| Evarts v Pyro Eng'g, Inc. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 02996 [117 AD3d 1148] |
| May 1, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| Lisa J. Evarts, Appellant, v Pyro Engineering, Inc., etal., Respondents. (And a Third-Party Action.) |
Conway & Kirby, LLP, Latham (Andrew W. Kirby of counsel), forappellant.
Pinsky & Skandalis, Syracuse (George Skandalis of counsel), forrespondents.
Egan Jr., J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Meyer, J.), enteredDecember 26, 2012 in Essex County, which granted defendants' motion for summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint.
In July 2008, plaintiff, a Vermont resident, was camping at Roger's RockCampground on the shores of Lake George in Warren County with her husband,daughter and her daughter's friend. On the evening of July 4, 2008, plaintiff and the restof her group, together with two additional friends, went to get ice cream and watch afireworks display that was being held at the little league field located in BicentennialPark on Burgoyne Road in the Town of Ticonderoga, Essex County. The fireworksdisplay, which was an annual event for the Town, was designed, set up and executed bydefendants.
Defendants' representatives described the setup and ignition process for the fireworksdisplay as follows. The actual fireworks or shells are placed inside of fiberglass tubesknown as mortars, and the mortars, in turn, are placed inside of wooden racks that arearranged according to the design for the show. Once the racks are in place, they are"daisy chain[ed]" or secured to one another, and "A" frames are nailed to the end of eachrow for additional stability. During the course of the show, a technician would hand lighteach shell, which contained a three- or four-second safety fuse, with a road flare. Theflame would burn down to the lift charge, which would [*2]propel the shell out of the mortar and ignite the timer fuse,the length of which depended upon the duration of lift desired for each shell. The timerfuse would then ignite the burst charge, which would open the shell and create thestarburst patterns in the night sky. The "shell count" for the Ticonderoga display was1,075 shells and 1,500 illuminations;[FN1]
this count included—insofar as is relevant here—75 six-inch mortars,which were secured three to a rack. According to defendants' representatives, industrystandards required a safety radius of 70 feet per inch based upon the largest mortarutilized, resulting in a radius of 420 feet for the Ticonderoga show.
On the evening in question, plaintiff and her group arrived at the little league fieldaround 9:00 p.m., parked, "walked across the street" and sat on the grass "fairly close tothe road" to watch the show. Approximately 30 to 40 minutes into the show, one of thesix-inch shells malfunctioned and detonated inside of the mortar.[FN2]
According to one of defendants' representatives, this occurrence is known as a "blowby" and results from "a flaw in the seal of the time fuse." This flaw, in turn, "allows thelift charge to bypass the time fuse and get to the core of the shell," causing the shell todetonate in the mortar. When this shell malfunctioned, it destroyed the rack in which itwas housed—causing another mortar in the rack to become dislodged. Theexplosion from the malfunctioning shell apparently ignited the dislodged shell, causingthe dislodged shell to be propelled—horizontally—"directly into thecrowd," eventually striking a spectator's cooler and detonating.[FN3]
As this second shell approached plaintiff and her group, plaintiff pivoted to her rightand attempted to shield her daughter and her daughter's friend. During this process,plaintiff's right hand, which had been resting on the ground, slipped on the grass.Plaintiff immediately felt a "pop" and pain in that hand, and a subsequent MRI revealed atorn collateral ligament necessitating surgical intervention.
Plaintiff thereafter commenced this negligence and strict products liability actionagainst defendants seeking to recover for injuries to her hand.[FN4]
Following joinder of issue and discovery, defendants moved for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint, contending that they owed no duty to plaintiff.[FN5]
Supreme Court granted defendants' motion and dismissed the complaint in itsentirety, prompting this appeal by plaintiff.
[*3] Absent evidence that defendant manufactured, sold, distributed or otherwisemarketed the fireworks in question, Supreme Court properly granted defendantssummary judgment dismissing plaintiff's strict products liability claim. We reach acontrary conclusion, however, with respect to Supreme Court's dismissal of plaintiff'snegligence claim and, therefore, Supreme Court's order must be modified to thatextent.
To establish a prima facie case of negligence, the plaintiff is required to demonstratethat the defendant owed a duty to him or her, that the defendant breached that duty andthat such breach was a proximate cause of the injuries sustained (see Ortega v Liberty Holdings,LLC, 111 AD3d 904, 906 [2013]; Merchants Mut. Ins. Co. v Quality Signs of Middletown, 110AD3d 1042, 1043 [2013]). "The existence and scope of [the] alleged tortfeasor'sduty is, in the first instance, a legal question for determination by thecourt"—giving due consideration to "whether the relationship of the parties is suchas to give rise to a duty of care, whether the plaintiff was within the zone of foreseeableharm and whether the accident was within the reasonably foreseeable risks" (DiPonzio v Riordan, 89 NY2d 578, 583 [1997] [citations omitted]; see Dance Magic, Inc. v PikeRealty, Inc., 85 AD3d 1083, 1088-1089 [2011]; Kemper v Arnow, 18 AD3d939, 940-941 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 708 [2005]). Once it is determinedthat a particular duty exists, whether—and the extent to which—that dutywas breached and whether any such breach was a proximate cause of the plaintiff'sinjuries generally are factual issues for the trier of fact to resolve (see Grant v Nembhard, 94AD3d 1397, 1398 [2012]; Finnigan v Lasher, 90 AD3d 1286, 1287 [2011]; MacDonald v New York StateOlympic Regional Dev. Auth., 46 AD3d 1085, 1086 [2007]).
Here, defendants possessed, furnished, set up and ignited "a large supply ofdangerous fireworks" (Morang v Burnett, 216 AD2d 835, 836 [1995]) and, assuch, were bound to exercise "a high degree of care" in order to prevent injury to others(Travell v Bannerman, 174 NY 47, 51 [1903]; accord Morang v Burnett,216 AD2d at 836). As to the foreseeability of a malfunction, one of defendants'representatives testified at his examination before trial that, although he had notexperienced a "blow by" prior to the Ticonderoga show, such an event was "anoccurrence in the industry," that "the chance for a malfunction [was] obviously there"and that malfunctions can be dangerous. As to whether plaintiff was in the zone offoreseeable harm, plaintiff estimated that she was sitting approximately 700 feet fromwhere the shells were being launched (well outside the purported safety radius) and, asnoted previously, acknowledged that the debris from the first malfunctioning shell didnot reach her location. Plaintiff also testified, however, that the second shell exploded"[v]ery close" to where she was sitting, causing sparks to land around her group, and oneof defendants' representatives conceded that "hot flaming debris" from this second shellwas propelled into the crowd of spectators. Further, when plaintiff returned to the ballfield the following day, she observed scorch marks on the grass—presumablycaused by flaming debris from the detonated shell—approximately 20 feet awayfrom where she had been sitting. Moreover, the police report prepared in this mattermakes reference to a witness who claimed that the second shell exploded "15-20 feetaway from the civilians sitting by Burgoyne [R]oad." Under these circumstances, we aresatisfied that plaintiff was within the zone of foreseeable harm (compare Lynfatt v Escobar, 71AD3d 743, 744-745 [2010], lv denied 15 NY3d 709 [2010]). Accordingly,Supreme Court erred in finding that defendants owed no duty to plaintiff.
As to the issues of breach and proximate cause, suffice it to say that questions of factpreclude an award of summary judgment to defendants with respect to plaintiff'snegligence claim. Even assuming that defendants were in compliance with all applicablefederal, state, local [*4]and industry regulations andstandards—facts that have yet to be established—the record nonethelesscontains numerous references to the allegedly disorganized nature of the fireworks showand the purported difficulties that defendants' technicians were having with detonatingthe devices—as well as one technician's alleged insistence that "the show go on"even after the shells malfunctioned. To the extent that defendants contend that they couldnot possibly foresee the manner in which plaintiff was injured, we note that plaintiff wasnot required to "demonstrate the foreseeability of the precise manner in which theaccident occurred or the precise type of harm produced in order to establish theforeseeability component of [her negligence claim]" (Di Ponzio v Riordan, 89NY2d at 583-584; see Derdiarian v Felix Contr. Corp., 51 NY2d 308, 315[1980]). In short, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to plaintiff as thenonmoving party (see U.W.Marx, Inc. v Koko Contr., Inc., 97 AD3d 893, 894 [2012]), we cannot say thatdefendants established—as a matter of law—that they were without legalresponsibility for plaintiff's injuries.
Lahtinen, J.P., McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified,on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as granted that part ofdefendants' motion for summary judgment dismissing plaintiff's negligence cause ofaction; motion denied to that extent; and, as so modified, affirmed.
Footnote 1:Illuminations, which areconsidered to be "ground displays," are propelled between 75 and 200 feet into the air.
Footnote 2:Plaintiff saw the firstshell detonate, but stated that the sparks and debris therefrom did not come near whereshe and her group were sitting.
Footnote 3:The resulting explosionwas captured on video, and the record contains still photographs from that videodisplaying a significant detonation.
Footnote 4:Although PyroEngineering, Inc. and Bay Fireworks each are named defendants, it appears that BayFireworks is the "doing business as" for Pyro Engineering, Inc.
Footnote 5:Defendants alsocommenced a third-party action against July 4 Ever, Inc., the entity from which theypurchased some of the shells used during the Ticonderoga show.