| Matter of Albany Basketball & Sports Corp. v City ofAlbany |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 02370 [116 AD3d 1135] |
| April 3, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Albany Basketball & Sports Corporation,Doing Business as Washington Avenue Armory, Appellant, v City of Albany et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] John J. Reilly, Corporation Counsel, Albany (Eric P. Sugar of counsel), forrespondents.
Stein, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Lynch, J.), entered May 22,2013 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceedingpursuant to CPLR article 78, to review a determination of respondent City of AlbanyBoard of Zoning Appeals finding that petitioner's current use of its premises was not apermitted use under the Code of the City of Albany.
Petitioner is the proprietor of the Washington Avenue Armory, which is located inthe City of Albany. The Armory is situated in a commercial office (hereinafter CO)zoning district. Pursuant to a request from petitioner in 2003, respondent City of AlbanyBoard of Zoning Appeals (hereinafter BZA) rendered a determination that, under theCode of the City of Albany (hereinafter Code), certain proposed uses of the Armory wereconsistent with the permitted use of an auditorium within such zoning district. In October2012, various events held at the Armory prompted the Division of Buildings andRegulatory Compliance of respondent City of Albany to issue multiple cease and desistorders alleging that, among other things, the events were not among the permitted usesidentified in the Code. Petitioner did not challenge these orders. [*2]Instead, petitioner and the City entered into a November2012 memorandum of understanding, in which, as is relevant here, petitioner "agree[d] tosubmit an application to the [BZA] for a further interpretation/clarification as to whichevents/uses constitute a permitted use of the premises as an '[a]uditori[um]' " as includedin the Code (see Code of City of Albany § 375-72). In December 2012,petitioner made such application and the BZA thereafter held a public hearing on theissue.[FN1] The BZA issued a determination in March 2013, finding that the "use of the facility for a'Rave' party, nightclub, dance club or other similar event is excluded from the definitionof an '[a]uditori[um]' and thus [is] an illegal use."[FN2] As a result, petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking to annul theBZA's March 2013 determination. Supreme Court dismissed the petition,[FN3] prompting this appeal.
We reverse. Preliminarily, we note that, inasmuch as the BZA's determination waslimited to its interpretation of the term "[a]uditor[ium]" under the Code as applied to theuses now being proposed by petitioner, our review is similarly limited and does notencompass the more general question—which was not before the BZA—ofwhether the proposed uses may be impermissible under any other provision of the Code.Turning to petitioner's arguments, we reject its assertion that the BZA lacked jurisdictionto render its interpretation. General City Law § 81-a (4) provides that, "[u]nlessotherwise provided by local law or ordinance, the jurisdiction of the board of appealsshall be appellate only" (emphasis added). However, as relevant here, Code of City ofAlbany § 375-14 (B) grants the BZA the power "[t]o determine if a use notspecifically listed is consistent with the enumerated uses in one or more specifieddistricts." Contrary to petitioner's argument, such power is not limited to appellatereview. In accordance with the parties' memorandum of understanding and the Code,petitioner requested a determination from the BZA as to whether the proposed uses of theArmory were consistent with the permitted use of an auditorium in a CO-zoned district.Therefore, the BZA had the authority to issue its responsive determination under Code ofCity of Albany § 375-14 (B).
We next address the merits of the BZA's determination. Courts will annul adetermination of a board of zoning appeals only if it is irrational or unreasonable (see Matter of Saratoga CountyEconomic Opportunity Council, Inc. v Village of Ballston Spa Zoning Bd. ofAppeals, 112 AD3d 1035, 1036 [2013]; Matter of Atkinson v Wilt, 94 AD3d 1218, 1219-1220[2012]; Matter of Mack v Boardof Appeals, Town of Homer, 25 AD3d 977, 980 [2006]). Although a reviewingcourt will generally grant deference to the interpretation of an ambiguous zoningordinance by a board of zoning appeals, where, as here, "the issue presented is one ofpure [*3]legal interpretation of the underlying zoning lawor ordinance, deference is not required" (Matter of Subdivisions, Inc. v Town of Sullivan, 92 AD3d1184, 1185 [2012], lv denied 19 NY3d 811 [2012]; accord Matter ofSaratoga County Economic Opportunity Council, Inc. v Village of Ballston Spa ZoningBd. of Appeals, 112 AD3d at 1036; Matter of Atkinson v Wilt, 94 AD3d at1220; see Matter of Blalock vOlney, 17 AD3d 842, 844 [2005]). Moreover, "[z]oning regulations, being inderogation of the common law, must be strictly construed against the municipality whichhas enacted and seeks to enforce them, and any ambiguity in the language used must beresolved in favor of the property owner" (Matter of Hess Realty Corp. v PlanningCommn. of Town of Rotterdam, 198 AD2d 588, 589 [1993]; accord Matter ofAtkinson v Wilt, 94 AD3d at 1220; see Matter of Ohrenstein v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town ofCanaan, 39 AD3d 1041, 1042 [2007]; Van Nostrand v Dalmata, 43AD2d 752, 752 [1973]).
In its application to the BZA, petitioner proposed to use the Armory for "musicalentertainment" events, including those where the audience was "standing for the entireevent." The BZA's conclusion that such proposed use was not permitted in a CO-zoneddistrict was based solely on its interpretation of the term auditorium. Inasmuch as theCode does not contain a definition of that term,[FN4] we look to its ordinary meaning (see Matter of Saratoga County EconomicOpportunity Council, Inc. v Village of Ballston Spa Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 112AD3d at 1037; Matter ofOefelein v Town of Thompson Planning Bd., 9 AD3d 556, 557 [2004];Matter of McGrath v Town Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 254 AD2d 614, 619[1998], lv denied 93 NY2d 803 [1999]).
The BZA correctly noted that certain dictionaries define an "auditorium" as "the areaof a concert hall, theatre, school, etc, in which the audience sits" (Harper Collins OnlineDictionary, http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/ auditorium [accessedFeb. 28, 2014] [British English Dictionary]) or as "the part of a public building where anaudience sits" (Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary,http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/auditorium [accessed Feb. 28, 2014]).Based on these definitions, the BZA determined that petitioner's use of the Armory for a" 'Rave' party, nightclub, dance club, or other similar event" was inconsistent with thepermitted use of an auditorium, because such events did not provide for "actual fixedseating."[FN5] However, the BZA ignored alternative [*4]definitions ofan auditorium—set forth in the same dictionaries it used—as "a building forpublic gatherings or meetings"(http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/american/auditorium [accessed Feb. 28,2014]) or "a large room or building where people gather to watch a performance, hear aspeech, etc." (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/auditorium [accessed Feb. 28,2014]), which make no reference to an audience sitting.[FN6] Even if petitioner's proposed uses of the Armory are inconsistent with the definitionsrelied on by the BZA, they are entirely consistent with the commonly used alternativedefinitions. Resolving, as we must, any ambiguity in favor of petitioner, we conclude thatthe BZA's determination that the proposed use was impermissible—based solelyupon its limited interpretation of the definition of auditorium as requiring fixed seating,to the exclusion of other commonly accepted definitions—was irrational andunreasonable (see Matter of Saratoga County Economic Opportunity Council, Inc. vVillage of Ballston Spa Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 112 AD3d at 1038; Matter ofAtkinson v Wilt, 94 AD3d at 1220-1221; Van Nostrand v Dalmata, 43AD2d at 753) and must be annulled.[FN7]
To the extent not specifically addressed herein, petitioner's remaining contentionshave been considered and found to be either academic or without merit.
Peters, P.J., McCarthy and Rose, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is reversed,on the law, without costs, petition granted and determination annulled. [Prior CaseHistory: 40 Misc 3d 578.]
Footnote 1: While the BZA'sdetermination was pending, and in response to an Armory event held in March 2013, theCity issued an additional order to petitioner to cease and desist from holding " 'RavePart[ies]' or similar function[s]." Petitioner appealed that order to the BZA.
Footnote 2: Petitioner contests,among other things, the BZA's characterization of the events in question as "Rave"parties, and asserts that they are akin to a "concert."
Footnote 3: As a result of the BZA'sMarch 2013 determination, Supreme Court, in a separate order, dismissed as mootpetitioner's application for a stay of the March 2013 cease and desist order.
Footnote 4: Notably, the Code doesprovide definitions of, among other things, a nightclub and a dance club (Code of City ofAlbany § 375-7 [B]), neither of which is listed as a permitted use in a CO-zoneddistrict. However, the BZA did not rest its determination on a finding that petitioner'sproposed use satisfied all of the elements of those definitions. Instead, the BZA referredto those definitions to differentiate them from an auditorium and concluded that "eventsconducted without fixed seating for each patron do not constitute an '[a]uditori[um]' andare therefore not permitted in a [CO] Zoning District."
Footnote 5: We note that thisinterpretation of the term auditorium would seemingly disallow other proposed events atthe Armory—such as trade shows, conventions, flea markets and other generalassembly events—which have never been at issue or determined to beimpermissible uses under the Code and for which the BZA previously gave its approval.
Footnote 6: Notably, RandomHouse Webster's definition is completely silent as to seating, and defines the term as "thespace set apart for the audience in a theater, school, or other public building" or "abuilding for public gatherings; hall" (Random House Webster's Unabridged Dictionary135 [2d ed 1999]).
Footnote 7: We also rejectrespondents' assertion that the BZA's 2013 determination was a consistent corollary of itsapproval of petitioner's proposed uses of the Armory in 2003. The 2003 approval wasbased on a different and more narrow issue presented to the BZA at that time.