Matter of Adirondack Historical Assn. v Village of Lake Placid/LakePlacid Vil., Inc.
2018 NY Slip Op 03194 [161 AD3d 1256]
May 3, 2018
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 27, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Adirondack Historical Association,Petitioner,
v
Village of Lake Placid/Lake Placid Village, Inc.,Respondent.

McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP, Glens Falls (Eric C. Schwenker of counsel), forpetitioner.

E. Stewart Jones Hacker Murphy LLP, Troy (Patrick L. Seely Jr. of counsel), forrespondent.

Mulvey, J. Proceeding initiated in this Court pursuant to EDPL 207 to review adetermination of respondent condemning two parcels of petitioner's real property for the purposeof constructing a parking garage in connection with a redevelopment project.

In 2017, the Lake Placid Village Board of Trustees (hereinafter the Village Board) beganconsideration of a plan to redevelop Main Street in the Village of Lake Placid, Essex County.The plan, described as the "Lake Placid Main Street Reconstruction Project," included theacquisition of two vacant parcels of real property owned by petitioner, a not-for-profitcorporation, located at 2476-2478 Main Street (hereinafter the subject property) for the purposeof constructing a public parking garage. The Village Board thereafter reviewed the environmentalimpacts associated with the redevelopment project under the State Environmental QualityReview Act (see ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) and adopted a negative declaration ofenvironmental significance in February 2017.

After attempts by the Village Board to negotiate the purchase of the subject property provedunsuccessful, respondent opted to proceed with acquisition under the authority of the EminentDomain Procedure Law. As a result, the Village Board engaged in a new SEQRA processspecifically with regard to the proposed condemnation. Following a public hearing and a [*2]written comment period, and upon review of an environmentalassessment form (hereinafter EAF) prepared by an engineering consultant, the Village Boarddetermined that the action would not create the potential for any negative environmental impactsand issued resolutions authorizing condemnation of the subject property. Petitioner thereaftercommenced this proceeding challenging the Village Board's determination.

Initially, we reject petitioner's contention that the SEQRA review process was impermissiblysegmented. Segmentation is "the division of the environmental review of an action such thatvarious activities or stages are addressed [for purposes of environmental quality review] asthough they were independent, unrelated activities, needing individual determinations ofsignificance" (6 NYCRR 617.2 [ag]). While there is no question that condemnation of the subjectproperty for the purpose of constructing a parking garage was related to the broader Main Streetredevelopment project, it is equally clear that the segmented review that occurred here was notimpermissibly undertaken "for the purpose of circumventing the detailed review called for underSEQRA" (Matter of Forman v Trustees of State Univ. of N.Y., 303 AD2d 1019, 1020[2003] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Saratoga Springs Preserv. Found. v Boff, 110 AD3d1326, 1328 [2013]; Matter ofFriends of Stanford Home v Town of Niskayuna, 50 AD3d 1289, 1290 [2008], lvdenied 10 NY3d 716 [2008]). Rather, it took place due to the fact that the Village Board wasunaware of its need to exercise its power of eminent domain to condemn the subject property atthe time of its SEQRA review with respect to the redevelopment project. Inasmuch as the VillageBoard "set[ ] forth the reasons supporting segmentation and 'demonstrate[d] that such review isclearly no less protective of the environment' " (Matter of Defreestville AreaNeighborhoods Assn. v Town Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 299 AD2d 631, 634 [2002],quoting 6 NYCRR 617.3 [g] [1]), we are satisfied that impermissible segmented review did notoccur here (see Matter of Saratoga Springs Preserv. Found. v Boff, 110 AD3d at 1328;Matter of Friends of Stanford Home v Town of Niskayuna, 50 AD3d at 1291; Matterof Concerned Citizens for Envt. v Zagata, 243 AD2d 20, 22 [1998], lv denied 92NY2d 808 [1998]; compare Matter of J.Owens Bldg. Co., Inc. v Town of Clarkstown, 128 AD3d 1067, 1068-1069 [2015]).

We do agree, however, with petitioner's contention that the record fails to establish that theVillage Board took the requisite hard look at potential traffic implications associated with theconstruction of a parking garage on the subject property or to set forth a reasoned elaboration ofthe basis for its determination that the development of the property would not result in anysubstantial increase in traffic. Upon review of an eminent domain proceeding, courts are requiredto determine whether the condemnor's findings and determinations comply with ECL article 8,which is incorporated as part of the required procedures under EDPL article 2 (see EDPL207 [C] [3]; Matter of Davis HoldingCo., LLC v Village of Margaretville, 55 AD3d 1101, 1103-1104 [2008]; Matter of Stefanis v Village ofFleischmanns, 43 AD3d 581, 583 [2007]; Matter of Board of Coop. Educ. Servs. ofAlbany-Schoharie-Schenectady-Saratoga Counties v Town of Colonie, 268 AD2d 838, 839[2000]). In assessing compliance with the substantive mandates of SEQRA, we are tasked withreviewing the record to determine whether the Village Board, as the lead agency, "identified therelevant areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them, and made a reasonedelaboration of the basis for its determination" (Matter of Jackson v New York State UrbanDev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted];see Matter of Gernatt Asphalt Prods. v Town of Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 688 [1996];Matter of WEOK Broadcasting Corp. v Planning Bd. of Town of Lloyd, 79 NY2d 373,381 [1992]; Matter of City ofMechanicville v Town of Halfmoon, 23 AD3d 897, 900 [2005]). "Literal compliancewith both the letter and spirit of SEQRA is required and substantial compliance will not suffice"(Matter of Board of Coop. Educ. Servs. of Albany-Schoharie-Schenectady-Saratoga Countiesv Town of Colonie, 268 AD2d at 840[*3][internal quotationmarks, brackets and citations omitted]; see Matter of Dawley v Whitetail 414, LLC, 130 AD3d 1570, 1571[2015]).

Because acquisition of the subject property was considered an unlisted action, a short formEAF was prepared (see 6 NYCRR 617.6 [a] [3]). The Village Board was thus required to"review the EAF, the criteria contained in [6 NYCRR 617.7 (c)] and any other supportinginformation to identify the relevant areas of environmental concern; . . . thoroughlyanalyze the identified relevant areas of environmental concern to determine if the action mayhave a significant adverse impact on the environment; and . . . set forth itsdetermination of significance in a written form containing a reasoned elaboration and providingreference to any supporting documentation" (6 NYCRR 617.7 [b] [2], [3], [4]). An adversechange in traffic levels is such a potential area of environmental concern (see 6 NYCRR617.7 [c] [1] [i]).

During both the public hearing and the written comment period, concerns regardingincreased traffic congestion and other potential traffic impacts associated with the proposedcondemnation were repeatedly voiced. Yet, the record is bereft of any evidence that the VillageBoard took the requisite hard look at these potential traffic implications. Indeed, the sum total ofthe proof of the Village Board's "hard look" is its negative response to the question on the EAF asto whether there would be a substantial increase in traffic above present levels—madewithout articulating a reasoned elaboration for the basis of such determination—and thewholly conclusory statement in its resolution that "[t]here is no significant environmental impactthat could not be mitigated with reasonable measures."[FN*] While respondent claims that an adequatereview of the environmental impacts associated with the proposed construction of the parkinggarage occurred during the Village Board's review of the broader Main Street redevelopmentproject, without record evidence of any such prior review, there is no indication "of anymeaningful investigation into this area of environmental concern" (Matter of Kittredge v Planning Bd. of Townof Liberty, 57 AD3d 1336, 1337-1338 [2008]). In light of this, and given the wholesalefailure on the part of the Village Board to set forth a record-based elaboration for its conclusionthat the identified traffic concerns were not significant, the SEQRA findings and determinationsmade in connection with the condemnation of the subject property must be vacated (see Matter of Baker v Village ofElmsford, 70 AD3d 181, 190 [2009]; Matter of Kittredge v Planning Bd. of Town ofLiberty, 57 AD3d at 1338; Matter ofFleck v Town of Colden, 16 AD3d 1052, 1054 [2005]; Matter of Board of Coop.Educ. Servs. of Albany-Schoharie-Schenectady-Saratoga Counties v Town of Colonie, 268AD2d at 840; Matter of Niagara Mohawk Power Corp. v Green Is. Power Auth., 265AD2d 711, 712 [1999], appeals dismissed 94 NY2d 891 [2000]; Matter of WestBranch Conservation Assn. v Planning Bd., Town of Ramapo, 177 AD2d 917, 918[1991]).

Petitioner's remaining contention has been rendered academic by our determination.

Egan Jr., J.P., Lynch, Devine and Clark, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isannulled, with costs, and petition granted.

Footnotes


Footnote *:At oral argument, counsel forrespondent conceded that this record is silent as to an analysis of traffic impacts, either as part ofits "hard look" or with respect to a "reasoned elaboration" of its negative declaration in the EAF.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.