[*1]
People v Williams
2021 NY Slip Op 50986(U) [73 Misc 3d 1209(A)]
Decided on October 19, 2021
Criminal Court Of The City Of New York, New York County
Rosenthal, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on October 19, 2021
Criminal Court of the City of New York, New York County


The People of theState of New York

against

Ozzie Williams, Defendant.




Docket No. CR-009654-21NY
Robert Rosenthal, J.

Documents considered in review of this motion:



1.People's Affirmation and Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Leave toReargue, dated September 1, 2021;

2.Defendant's Notice of Opposition toProsecutor's Motion for Leave to Reargue, dated September 16, 2021;

3.Defendant'sAffirmation in Opposition to Motion to Reargue, dated September 16, 2021.



Robert Rosenthal, J.:

Defendant is charged by information with violating Penal Law § 130.52(1), ForcibleTouching, and Penal Law § 130.55, Sexual Abuse in the Third Degree. On July 30, 2021,the court granted defendant's motion pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law §§ 245.20and 245.50 to invalidate the People's Certificate of Compliance (COC) and Certificate ofReadiness (COR) for the People's failure to disclose material and information required by CPL245.20 (1)(k) — specifically, materials underlying substantiated accusations ofmisconduct against the People's police officer witness (People v Williams, 72 Misc 3d 1214[A][Crim Ct, NY County2021]). On September 16, 2021, the People moved for leave to reargue that motion. The requestfor leave to reargue is denied.



Leave to Reargue

A reargument motion "shall be based upon matters of fact or law allegedly overlooked ormisapprehended by the court in determining the prior motion" (CPLR 2221[d][2]). While it is notsettled that CPLR 2221 is applicable in criminal cases (see People v DeFreitas, 48 Misc3d 569 [Crim Ct NY County 2015]), courts have inherent power to correct their ownmistakes.Thus, "reargument" is available, regardless of the applicability of CPLR 2221 tocriminal proceedings (see People vGodbold, 117 AD3d 565, 566 [1st Dept 2014]; People v Baptiste, 70 [*2]Misc 3d 706, 708 [Crim Ct NY County 2020]; People v Jones, 57 Misc 3d 590,592-593 (Crim Ct Kings County 2017); People v DeFreitas, 48 Misc 3d at 576-577).



The People's Motion for Leave to Reargue

The People assert that the court "fail[ed] to distinguish between 'good faith' and 'duediligence,'" and "improperly ascribed bad faith to the People's COC filing. . . ." That is not thecase.

As noted in the original decision, CPL 245.20 (2) requires that "the prosecutor shall make adiligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence of material or information discoverable undersubdivision one of this section and to cause such material or information to be made available fordiscovery where it exists but is not within the prosecutor's possession, custody or control" (CPL245.20 [2]).

As explained in the original decision, the People here ascertained the existence ofdiscoverable material and information — substantiated disciplinary accusations against thepolice witness. Thus, they fulfilled the first component of their obligation. But the People did notcause that material and information — the underlying files — to be made availablefor discovery. Thus, the People failed to satisfy the second part of their obligation under CPL245.20(2).

The People argue, as they did before, that because it was in "good faith" that they decidedthat the files were not discoverable, their failure to disclose should not affect the validity of theirCOC. The statute, however, does not concern the People's rationale for failing to disclose. Itrequires simply that the People disclose discoverable information and material, whether or notsuch information is recorded in tangible form (People v Williams, 72 Misc 3d at *4-*5;People v Edwards, CR-003469-21NY [Crim Ct, NY County 2021]; People v Soto, 72 Misc 3d 1153,1163 [Crim Ct, NY County 2021]). The People did not do that here. It is for that reason that thePeople's COC was deemed invalid. The People have not raised any matter that the court hasmisapprehended. The motion for leave to reargue is thus denied.

Although leave to reargue is denied, several points are worth noting. First, in their oppositionto defendant's motion, the People argued that disclosure of the disciplinary records should not berequired due to the burden and hardship that requiring disclosure of the underlying disciplinarymaterials would cause. That claim is belied by the fact that within 34 days of the court's decisionordering disclosure, the People produced those materials to the defense. That is well within theallotted time period for discovery — including time allotted for voluminous materials(CPL 245.10 [1][a]).[FN1]

Second, the People's claim that the court has ascribed "bad faith" to their failure to disclose isincorrect. The People's failure to disclose rendered their COC invalid, regardless of the rationalefor that failure. Moreover, the absence of the particular diligent, good faith effort required bystatute is not equivalent to "bad faith."

Third, as noted in the original decision, the court is aware of decisions by courts ofconcurrent jurisdiction ordering disclosure of withheld disciplinary records, while permittingCOCs to stand (see [*3]People v Porter, 71 Misc 3d 1187[Crim Ct, Bronx County 2020]; People vKelly, 71 Misc 3d 1202[A] [Crim Ct, NY County 2021]). It may have been the newnessof the statute that prompted those courts deciding the earliest cases under the new law to affordthe People a kind of grace period to accommodate non-compliance. This court finds, however, nostatutory authority for finding that a COC is valid once it is determined that the People have notmet their discovery obligations. Further, to the extent a grace period was once justifiable, by thetime discovery was due in the instant case, sufficient decisions requiring disclosure ofsubstantiated disciplinary records had been handed down to place the People on notice of theperil of their nondisclosure.

Fourth, to the extent the People rely on CPL 245.50 and 245.60, those provisions impose acontinuing duty to disclose, without adverse consequences when the People provide additionaldiscovery learned of "subsequent[]" to the initial discovery — that is, after the People havemade their initial diligent, good-faith efforts to ascertain the existence of and then to disclosediscoverable evidence. That is not the situation here, where from the outset the People decidednot to disclose the disciplinary records.

The People have not raised any element of law or fact that was misapprehended by the court.Accordingly, the People's motion for leave to reargue is denied.

This constitutes the decision and order of the court.



DATE: October 19, 2021

New York, NY

RobertRosenthal

Judge of the Criminal Court

Footnotes


Footnote 1:The People did not provide thedecision to the NYPD until August 6, 2021. Thus, only 27 days elapsed from the time thematerials were requested from NYPD to the time they were disclosed.




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.