| Matter of Ippolito v Commissioner of N.Y. State Dept. ofTaxation & Fin. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 02475 [116 AD3d 1176] |
| April 10, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Frederick P. Ippolito,Petitioner, v Commissioner of New York State Department of Taxation andFinance et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Owen Demuth of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Stein, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant toTax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalwhich sustained a sales and use tax assessment imposed under Tax Law articles 28 and29.
Cai Restaurant, Inc. operates a restaurant, pizzeria, wine cellar and steak houseknown as Christiano's, and petitioner is its chairperson and/or chief executive officer. In2006, the Department of Taxation and Finance conducted a field audit of Cai's businessoperations in connection with outstanding sales and use taxes owed for the periodSeptember 1, 2003 through May 31, 2006. After the audit, the Department issued anotice of determination assessing petitioner for outstanding sales and use taxes owed byCai totaling $66,620.28, plus interest.[FN1][*2]Petitioner sought a redetermination of the assessmentby the Division of Tax Appeals and the parties stipulated to have the matter decided byan Administrative Law Judge (hereinafter ALJ) without a hearing. The ALJ sustained thenotice of determination after concluding—based on the documentssubmitted—that, as a corporate officer of Cai, petitioner was authorized to act onits behalf and was, therefore, personally liable for the tax deficiency under Tax Law§§ 1131 (1) and 1133 (a). Petitioner filed a notice of exception withrespondent Tax Appeals Tribunal, arguing that he had only temporarily acted on behalfof his wife—who was ill[FN2]—through a power of attorney and was not actively involved in the management ofthe corporation. The Tribunal rejected this argument and affirmed the ALJ's decision.This CPLR article 78 proceeding ensued.
We confirm. Tax Law § 1133 (a) imposes personal liability on any person whois responsible for collecting tax under Tax Law article 28. A person required to collecttax (a responsible person) includes "any officer, director or employee of a corporation. . . who . . . is under a duty to act for such corporation. . . in complying with any requirement of [Tax Law article 28]" (Tax Law§ 1131 [1]). Whether a person has a duty to act for a corporation and is responsiblefor collecting sales tax is a factual determination to be made on a case by case basis(see Matter of Cohen v State Tax Commn., 128 AD2d 1022, 1023 [1987]; 20NYCRR 526.11 [b] [1], [2]). The factors that the courts have considered relevant to thisdetermination include (1) authority to sign corporate checks, (2) responsibility formanaging the corporation and maintaining its books, (3) ability to hire and fireemployees, (4) status as a corporate officer, and (5) receipt of substantial income fromthe corporation or stock ownership (see Matter of Hall v Tax Appeals Trib. of Stateof N.Y., 176 AD2d 1006, 1006 [1991]; Matter of Cohen v State TaxCommn., 128 AD2d at 1023; Matter of Blodnick v New York State TaxCommn., 124 AD2d 437, 437 [1986], appeal dismissed 69 NY2d 822[1987]). Significantly, this Court has stressed that "[w]hat must be considered is [theperson's] authority and responsibility to exercise control over the corporation, not his[or her] actual assertion of such authority" (Matter of Coppola v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37AD3d 901, 903 [2007] [emphasis added]).
Here, an enrolled agent retained by petitioner to contest the notice of determinationcompleted a questionnaire representing that petitioner (1) was responsible for preparingor supervising the preparation of corporate sales tax returns, (2) participated in makingsignificant business decisions, (3) maintained and managed the business, (4) ownedcorporate and voting stock, (5) had the authority to manage financial affairs, pay or directpayment of credits, sign checks and act on behalf of the corporation in dealing with theDepartment and (6) had the authority to hire and fire employees. The enrolled agent alsolisted petitioner as the president of the corporation on another questionnaire, which wasconsistent with records of the Secretary of State indicating that petitioner was thecorporation's sole chairperson and/or chief executive officer. Notwithstanding evidencethat petitioner's wife may also have been a corporate officer [*3]involved in the management of the corporation,[FN3]it is apparent—despite his denials—that petitioner retained the authority toact as a corporate officer and, in such capacity, was fully capable of undertaking many ofthe duties necessary to manage the corporation. Indeed, his ability to step in and overseethe operation of the business while his wife was ill underscores the authenticity of hisauthority. In view of this, and given that the controlling consideration is petitioner'sauthority to act on behalf of a corporation, not the degree to which he actually exercisedthat authority (see Matter of Coppola v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37AD3d at 903), the Tribunal's determination that petitioner was a responsible person andwas personally liable under Tax Law §§ 1131 (1) and 1133 (a) for theoutstanding sales and use taxes owed by Cai is "rationally based upon and supported bysubstantial evidence," despite the existence of record evidence that would support acontrary conclusion (Matter ofIngle v Tax Appeals Trib. of the Dept. of Taxation & Fin. of the State of N.Y., 110AD3d 1392, 1393 [2013] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Hwang v TaxAppeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 105 AD3d 1151, 1152 [2013]). Therefore,we decline to disturb it.
Lahtinen, J.P., McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote 1: The Department alsoissued a notice of determination assessing Cai for a sales and use tax deficiency ofapproximately $160,000, including interest, for the entire period covered by the audit.Although Cai initially filed a petition contesting the assessment, it later withdrew thepetition. The assessment issued against petitioner was only for a portion of the auditperiod.
Footnote 2: Petitioner's wife passedaway during the course of the proceedings.
Footnote 3: To the extent thatpetitioner relies on certain documents which were not part of the administrative record toestablish that he was not a responsible person (see Tax Law § 1131 [1]),we decline to consider them (seeMatter of Huszar v Bayview Park Props., LLC, 109 AD3d 922, 924-925 [2013];Matter of Dolan v New York State Dept. of Civ. Serv., 304 AD2d 1037, 1039[2003], lv denied 100 NY2d 512 [2003]).