing to impose a sanction related to the People's Rosarioviolation and that, on this appeal, this Court should apply the new discovery statutes (seeCPL art 245) as opposed to the statutes that were in existence at the time of trial (see CPLformer art 240). We reject defendant's contentions.

Addressing first the issue concerning which statutes should be applied, we conclude that wemust review defendant's contention regarding the need for a sanction using the statutes that werein existence at the time of trial. "[W]hile procedural changes are, in the absence of words ofexclusion, deemed applicable to 'subsequent proceedings in pending actions'. . . , it takes 'a clear expression of the legislative purpose to justify' a retrospectiveapplication of even a procedural statute so as to affect proceedings previously taken insuch actions" (Simonson v International Bank, 14 NY2d 281, 289 [1964]; see alsoCharbonneau v State of New York, 148 Misc 2d 891, 895 [Ct Cl 1990], affd 178AD2d 815 [1991], affd sub nom. Dreger v New York State Thruway Auth., 81 NY2d 721[1992]). Indeed, "it would be particularly inappropriate for the courts now to undertake theformulation of new rules, and hold them applicable to cases instituted years ago"(Simonson, 14 NY2d at 288).

Here, applying the statutes that were in existence at the time of trial, we further conclude thatthe court properly refused to impose sanctions. In his omnibus motion, defendant sought, interalia, disclosure of prior statements of witnesses as well as any audio recordings that containedprior statements of witnesses or any evidence related to discrepancies in identification. On thefirst day of trial, defense counsel noted that, although he had received Rosario materialfrom the prosecution, it did not contain any radio transmissions of the officers expected to testifyat trial. Upon investigation, the prosecutor learned that the recordings had been destroyed as amatter of routine procedure 90 days after the incident. It is undisputed that defendant's omnibusmotion requesting such evidence was filed before expiration of that 90-day period. Defensecounsel sought a mistrial or, in the alternative, preclusion of evidence or an adverse inferenceinstruction. In opposition, the People argued that, inasmuch as there was a transcript of the radiotransmissions that was made contemporaneously with the recording, defendant was notprejudiced by the destruction of the audio recordings. The court agreed and denied defendant'srequest for sanctions.

[*2] Although the People had anobligation to preserve the requested evidence (see People v Martinez, 71 NY2d 937, 940[1988]; see generally People v Kelly, 62 NY2d 516, 520 [1984]), we conclude thatsanctions were not warranted because defendant sustained no prejudice. The People correctlyconcede that the transcript of the radio transmissions cannot be considered a duplicativeequivalent (see People v Joseph, 86 NY2d 565, 570 [1995]), but it "disclose[s] enoughinformation to determine the general subject matter and approximate content of the missingmaterials, so as to enable this Court to fairly evaluate defendant's claim of prejudice" (Peoplev Smith, 235 AD2d 639, 641 [3d Dept 1997], lv denied 89 NY2d 1041 [1997]).

It is well settled that "nonwillful, negligent loss or destruction of Rosario materialdoes not mandate a sanction unless the defendant establishes prejudice" (People v Martinez, 22 NY3d 551,567 [2014]; see Joseph, 86 NY2d at 570-571; Martinez, 71 NY2d at 940). Underthe circumstances of this case, we discern no prejudice from the destruction of the recordings ofthe radio transmissions between the officers (see Smith, 235 AD2d at 641; People vTorres, 179 AD2d 696, 697 [2d Dept 1992], lv denied 79 NY2d 1008 [1992];People v Hyde, 172 AD2d 305, 306 [1st Dept 1991], lv denied 78 NY2d 1077[1991]; cf. People v Viruet, 29NY3d 527, 533 [2017]).

Defendant further contends that the identification testimony of two police officers shouldhave been precluded because he received no CPL 710.30 notice related to their prioridentification of him and the court granted his motion to preclude "identification . . .evidence of which the People failed to give notice." That contention is not preserved for ourreview "inasmuch as defendant did not object to the admission of that evidence on that groundduring trial" (People v King, 166AD3d 1562, 1563 [4th Dept 2018], lv denied 34 NY3d 1017 [2019]; see People v Marvin, 162 AD3d1744, 1744 [4th Dept 2018], lv denied 32 NY3d 1066 [2018]; see also People vHunter, 122 AD2d 166, 166 [2d Dept 1986], lv denied 68 NY2d 770 [1986]).

By making only a general motion for a trial order of dismissal, defendant "failed to preservefor our review his challenge to the legal sufficiency of the evidence" (People v Alejandro, 60 AD3d1381, 1382 [4th Dept 2009], lv denied 12 NY3d 850 [2009]; see generally Peoplev Gray, 86 NY2d 10, 19 [1995]). In any event, the evidence, viewed in the light mostfavorable to the People (see People v Contes, 60 NY2d 620, 621 [1983]), is legallysufficient to support the conviction (see generally People v Bleakley, 69 NY2d 490, 495[1987]). Moreover, viewing the evidence in light of the elements of the crime as charged to thejury (see People v Danielson, 9NY3d 342, 349 [2007]), we conclude that the verdict is not against the weight of theevidence (see generally Bleakley, 69 NY2d at 495). Where, as here, "witness credibility isof paramount importance to the determination of guilt or innocence, the appellate court must give'[g]reat deference . . . [to the] fact-finder's opportunity to view the witnesses, hearthe testimony and observe demeanor' " (People v Harris, 15 AD3d 966, 967 [4th Dept 2005], lvdenied 4 NY3d 831 [2005], quoting Bleakley, 69 NY2d at 495). We see no basis todisturb that determination.

Although defendant correctly concedes that any contention that he was penalized forasserting his right to a trial is not preserved for our review (see People v Hurley, 75NY2d 887, 888 [1990]; People vFudge, 104 AD3d 1169, 1170 [4th Dept 2013], lv denied 21 NY3d 1042[2013]), he nevertheless contends that the addition of one year to the maximum term of theindeterminate sentence offered under the plea was not justified by anything that was elicitedduring the trial and, as a result, the sentence is unduly harsh and severe. We reject thatcontention. Considering, among other things, that defendant was eligible to be sentenced as apersistent felony offender (see Penal Law § 70.10 [1] [a], [b]; [2]; seealso § 70.00 [2] [a]; [3] [a] [i]), we conclude that his sentence of31/2 to 7 years of incarceration, i.e., the maximum sentence for a second felonyoffender (§ 70.06 [3] [d]; [4] [b]), is not unduly harsh or severe.Present—Whalen, P.J., Centra, Peradotto, Lindley and Bannister, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.