| People v Perez |
| 2022 NY Slip Op 50387(U) [75 Misc 3d 1205(A)] |
| Decided on May 6, 2022 |
| Criminal Court Of The City Of New York, Bronx County |
| Chin, J. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on May 6, 2022
The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff, against Jaime Perez, Defendant. |
Docket No. CR-013226-21BX
Attorney for the People: Hon. Darcel D. Clark, District Attorney, Bronx County, 198East 161st St., Bronx, NY 10451 - by Assistant District Attorney Latoya Stephens, Esq.
Attorney defendant Jaime Perez: Janet E. Sabel, The Legal Aid Society, Criminal DefensePractice, 260 East 161st St., 10th Floor, Bronx, NY 10451 - by Chrystalia King, Esq.
Christopher Chin, J.
Upon review and consideration of the submissions, court file and relevant law, defendant'smotion to deem the certificate of compliance ("COC") filed on November 18, 2021 to beimproper under CPL § 245.50 (1) and to dismiss the accusatory instrument on speedy trialgrounds pursuant to CPL § § 30.30 and 210.20 (1)(g), as a result of the defective COC,is granted. The reasons for the court's decision are explained below.
Procedural Background
Defendant Jaime Perez was arrested on September 4, 2021 and charged with three (3) countsof operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs (Vehicle and TrafficLaw § 1192 [1], [2] and [3]). He was arraigned on the same day and released on his ownrecognizance.
The People provided various discovery materials to the defense and on November 18, 2021,served and filed a certificate of compliance (COC) and statement of readiness.
On December 7, 2021, the parties appeared in All-purpose Part 3 ("AP3") and the Peopleasked to be found in compliance with their discovery obligations, which was challenged by thedefense. The court (Hon. Joseph J. McCormack) instructed defendant to put his objections to theCOC in writing and a motion schedule was set.
By notice dated February 10, 2022, defendant moved for an order: (1) deeming theNovember 18, 2021 COC to be a nullity under CPL § 245.50 (1) on the ground that certainmaterials discoverable pursuant CPL § 245.20 (1) were not disclosed and made available tothe defense; and (2) dismissing the accusatory instrument pursuant to CPL § § 30.30and 210.20 (1)(g), as a result of the defective COC.
Specifically, defendant asserts that prior to filing the certificate of compliance, theprosecution failed to comply with CPL § 245.20 (1)(e) and (s) because the following itemswere not provided: (1) memo books for three of the five police officers involved in defendant'sarrest—explaining that the prosecution turned over body worn camera footage for fiveofficers but memo books for only two of the officers; (2) NYDP Scratch Report for the ArrestReport Worksheet; (3) a formalized and finalized copy of the Collision Information Exchange(PD 302-257); (4) a formalized and finalized copy of the police accident report (MV 104AN); (5)a formalized and finalized copy of the motor vehicle accident report (MV 104); (6) a Truck andBus Supplemental Police Accident Report (MV 1045); and (7) calibration reports.
By affirmation dated March 4, 2022, the People opposed, arguing that they met their burdenunder CPL § 245.50 (1) as they filed a COC and statement of readiness after exercising duediligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of material subject todiscovery. The People urge that they turned over all discoverable items provided to them,substantially complied with their discovery obligations, and made good faith efforts to providediscovery materials under CPL § 245.20 (1).[FN1]The People simply state that: (1) the memo books of all five officers were provided to thedefense on March 4, 2022; (2) the NYPD arrest report was "re-shared" with the defense onMarch 4, 2022 and they made inquiries of the arresting officer and precinct discovery liaisonregarding the scratch report for the arrest report worksheet, which has yet to be provided; (3)collision information was "re-shared" with the defense on March 4, 2022 and they made inquiriesof the arresting officer and precinct discovery liaison regarding the Collision InformationExchange, which has yet to be provided; (4) the NYPD Motor Vehicle Worksheet was"re-shared" with the defense on March 4, 2022; (5) they inquired of the arresting officer andprecinct discovery liaison with respect to the Truck and Bus Supplemental Police AccidentReport, which has yet to be provided; and (6) calibration reports were provided on March 4,2022.[FN2]The People further maintain that they recognize their continuing duty to supply disclosure andthe minimal amount of discovery that remains outstanding is not due to a lack of a good faitheffort on their part. The People argue that the defense failed to set forth any harm, to warrant theimposition of remedies or sanctions by this court.
In reply, the defense maintains that the prosecution conceded that the memo books for allfive (5) officers, calibration reports, and NYPD Arrest Report were not provided to it until March4, 2022 (which was more than 90 days after this action was commenced), and the prosecutionfailed to explain why these materials were not previously provided. The defense furthermaintains that while the prosecution stated that they "re-shared" the NYPD Arrest Report,Collision Information, NYPD Motor Vehicle Collision Worksheet as of March 4, 2022, theprosecution did not state when the materials were originally provided. The defense contends thatthe materials claimed to be "re-shared" were not in fact supplied prior to the filing of theprosecution's certificate of compliance and statement of trial readiness.
[*2]Discussion
Pursuant to CPL § 30.30 (1), a motion to dismiss must be granted when the prosecutionis not ready for trial within the time period set forth by the relevant speedy trial provision.
In this case, it is undisputed that the prosecution must be ready for trial within ninety (90)days of the commencement of the action, because defendant is accused of one or more offenses,at least one of which is a misdemeanor punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of more thanthree (3) months (see CPL §30.30 [1] [b]).[FN3]Although a criminal action commences with the filing of an accusatory instrument, computationfor speedy trial purposes commences on the next day (see People v Stiles, 70 NY2d 765,767 [1987]). Here, all parties do not dispute that the speedy trial clock started on September 5,2021.
To satisfy the initial burden under CPL § 30.30, a defendant need allege "only that theprosecution failed to declare readiness within the statutorily prescribed time period" (People vLuperon, 85 NY2d 71, 77-78 [1995]). Once a defendant has alleged that more than thestatutorily prescribed time period has elapsed since the commencement of the action without adeclaration of readiness, the prosecution bears the burden of establishing sufficient excludabledelay (see People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d 333, 349 [1980]). The time within which theprosecution must be ready is computed by subtracting any periods of delay that are excludableunder the statute (see People v Cortes, 80 NY2d 201, 208 [1992]).
Trial readiness means that the prosecutors must have "done all that is required of them tobring the case to a point where it may be tried" (People v England, 84 NY2d 1, 4 [1994])and a proper certificate of compliance with the disclosure requirements of CPL § 245.20must have been filed (see CPL § § 245.50 [3]; 30.30 [5]; People v Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d563, 575 [Crim Ct, Kings County 2020]).
Under the "initial discovery" provision of CPL § 245.20 (1), soon after thecommencement of an action, "[t]he prosecution shall disclose to the defendant and permit thedefendant to discover, inspect, copy, photograph and test, all items and information that relate tothe subject matter of the case and are in the possession, custody or control of the prosecution orpersons under the prosecution's direction or control, including but not limited to" anon-exhaustive list of materials. The prosecution is to make a diligent and good faith effort toascertain the existence of the discovery materials and make them available to the defense, even ifthe information is not in the prosecution's physical possession, except for lost or destroyedmaterial, and materials subject to a protective order (see CPL § § 245.20 [2];245.70 [1]; 245.80 [1][b]). Unless the court has made "an individualized finding of specialcircumstances . . . the prosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial for purposes of section30.30 . . . until it has [fulfilled its discovery obligations under CPL §§245.20 (1) and]filed a proper certificate [of compliance]" (CPL § 245.50 [3]; see also People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d518, 520 [Crim Ct, Kings County 2021]).
CPL § 245.50 (1) sets for the requirements for a COC as follows:
[t]he certificate of compliance shall state that, after exercising due diligence andmaking [*3]reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence ofmaterial and information subject to discovery, the prosecutor has disclosed and made availableall known material and information subject to discovery. It shall also identify the itemsprovided (emphasis supplied).
The statute further states that where "additional discovery is subsequentlyprovided prior to trial pursuant to section 245.60 [under the prosecution's continuing duty todisclose material discovered after the initial discovery has been exchanged and a COC filed], asupplemental certificate shall be served identifying the additional material and informationprovided" (CPL § 245.50 [1]). The last sentence of CPL § 245.50 (1) states: "Noadverse consequence to the prosecution or the prosecutor shall result from the filing of acertificate of compliance in good faith and reasonable under the circumstances; but the court maygrant a remedy or sanction for a discovery violation as provided in section 245.80 of thisarticle."
The only logical way to interpret CPL § § 245.50(1) and 30.30 together, in thecontext of a motion to dismiss on speedy trial grounds, is to first examine the People's "actualreadiness" (CPL 30.30 [5]); that is, whether the prosecution has "done all that is required of themto bring the case to a point where it may be tried," including filing a valid COC (People vEngland, 84 NY2d at 4). In order to find the COC to be valid, the Court must be satisfiedthat it was filed in "good faith and reasonable under the circumstances" (CPL§ 245.50 [1]).If any known discoverable materials were not exchanged prior to the filing of the COC, theprosecution must demonstrate how due diligence was exercised with regard to those items notexchanged (see People v Pierna, — Misc 3d —, 163 NYS 3d 897, 909[Crim Ct, Bronx County 2021]). They must detail the reasonable inquiries made to obtain thesediscoverable materials (see id.; CPL§ 245.50 [1]). If after review of the detailsprovided by the prosecution, the court is satisfied that the COC was filed in good faith despite thediscovery that was not exchanged, it may consider appropriate sanctions pursuant to CPL §245.80, the severity of which may depend on any prejudice the defense suffered as a result of thediscovery that was not exchanged prior to the filing of the COC (see CPL § 245.50[1]).
If the court finds that the COC was not filed in good faith, the certificate of compliance shallbe deemed invalid and there is no need to consider the sanctions under CPL § 245.80, or toconsider if the defense was prejudiced. (see People v Georgiopoulos, 71 Misc 3d 1215 [A], *3 [Sup Ct,Queens County 2021]; People v Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d at 574).
Thus, "discovery compliance is a question of diligence and reasonableness given theparticular facts of the case: neither a claim of good faith nor an absence of bad faith, standingalone, can exempt the People from these requirements" (People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d at5; People v Georgiopoulos, 71 Misc3d 1215[A], *3 [Sup Ct, Queens County 2021] ["good faith and due diligence are thetouchstones by which a certificate of compliance must be evaluated"]). Rather, "[w]hen thePeople submit documentation to the court certifying their compliance with their statutoryobligation, they must do more than merely mouth the words" (People v Adrovic, 69 Misc3d at 574-75).
Here, the court finds that the People failed to meet their discovery obligations when the COCwas filed and therefore, the certificate is deemed invalid. It is undisputed that on November 18,2021, when the COC and statement of readiness were served and filed, several items of discoverythat were known to exist—including three (3) out of five (5) of the police officers' memobooks and calibration reports—had not been provided to the defense. Notably, the People'sCOC lists that "memo books" were provided to defendant, yet the People conceded in [*4]response to the within motion that "all known" memo books werenot supplied to defendant until March 4, 2022, almost four months after the COC wasfiled (CPL § 245.50 [1]). "[C]ontrary to the People's contention, their filing of thecertificate of compliance pursuant to CPL 30.30 (5) could not be deemed complete untilall of the material and information identified in the certificate as subject to discovery . . .was actually produced to the defendant, pursuant to CPL 245.50 (1) and (3)" (People v Brann, 197 AD3d 787,788 [2nd Dept 2021] [emphasis supplied]; see also People v Diaz, — Misc 3d—, 2022 NY Slip Op 22083, *3 [Crim Ct, Bronx County March 16, 2022] ["[w]ithout theexpress permission of the court, the statute does not permit the prosecution to file a certificate ofdiscovery compliance [claiming] to have exercised due diligence and turned over all knowmaterial and information when the prosecution has not actually done so"]).
Additionally, the People failed demonstrate or detail any "due diligence" or how they madereasonable inquiries or provide any details of the good faith efforts they made to obtain thediscovery not disclosed prior to their filing of the COC (see People v Adrovic, 69 Misc3d at 575-76 [People's unexplained failure to provide discovery rendered the certificate ofcompliance and statement of readiness illusory]; People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d at 523-24[certificate of compliance invalidated where People failed to provide known discovery and noshowing of diligence]; People vGeorgiopoulos, 71 Misc 3d 1215[A], *6 [CPL § 245.50 [1] [given the deficienciesin both the certificate of compliance and People's explanation, the court found no showing of duediligence and certificate deemed invalid]).[FN4]The prosecution's conclusory assertions of due diligence, without specific details regarding actualsteps they took to obtain the discovery prior to filing the COC, are insufficient (see People v Georgiopoulos, 71 Misc3d 1215[A] *3). Significantly, the People offered no explanation whatsoever as to theirattempts to obtain the three (3) memo books and calibration reports, that were admittedly notdisclosed with the COC and which were ultimately disclosed almost four (4) months after theCOC was filed (and approximately one month after defendant moved to dismiss). Rather, thePeople merely list in their response to the motion that "[m]emo [b]ooks for all five officers wereprovided to [d]efense on March 4, 2022" and "[c]alibration reports were provided to the defense on March 4, 2022" (Response in Opposition, at 6-7). Further, the People fail to state when theitems they claim were "reshared" to the defense (the NYPD Arrest Report, Collision Information,NYPD Motor Vehicle Collision Worksheet) were originally disclosed and in particular, whetherthe original disclosure was prior to the filing of the COC.
The People did not request a protective order or additional time to comply with theirdiscovery obligations upon a showing of good cause pursuant to CPL § 245.70 (1) and (2),and they also did not seek "an individualized finding of special circumstances" from the court, aspermitted by CPL § 245.50 [3]). Nor did they assert that any of the missing discovery was"lost or destroyed" (id.).
Moreover, "the People's obligation to provide discovery, and to certify compliance with thatobligation, is not relieved by an absence of prejudice to the defendant" (People vAdrovic, 69 Misc 3d at 574; see also People v Diaz, — Misc 3d —,2022 NY Slip Op 22083, *4 [prejudice analysis not to be considered when assessing validity of acertificate of discovery [*5]compliance]).[FN5]
Since the COC has been deemed invalid, the People's statement of readiness filed onNovember 18, 2021 was ineffective to stop the speedy trial clock under CPL § 30.30(see People v England, 84 NY2d at 4 ["A statement of readiness at a time when thePeople are not actually ready is illusory and insufficient to stop the running of the speedy trialclock"]). The speedy trial clock therefore continued to run through December 7, 2021, the datethe motion schedule was set. The court finds a total of 94 days [FN6]are chargeable to the prosecution for the time period from arraignment (September 4, 2021),through December 7, 2021. Since the prosecution was not ready for trial within 90 days ofcommencement of this criminal action, defendant's motion to dismiss pursuant to CPL §30.30 is granted, and it is ordered that this matter is hereby dismissed.[FN7]
Dated: May 6, 2022
Bronx, New York
Hon. Christopher Chin, J.C.C
Footnote 1:The court notes that the term"substantial compliance" is not contained in the relevant statutes (see CPL § §245.20; 245.50 [1]).
Footnote 2:It does not appear from theparties' submissions or the court's file that the People served and filed a supplemental COC withrespect to the discovery they served on March 4, 2022 (the same day they filed their response todefendant's motion), in accordance with CPL § 245.50 (1).
Footnote 3:It is noted that the defenseinitially inaccurately asserted in its motion that defendant was accused of a felony and the timefor the prosecution to be ready for trial was within six (6) months of commencement of thecriminal action; later, the defense correctly stated the relevant time period for CPL § 30.30purposes is 90 days.
Footnote 4:It is noted that the prosecution,does not dispute that the belatedly disclosed and non-disclosed materials are subject todisclosure.
Footnote 5:The issue of prejudice shouldonly be considered when determining whether the People should be sanctioned or a remedyimposed under CPL § 245.80 for late disclosure or non-disclosure, after a finding that aproper certificate of compliance had been filed (see People v Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d at574-75; People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d at 527).
Footnote 6:The defense incorrectlycalculated 84 days (see Affirmation in Support, at 16).
Footnote 7:September 4, 2021 toOctober 21, 2021 (47 days charged): On September 4, 2021, the accusatory instrument wasfiled, and defendant was arraigned. The People were not ready for trial and the matter wasadjourned to October 21, 2021 for the filing of a supporting deposition and COC. A total offorty-seven (47) days are chargeable to the People for that time period (it is noted that the Peopleincorrectly calculated 48 days for this period [see Response in Opposition, at 6]).