| People v Brown |
| 2023 NY Slip Op 01306 [214 AD3d 823] |
| March 15, 2023 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Appellant, v Timothy Brown, Respondent. |
Thomas E. Walsh, II, District Attorney, New City, NY (Jacob B. Sher of counsel),for appellant.
James D. Licata, New City, NY (Ellen O'Hara Woods of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal by the People from an order of the County Court, Rockland County (Kevin F.Russo, J.), dated April 6, 2021. The order, inter alia, granted the defendant's motionpursuant to CPL 30.30 to dismiss the indictment on the ground that he was deprived ofhis statutory right to a speedy trial, and denied the People's cross motion pursuant to CPL245.70 (2) for an extension of time to serve and file a late certificate of compliance.
Ordered that the order is affirmed.
The facts are undisputed. By indictment filed on November 30, 2018, a grand jurycharged the defendant with two counts of rape in the third degree, and the defendant wasarrested pursuant to an arrest warrant. On December 21, 2018, the defendant wasarraigned and the People announced their readiness for trial. In 2019, the case wasadjourned multiple times. During that time, the People provided certain discovery. OnMarch 6, 2019, the People again announced their readiness for trial. On January 2, 2020,the defendant filed a discovery demand pursuant to the then newly-enacted discoveryreform statute, CPL article 245, and the case was adjourned to February 6, 2020, fordiscovery compliance. Subsequently, the case was adjourned several times, including dueto the court closures resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. At the parties' appearanceon July 22, 2020, defense counsel acknowledged that there was no outstandingdiscovery. Thereafter, the case was adjourned again. At the parties' appearance onOctober 28, 2020, the People renewed their statement of readiness. As trials were still notbeing scheduled due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the case continued to be adjourned. Atthe parties' appearance on March 1, 2021, the County Court indicated that the case couldbe called in for jury selection on April 5, 2021.
On March 19, 2021, the defendant moved to dismiss the indictment for exceeding thespeedy trial requirements of CPL 30.30 (1) (a) as a result of the People's failure to serveand file a certificate of compliance within the speedy trial statutory period. The Peopleopposed and cross-moved pursuant to CPL 245.70 (2) for an extension of time to serveand file a late certificate of compliance. In an order dated April 6, 2021, the CountyCourt granted the defendant's motion and denied the People's cross motion. The Peopleappeal.
"A defendant seeking dismissal of the indictment on speedy trial grounds under CPL[*2]30.30 meets his or her initial burden on the motionsimply by alleging that the People failed to declare readiness within the statutorilyprescribed period" (People vPerkins, 175 AD3d 1327, 1327 [2019]; see People v Santos, 68 NY2d859, 861 [1986]). As of January 1, 2020, the calculation of speedy trial timepursuant to CPL 30.30 is tied to the People's good faith compliance with their mandatorydiscovery obligation under CPL 245.20, which they are required to certify in a certificateof compliance that must accompany or precede any statement of trial readiness(see CPL 30.30 [5]; 245.50 [1], [3]). CPL 245.50 (3) provides, in relevant part:"[A]bsent an individualized finding of special circumstances in the instant case by thecourt before which the charge is pending, the prosecution shall not be deemed ready fortrial for purposes of [CPL 30.30] until it has filed a proper certificate pursuant to [CPL245.50 (1)]." CPL 30.30 (5) reiterates that requirement, providing, in relevant part: "Anystatement of trial readiness must be accompanied or preceded by a certification of goodfaith compliance with the disclosure requirements of [CPL] 245.20." "Generally, theplain meaning of the statutory text is the best evidence of legislative intent" and, "[a]s ageneral rule, unambiguous language of a statute is alone determinative" (People v Galindo, 38 NY3d199, 203 [2022] [internal quotation marks omitted]; see Colon v Martin, 35 NY3d75, 78 [2020]).
"The failure to declare readiness within the statutory time limit will result indismissal of the prosecution, unless the People can demonstrate that certain time periodsshould be excluded" (People vBrown, 28 NY3d 392, 403 [2016] [internal quotation marks omitted]; see People v Price, 14 NY3d61, 63-64 [2010]). Once a defendant has alleged that the People failed to declarereadiness within the statutorily prescribed time period, the burden shifts to the People todemonstrate whether any time periods are to be excluded from the calculation, such thatthe allowable time has not lapsed (see People v Santos, 68 NY2d at 861;People v Perkins, 175 AD3d at 1327).
Here, the County Court properly granted the defendant's motion to dismiss theindictment. Contrary to the People's contention, their October 28, 2020 statement ofreadiness, which, technically, was within the speedy trial time limit, was neverthelessillusory, as they never certified their compliance with their discovery obligation underCPL 245.20 in a certificate of compliance that they were required to file with the courtbefore or at the time they announced their readiness for trial (see CPL 30.30 [5];245.50 [1], [3]). The People's October 28, 2020 statement of readiness was thereforeinsufficient to stop the running of the speedy trial clock (see generally People vBrown, 28 NY3d at 404), and the statutory period to declare readiness had lapsed forspeedy trial purposes as of the time the defendant moved to dismiss the indictment.
The People's remaining contentions are without merit. Brathwaite Nelson, J.P.,Maltese, Ford and Voutsinas, JJ., concur.