People v Gatchell
2022 NY Slip Op 05355 [208 AD3d 1549]
September 29, 2022
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 9, 2022


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
James B. Gatchell, Appellant.

David E. Woodin, Catskill, for appellant.

J. Anthony Jordan, District Attorney, Fort Edward (Taylor Fitzsimmons of counsel),for respondent.

McShan, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Washington County(Kelly S. McKeighan, J.), rendered September 20, 2019, convicting defendant upon hisplea of guilty of the crime of failure to properly register as a sex offender (twocounts).

Defendant waived indictment and pleaded guilty to a two-count superior courtinformation (hereinafter SCI) charging him in count one with failure to properly registeras a sex offender, a class D felony, in violation of Correction Law§§ 168-f (4) and 168-t, and in count 2 with failure to properly registeras a sex offender in violation of Correction Law §§ 168-f (2) (b-2) and168-t, a class E felony. County Court sentenced defendant, in accordance with the termsof the plea agreement, to a prison term of 21/3 to 7 years upon hisconviction of count 1 of the SCI and a consecutive prison term of 11/3 to 4years upon his conviction of count 2 of the SCI. Defendant appeals.

We are unpersuaded by defendant's contention that the waiver of his right to appealis invalid. County Court, albeit briefly, explained that the waiver of the right to appealwas separate and distinct from the rights automatically forfeited by the guilty plea andthat by waiving his right to appeal defendant was giving up certain rights that would notbe reviewed by a higher court, which defendant acknowledged that he understood.Defendant also, after conferring with counsel, executed a detailed written waiver, whichexplicitly set forth various rights that could not be waived, and assured the court that heunderstood and had no questions about the appeal waiver. We are satisfied that therecord here reflects that defendant knowingly, voluntarily and intelligently waived hisright to appeal (see People vRuest, 206 AD3d 1174, 1174-1175 [3d Dept 2022]; People v Stockwell, 203 AD3d1407, 1408 [3d Dept 2022], lv denied 38 NY3d 1036 [2022]; People v Thaxton, 191 AD3d1166, 1167 [3d Dept 2021], lv denied 37 NY3d 960 [2021]). As such, to theextent that defendant asserts that his sentence is unduly harsh or severe, his argument isprecluded (see People vKing, 206 AD3d 1170, 1170 [3d Dept 2022]; People v Ruest, 206 AD3dat 1175).

Defendant's contention that County Court illegally imposed consecutive sentences,however, is not foreclosed by his appeal waiver or his guilty plea (see People v Light, 184 AD3d904, 906 [3d Dept 2020]; People v Parks, 180 AD3d 1109, 1110 n [3d Dept 2020]),and preservation is not required (see People v Nieves, 2 NY3d 310, 315-316 [2004]). Wenevertheless find it to be without merit. Penal Law § 70.25 (2) provides thatconcurrent sentences must be imposed when "two or more offenses [are] committedthrough a single act or omission, or through an act or omission which in itself constitutedone of the offenses and also was a material element of the other." Where, however,"either the elements of the crimes do not overlap or if the facts demonstrate that thedefendant's acts underlying the crimes are separate and distinct," [*2]consecutive sentences may be imposed (People v Brahney, 29 NY3d10, 15 [2017] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted])—"even thoughthose acts are part of a single criminal transaction" (People v Parks, 180 AD3d at1110 [internal quotation marks, brackets and citation omitted]). It is the People's burdento establish that separate and distinct acts occurred and, in doing so, they can rely on theaccusatory instrument and any facts adduced at the plea allocution (see People vLight, 184 AD3d at 906).

As to the particular crimes at issue, defendant pleaded guilty to two counts of failureto properly register as a sex offender stemming from two separate and distinct incidentswhich—although part of a continuing course of conduct—occurred indifferent, specified months. The first count alleged that, on or about August 29, 2018 andcontinuing thereafter, defendant failed to register his new home address with theDivision of Criminal Justice Services within 10 calendar days as required by CorrectionLaw § 168-f (4). The second count of the SCI charged defendant withfailure to properly register as a sex offender in that, on or about November 13, 2018 andcontinuing thereafter, defendant, as a level 3 convicted sex offender, did not appear at theDivision of Criminal Justice Services and provide a current photograph of himselfannually as required by Correction Law § 168-f (2) (b-2). All told, therequirements at issue—the duty to register a new address within 10 days and theduty to personally appear annually for the purpose of providing a photograph—areprovisions which are independent of each other and serve separate and distinct purposesin connection with defendant's duty to register as a sex offender. The imposition ofconsecutive sentences was, therefore, appropriate (see People v Parks, 180 AD3dat 1110-1111; People vMoon, 119 AD3d 1293, 1294-1295 [3d Dept 2014], lv denied 24 NY3d1004 [2014]; People vKeebler, 15 AD3d 724, 727-728 [3d Dept 2005], lv denied 4 NY3d 854[2005]).

Lynch, J.P., Aarons, Reynolds Fitzgerald and Fisher, JJ., concur. Ordered that thejudgment is affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.