People v Sims
2022 NY Slip Op 04586 [207 AD3d 882] [207 AD3d 882]
July 14, 2022
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 31, 2022


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
Yasif Sims, Appellant.

Noreen McCarthy, Keene Valley, for appellant.

Letitia James, Attorney General, New York City (James F. Gibbons of counsel), forrespondent.

Clark, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of St. Lawrence County(Richards, J.),rendered August 20, 2018, convicting defendant upon his plea of guilty of the crime ofcriminalpossession of a controlled substance in the second degree.

In connection with an 86-count indictment against multiple codefendants related todrugtrafficking, defendant was charged with conspiracy in the second degree and criminalpossessionof a controlled substance in the first and third degrees. In satisfaction of all charges,defendantpleaded guilty to criminal possession of a controlled substance in the second degreeunder count66 of the indictment, as amended and reduced, and executed a waiver of the right toappeal, inexchange for an agreed-upon prison sentence of six years to be followed by five years ofpostrelease supervision (hereinafter PRS). County Court raised the prospect thatdefendant couldbe sentenced as a predicate felon based upon numerous out-of-state convictions. On thedayscheduled for sentencing, County Court indicated, following off-the-record discussions,that itwould grant defense counsel's request for an adjournment to investigate whetherdefendant hadfailed to abide by the conditions of his plea agreement by violating jailhouse rules afterhis guiltyplea was entered, which would relieve the court of its sentencing commitment. Atsentencing,after hearing from both sides, the court determined that defendant had violated the termsof theplea agreement, thereby relieving it of its sentencing commitment, and sentenceddefendant, as afirst-time felony offender, to an enhanced prison sentence of seven years, followed byfive yearsof PRS. Defendant appeals.

Initially, the record reflects that defendant knowingly, intelligently and voluntarilywaived hisright to appeal (see People vLopez,6 NY3d 248, 256 [2006]; People vShindler, 179 AD3d 1306, 1307-1308 [2020]). Defendant was advised that anappealwaiver was a condition of the plea agreement, and County Court explained, withexamples, thatsome rights were not waived. The court conveyed that the right to appeal is separate anddistinctfrom the trial-related rights automatically forfeited by his guilty plea and ascertained thatdefendant understood the waiver (see People v Lopez, 6 NY3d at 256).Defendant thenexecuted a written waiver of appeal after reviewing it with counsel, indicating that hehad readand understood it and had no questions. Contrary to defendant's claim, although thewrittenwaiver contained some overly broad language regarding its scope, both the oral andwrittenwaivers clearly advised that certain issues survive a waiver of appeal. There was nosuggestionthat the appeal waiver was an absolute bar to taking an appeal. On this record, we aresatisfiedthat defendant, assisted by counsel, "understood the distinction that some appellatereviewsurvived" (People vThomas, 34NY3d 545, 561 [2019]; cf.People vShanks, 37 NY3d 244, 253 [2021]; People v [*2]Bisono, 36 NY3d1013, 1017-1018 [2020]).

Given the valid appeal waiver, defendant's challenge to the factual sufficiency of thepleaallocution, which was not preserved by an appropriate postallocution motion (see People v Aponte, 190AD3d1031, 1032 [2021], lv denied 37 NY3d 953 [2021]), is precluded (see People v Dickerson, 198AD3d1190, 1193 [2021]). In any event, "a pleading defendant need not recite everyelement of thecrime or provide a factual exposition . . . [and] where, as here, a defendantpleads toa lesser crime as part of a plea bargain, the court is not required to engage in a factualrecitationin order to establish the elements of the crime" (People v Favreau, 174 AD3d 1226, 1227-1228 [2019],lvdenied 34 NY3d 980 [2019] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]).Defendant'schallenge to the voluntariness of his plea survives his appeal waiver but is alsounpreserved forour review in the absence of an appropriate postallocution motion, despite having hadample timein which to make such motion (seePeople v Jackson, 203 AD3d 1388, 1389 [2022]). Defendant made nostatements duringthe plea allocution or at sentencing that negated an element of the crime or thevoluntariness ofhis plea, so as to trigger the narrow exception to the preservation requirement (see People v Williams, 27NY3d212, 214, 219-222 [2016]; People v Lopez, 71 NY2d 662, 666 [1988]).Defendant'sunsworn, postplea statements to the Probation Department—to the extent that theywereinconsistent with his admissions during the plea allocution—were unsubstantiatedand didnot impose a duty of further inquiry upon County Court (see People v Rosario, 203 AD3d 1404, 1405 [2022], lvdenied 38 NY3d 1035 [2022]; People v Carroll, 172 AD3d 1821, 1822 [2019], lvdenied34 NY3d 929 [2019]; People vAllen, 166 AD3d 1210, 1211 [2018], lv denied 32 NY3d 1201[2019]).

Moreover, County Court did not overstate defendant's potential sentencing exposurefor theclass A-II crime to which he was entering a guilty plea, as he was properly advised thathe faced apotential sentence of 14 years with five years of PRS were he determined to be a secondfelonydrug offender (see Penal Law §§ 70.71 [1] [b]; [3] [b] [ii];70.45 [2];220.18). To the extent that defendant claims that the court erred in accepting his guiltyplea priorto determining his predicate sentencing status, this contention has not been preserved forourreview as he did not raise it during the plea allocution but, rather, voluntarily pleadedguiltywhile aware that he could be sentenced as a second felony drug offender and that hissentencingstatus was yet to be determined (seePeople v Hernandez, 188 AD3d 1357, 1359 [2020], lv denied 36 NY3d1057[2021]). Were we to address defendant's claim, we would find that determiningdefendant'spredicate status at sentencing, with the benefit of the presentence report and predicatefelonystatements, did not violate lawful procedure or render [*3]hisguilty plea involuntary, and the agreed-upon sentence was not contingent upon thatdetermination(see CPL 400.21). Notably, defendant was ultimately and lawfully sentenced as afirst-time felony drug offender to a prison term of seven years, followed by five years ofPRS(see Penal Law §§ 70.45 [2]; 70.71 [1] [a]; [2] [b] [ii]).

Defendant further contends that County Court failed to conduct a sufficient inquiryintowhether he violated the terms of the plea agreement prior to imposing an enhancedsentence.However, defendant failed to preserve this claim as he did not move to withdraw hisguilty pleaon this basis or request a hearing to contest the basis for the charges that he violatedjailhouserules (see People v Bishop,188AD3d 1445, 1446 [2020]). In any event, County Court made clear that a conditionof theplea was that he "comply with the jail rules" by, among other things, respecting thecorrectionofficers and that, if he failed to do so, the court would no longer be bound by thepromisedsentence. At sentencing, the court outlined the information it had received regarding thejailhouserules violations, and defense counsel argued, albeit unsuccessfully, for adherence to thepromisedsentence; defendant had an opportunity to provide his version of the postplea incidentthatresulted in charges, essentially admitting the incident but arguing that his conduct did notamountto harassment of a correction officer. An evidentiary hearing was not required and, underthecircumstances, we find that the court conducted a sufficient inquiry before determiningthat therewas a legitimate basis for the charges (see People v Albergotti, 17 NY3d 748, 750 [2011];People vOutley, 80 NY2d 702, 712-713 [1993]). Defendant's appeal waiver precludes hisrelatedcontention that the court, in sentencing him, considered unreliable information (see People v Smith, 119 AD3d1088, 1089 [2014], lv denied 24 NY3d 1089 [2014]) and such contention is,in anyevent, unsupported by the record.

Defendant's claim that counsel provided ineffective assistance is unpreserved andprecludedby the waiver of appeal except to the extent that it impacts upon the voluntariness of hisguiltyplea; to the extent that it concerns matters outside of the record, such as what counseladvisedhim or investigated, such matters are more properly addressed in a motion to vacate thejudgmentof conviction pursuant to CPL article 440 (see People v Williams, 203 AD3d 1398, 1399-1400 [2022],lvdenied 38 NY3d 1036 [2022]). Were we to address this claim, we would find, on thisrecord,that defense counsel was not ineffective for failing to request an evidentiary hearing tocontestthe charges that defendant violated jailhouse rules (see People v Bishop, 188AD3d at1447). Contrary to defendant's argument, the record does not support a finding thatdefensecounsel, in advocating against an enhanced sentence, took a position adverse todefendant orundermined his defense [*4]against the plea violationcharges soas to create a conflict of interest (seePeople v Mitchell, 21 NY3d 964, 966-967 [2013]; People v Curry, 123 AD3d 1381, 1382 [2014], lvdenied 25NY3d 950 [2015]; cf. People vMaldonado, 183 AD3d 1129, 1129-1130 [2020]). We have examineddefendant'sremaining contentions and find them to be without merit.

Garry, P.J., Egan Jr., Aarons and McShan, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.