[*1]
People v Salters
2021 NY Slip Op 50800(U) [72 Misc 3d 1219(A)]
Decided on August 20, 2021
District Court Of Nassau County, First District
Engel, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on August 20, 2021
District Court of Nassau County, First District


The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff,

against

Kyle Salters, Defendant.




Docket No. CR-027513-19NA



Acting Nassau County District Attorney: Joyce A. Smith
Attorney forDefendant: David Zeitlin

 

Andrew M. Engel, J.

 

Papers Submitted:

Notice Motion 1

Affirmation in Support 2

Affirmation in Opposition3

Reply Affirmation 4

On October 26, 2019, the Defendant was arraigned and charged with driving whileintoxicated, stopping/standing/parking on a highway and driving on the shoulder, in violation ofVTL §§ 1192(3), 1201(a) and 1131, respectively.

On or about December 29, 2020, the People filed and served a Certificate of Compliancewith Initial Discovery and a Certificate of Readiness for Trial. The Certificate of Compliancerepresented "that the People have exercised due diligence and made reasonable inquires toascertain the existence of material and information subject to discovery under C.P.L. §245.20(1) and have disclosed and made available all known material and information subject todiscovery."

After several adjournments, on April 20, 2021, both sides indicated that they were ready toproceed with pre-trial hearings that day. Moments before calling their first witness, the Peopledisclosed, for the first time, that had they obtained a letter of censure which had been issuedagainst the arresting trooper, involving a motor vehicle collision in which he had been involved,and that there is a pending personnel complaint against the assisting trooper regarding anallegation of excessive force used in a driving while intoxicated matter. At that time, the Peopleprovided defense counsel with the letter of censure for the arresting trooper.

Upon questioning by the court, the People acknowledged that they had neither obtained norprovided defense counsel with disciplinary records for either the arresting or assisting trooper.When asked if the People had requested such records from the New York State Police [*2]before the People filed their Certificate of Compliance, theAssistant District Attorney ("ADA") handling the matter first responded, "No, but I believe at thetime of filing that would not have been required." (Transcript 4/20/21, p. 7 l. 5-6) TheADA then indicated that she had been informed that her office "made requests of every lawenforcement agency which includes the New York State Police for them to provide us with alldisciplinary records of every trooper which would of course then include both testifying troopersin this case." (Transcript 4/20/21, p. 9 l. 17-22) The ADA then acknowledged that as ofthe hearing date she still did not have the relevant troopers' disciplinary records. When pressedabout the efforts made to obtain these records, the ADA reiterated, "We've made requests."(Transcript 4/20/21, p. 9 l. 25) Finally, when specifically asked by the court when theserequests were made, to whom the requests were made, who made the requests, what was theresponse, what was received, what was not yet received, and when they will be received, theADA requested, "that before especially given that there hasn't been a motion made, even if one ismade, I would ask that we have the opportunity as we are entitled to by statute in terms ofresponding to the motion, I would ask that we are given that opportunity to provide the courtwith the information that would substantiate my representations that we have made efforts."(Transcript 4/20/21, p. 12 l. 5-12)

The Defendant now moves for an order striking the People's Certificate of Compliance anddismissing the accusatory instruments pursuant to CPL §§ 170.30 and 30.30.



CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE

The Defendant argues that the representations the People made in their Certificate ofCompliance, that they "have exercised due diligence and made reasonable inquires to ascertainthe existence of material and information subject to discovery under C.P.L. § 245.20(1) andhave disclosed and made available all known material and information subject to discovery .,"are erroneous. According to the Defendant, given the fact that four months after filing theirCertificate of Compliance, the People, for the first time, acknowledged the existence ofdisciplinary records for the testifying troopers which had not been delivered or made available tothe Defendant, "[t]he Certificate of Compliance therefore cannot be said to be 'proper' under CPL§ 245.50(3)." (Zeitlin Affirmation, 5/5/21, ¶ 17)

The People acknowledge that CPL § 245.20(1)(k) requires them to disclose anyinformation or evidence that tends to impeach the credibility of a witness before they may file aCertificate of Compliance and Certificate of Readiness. The People also concede that, " Here, thefiling of the certificate of compliance and certificate of readiness preceded the disclosure of theletters of censure." (Greenberg Affirmation 7/6/21, p. 2) The People, nevertheless,challenge the timing of the Defendant's motion, brought only after the court questioned thePeople concerning their belated and incomplete disclosure of the disciplinary records of the twoNew York State Trooper witnesses they intended to call at the hearing. The People also assertthat the letter of censure is not impeachment material, is sufficient compliance with theirdiscovery obligation and that the Defendant was not prejudiced by this late disclosure, given thefact that the Defendant could review the letter of censure and question the trooper about itscontents.

On January 1, 2020 the newly enacted CPL Article 245 became effective and CPL Article240 was simultaneously repealed. The new discovery statute significantly expanded the People'sdiscovery obligations, providing for "a presumption in favor of disclosure[,]" CPL §245.20(7), See: People v.Porter, 71 Misc 3d 187, 142 N.Y.S.3d 703 (Crim. Ct. Bronx Co. 2020); People v.Georgiopolos, 71 Misc 3d 1215(A), 144 N.Y.S.3d 344 (Sup. Ct. Queens Co. 2021) andrelieving defendants of their former obligation to demand discovery, placing the [*3]affirmative obligation on the People to comply with their automaticdiscovery obligations, as set forth in CPL §§ 245.10 and 245.20(1)(a-u). See:People v. Villamar, 69 Misc 3d842, 132 N.Y.S.3d 593, (Crim. Ct. NY Co. 2020); People v. DeMilio, 66 Misc 3d 759, 117 N.Y.S.3d 830 (County Ct.Dutchess Co. 2020); People v.Lobato, 66 Misc 3d 1230(A), 122 N.Y.S.3d 492 (Crim. Ct. Kings Co. 2020)

CPL § 245.20(1) provides a non-exhaustive list of the items the People must disclose.Among them, CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) mandates the disclosure of "All evidence andinformation, including that which is known to police or other law enforcement agencies acting onthe government's behalf in the case, that tends to: impeach the credibility of a testifyingprosecution witness ." As appropriately noted in People v. McKinney, 71 Misc 3d 1221(A), 145 N.Y.S3d 328(Crim. Ct. Kings Co. 2021), this statutory obligation is broader than the People's Brady[FN1]and Giglio [FN2] obligations, as they existed prior to the enactment of Article 245:

While the list of items for which disclosure is required may have been partiallydrawn from Brady, see e.g. William C. Donnino, Practice Commentary,McKinney's Cons. Laws of NY C.P.L. § 245.10, the People's specific discovery obligationsunder C.P.L. § 245.20(1)(k) go beyond the Supreme Court's mandate in Brady v.Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963). Importantly, the statute abandons the 'materiality' requirementof Brady, see 373 U.S. at 87, in favor of broader disclosures, encompassing 'all evidenceand information' which 'tends to impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness ...irrespective of whether the prosecutor credits the information.' C.P.L. § 245.20(1)(k). Moreexpansive than Brady, C.P.L. § 245.20(1) also requires the disclosure of 'allevidence and information' (emphasis added), without regard for whether such evidenceand information is already known to the defendant, or was previously disclosed in a differentform. Compare People v.LaValle, 3 NY3d 88 (2004).



See also: People v. Castellanos, 72 Misc 3d371, 148 N.Y.S.3d652 (Sup. Ct. Bronx Co. 2021); People v. Rosario, 70 Misc 3d 753, 139 N.Y.S.3d 498 (Co. Ct.Albany Co. 2020) Similarly, "impeachment evidence and information is not limited to that whichis related to the subject matter of the underlying case." People v. Williams, 72 Misc 3d1214(A), 2021 NY Slip Op. 50743(U) (Crim. Ct. NY Co. 2021); See also: People v. Altug, 70 Misc 3d1218(A), 139 N.Y.S.3d 791 (Crim. Ct. NY Co. 2021) As noted in People v. Soto,2021 NY Slip Op. 21204, 2021 WL 3355998 (Crim. Ct. NY Co. 2021)

Impeachment evidence and information is that which concerns the credibility of theofficer witness — regardless of the subject matter of the charges against the defendant (People v. Smith, 27 NY3d 652, 36N.Y.S.3d 861, 57 N.E.3d 53 [2016] [cross-examination concerning any immoral, vicious orcriminal act which may affect witness' character and show unworthiness of belief]; People v.Beal, supra. (same); People v. Altug, supra.).



As this court has previously detailed, in People v. Herrera, 71 Misc 3d 1205 142 N.Y.S.3d 791 (District Ct.Nassau Co. 2021), the People's discovery obligation pursuant to CPL § 245.20(1)(k),particularly in light of the repeal of Civil Rights Law § 50-a, includes "'any record created infurtherance of a law enforcement disciplinary proceeding' (Public Officers Law [*4]86[6], seealso, Buffalo Police Benevolent Association, Inc. v. Brown, 69 Misc 3d 998 [Sup Ct,Erie County October 9, 2020])." Peoplev. Cooper, 71 Misc 3d 559, 143 N.Y.S.3d 805 (Co. Ct. Erie Co. 2021); See also:People v. Perez, 71 Misc 3d1214(A), 144 N.Y.S.3d 332 (Crim. Ct. Bronx Co. 2021) This is consistent with the plainlanguage of CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv), which mandates the disclosure of "Allevidence and information that tends to impeach the credibility of a testifyingprosecution witness[.]" (emphasis added) This cannot mean simply summaries of disciplinaryrecords or officers' self-reporting questionnaires. See: People v. Williams, supra.,People v. Cooper, supra., People v. McKinney, 71 Misc 3d 1221(A) (Crim. Ct. Kings Co.2021) "All" must mean "all," See: People v. Castellanos, supra., and "evidence"must include the actual documents, not just "information."

It is not for the People to decide, in the first instance, if a particular item from a disciplinaryrecord might be admissible or might impeach a witness. The clear scope of the statute removesthat discretion from the People. People v. Williams, supra., People v.Soto, supra., People v. Porter, supra. These items must be disclosed"regardless of whether the prosecutor finds the information to be 'material' or 'credible.'" CPL§ 245.20(1)(k); People v.Suprenant, 69 Misc 3d 685, 130 N.Y.S.3d 633 (City Ct. Glens Falls 2020); Seealso: People v. Cooper, supra. Moreover, if after reviewing a disciplinary record thePeople believe certain items are not subject to disclosure, they may seek a protective order forsuch items pursuant to CPL § 245.70.

To hold otherwise conflates discovery with admissibility at hearing or trial. It has long beenrecognized "that the best judge of the value of evidence to a defendant's case is 'thesingle-minded devotion of counsel for the accused (People v. Baghai—Kermani,84 NY2d 525, 531, 620 N.Y.S.2d 313, 644 N.E.2d 1004; People v. Flores, 84 NY2d 184,187, 615 N.Y.S.2d 662, 639 N.E.2d 19; People v. Banch, 80 NY2d 610, 615, 593N.Y.S.2d 491, 608 N.E.2d 1069; People v. Young, 79 NY2d 365, 371, 582 N.Y.S.2d977, 591 N.E.2d 1163)." People v. DaGata, 86 NY2d 40, 45, 629 N.Y.S.2d 186, 189(1995) Of course, the admissibility of any evidence or information defense counsel may believeuseful at hearing or trial will ultimately be determined by the court upon a motion inlimine. See: People v.Randolph, 69 Misc 3d 770, 132 N.Y.S.3d 726 (Sup. Ct. Suffolk Co. 2020), People v.Cooper, supra., People v. Castellanos, supra., People v. Williams, supra.

To facilitate the People's compliance with their discovery obligations, CPL 245.20(2)mandates that:

The prosecutor shall make a diligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence ofmaterial or information discoverable under subdivision one of this section and to cause suchmaterial or information to be made available for discovery where it exists but is not within theprosecutor's possession, custody or control; For purposes of subdivision one of this section, allitems and information related to the prosecution of a charge in the possession of any New Yorkstate or local police or law enforcement agency shall be deemed to be in the possession of theprosecution.



Further, CPL § 245.55 obligates "[t]he districtattorney and the assistant responsible for the case" (emphasis added) to:

endeavor to ensure that a flow of information is maintained between the police andother investigative personnel and his or her office sufficient to place within his or her possessionor control all material information pertinent to the defendant and the offense or offenses charged,including, but not limited to, any evidence or information [*5]discoverable under paragraph (k) of subdivision one of section245.20 of this article.



See: People v. McKinney,supra.; People v. Georgiopoulos, supra.

After the People have provided all of their automatic discovery, except for lost or destroyeditems, or items subject to a protective order issued pursuant to CPL § 245.70, the Peopleshall serve their Certificate of Compliance, in which they must certify that "after exercising duediligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of material and informationsubject to discovery, the prosecutor has disclosed and made available all known material andinformation subject to discovery." See: CPL § 245.50(1); People v. Haymon, 71 Misc 3d1203(A), 142 N.Y.S.2d 790 (Co. Ct. Albany Co. 2021); People v. Johnson, 70 Misc 3d 1205, 135 N.Y.S.3d 811 (Co. Ct.Albany Co. 2021) Such a Certificate of Compliance "is a necessary prerequisite to a validstatement of readiness under C.P.L. § 30.30." People v. Barnett, 68 Misc 3d 1000, 129 N.Y.S.3d (Sup. Ct. NYCo. 2020); See also: People v. Piasecki, 66 Misc 3d 1231(A), 125 N.Y.S.3d 537(Crim. Ct. Kings Co. 2020); People v.Freeman, 67 Misc 3d 1205(A), 125 N.Y.S.3d 842 (Crim. Ct. Bronx Co. 2020) In thisregard, CPL § 30.30(5) explicitly provides, "Any statement of readiness must beaccompanied or preceded by a certificate of good faith compliance with the disclosurerequirements of section 245.20 of this chapter " Likewise, CPL § 245.50(3) provides,"absent an individualized finding of special circumstances in the instant case by the court beforewhich the charge is pending, the prosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial for purposes ofsection 30.30 of this chapter until it has filed a proper certificate of compliance pursuant tosubdivision one of this section."

Against this backdrop, the question herein becomes, did the People file a "proper" Certificateof Compliance on December 29, 2020. A finding that they did not would render the Certificate ofCompliance and Certificate of Readiness illusory and subject to being stricken. See:People v. Barnett, supra., People v. Georgiopoulos, supra., People v.Williams, supra.

While Article 245 does not define what constitutes a "proper" Certificate of Compliance, thecourt in People v. Georgiopoulos, supra. astutely recognized, "Given that thestatute specified that '[n]o adverse consequences' shall adhere to the People based on the filing ofa certificate that is filed 'in good faith and reasonable under the circumstances,' (CPL §245.50[1]), the most reasonable inference is that such a certificate is 'proper' within the meaningof CPL § 245.50[3] and, thus, fulfills that section's prerequisite to any valid statement ofreadiness by the People." This "good faith and reasonableness under the circumstances" must bemeasured against the requirement mandated by CPL § 245.50(1) that the People exercisedue diligence and make reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of material andinformation subject to discovery before filing their Certificate of Compliance Thus, the courtfinds that a "proper" Certificate of Compliance is one which is filed in good faith, reasonableunder the circumstance, after the exercise of due diligence and reasonable inquiries to ascertainthe existence material and information subject to discovery.

Contrary to the People's suggestion, the fact that the Defendant did not file a motionchallenging the propriety of the People's Certificate of Compliance until after the People firstdisclosed some limited information regarding disciplinary proceedings involving their witnesses,at the moment pre-trial hearings were to begin, neither affects the propriety of the People'sCertificate of Compliance nor the timeliness of the Defendant's motion challenging same. WhileCPL § 245.50(4) provides, "Challenges to, or questions related to a certificate ofcompliance shall be addressed by motion[,] See: People v. Gonzalez, 68 Misc 3d 1213(A), 130 N.Y.S.3d 262 (Sup.Ct. Kings Co. 2020); People v. Suprenant, supra., Article 245 does not state atwhat time [*6]such a motion must be made. The court wouldnote, however, although amended in part, effective January 1, 2020, CPL § 255.20(1)continues to provide, in pertinent part, "all pre-trial motions shall be served or filed withinforty-five days after arraignment and before commencement of trial, or within such additionaltime as the court may fix upon the application of the defendant made prior to entry ofjudgment."

Given the facts and circumstances presented herein, it is clear the Defendant had no reason tobelieve the People failed to provide or make available to him the disciplinary records for thearresting and assisting troopers until the hearing date of April 20, 2021. It was only when thePeople turned over a letter of censure for the arresting trooper and orally advised that theassisting trooper was the subject of an open disciplinary matter that the Defendant, or the courtfor that matter, had any reason to question the propriety of the People's Certificate ofCompliance. Immediately upon receiving this information, the Defendant sought the opportunityto make the present motion and moved expeditiously, with the court's permission.

The People acknowledge that at the time they filed their Certificate of Compliance they hadnot provided or made available to the Defendant a single item of disciplinary information foreither of their anticipated witnesses. The record is also clear that almost four months after filingtheir Certificate of Compliance, the only item they provided or made available to the Defendantwas a letter of censure regarding the arresting trooper. Moreover, as explained by the ADA at thetime pre-trial hearings were to be held, relevant disciplinary records existed but were neitherprovided nor made available to the Defendant.

Notwithstanding the People's failure to provide the disciplinary records, "[i]f the Peopleestablish that they exercised due diligence and acted in good faith in filing their certificate, theircertificate of compliance shall be deemed valid." People v. Georgiopoulos, supra.; Seealso: People v. Bruni, 71 Misc3d 913, 144 N.Y.S.3d 544 (Co. Ct. Albany Co. 2021) The People in the matter subjudice, however, fail to make such a demonstration.

The People herein provide no explanation for their failure to provide the disciplinary recordsof their trooper witnesses. The ADA handling the matter explained, on the record, that shereceived self-reporting questionnaires from the troopers and, based thereon, almost four monthsafter filing a Certificate of Compliance, she delivered a single letter of censure for one witnessand advised of an open disciplinary complaint for the other. The assigned ADA indicated thatwhile she knows the People "routinely receive disclosure from the New York State Policeautomatically without a request[,] [Transcript 4/20/20, p. 5 l. 23-25], the People did not havethese disciplinary records before their Certificate of Compliance was filed. The assigned ADAfurther advised that she was informed that her office made a request of the New York StatePolice for the troopers who were expected to testify in this case, but that, contrary to the mandateof CPL § 245.55(1) she, as "the assistant responsible for the case" did not "endeavor toensure that a flow of information [was] maintained between the police and her office sufficientto place within her possession or control all material and information discoverable underparagraph (k) of subdivision one of section 245.20 of [CPL Article 245]." Indeed, the ADAacknowledged that, even as late as April 20, 2021, she did not have the disciplinary records of thetroopers who were expected to testify in this case.

When given the opportunity to demonstrate, on the record, who made the request fordisciplinary records, to whom the request was made, when the request was made, what was theresponse to the request, what records have been provided by the police, what records have notbeen provided and when all records will be provided, the People merely asked for the [*7]opportunity to put this information in their opposition to theDefendant's motion. Their opposition to this motion, however, does not utter a single wordaddressing any of these issues. This sort empty response, choosing instead to rely on "We'vemade requests" [Transcript 4/20/21, p. 9 l. 25] and the belated disclosure of a single letterof censure, does not support a claim of diligent good faith and reasonable inquiry. See:People v. Georgiopoulos, supra., People v. Williams, supra., People v.McKinney, supra.; Compare: People v. Bruni, supra.

On this record, the People cannot avoid the vacatur of their Certificate of Compliance bystating that the disciplinary records are not in their actual possession. As noted in People v.Georgiopoulos, supra.

all police paperwork is imputed to be in the People's control and it is theprosecutor's duty to work with the police to obtain such materials. As a result, it is neversufficient for the People to affirm that an item is not in their physical possession to defeat acertificate of compliance challenge. If the item at issue is police paperwork, that argument mustalways fail.



Similarly, "the withholding of [disciplinary records]by law enforcement agencies cannot excuse the People of their discovery obligation" Peoplev. Perez, supra. Moreover, as noted in People v. Altug, supra.:

the People's failure to state that they have actually examined the officer'sdisciplinary file (or whether there is one), means that they cannot be found to have exercised duediligence in determining the existence of discoverable impeachment material that might be in adisciplinary or personnel file.

In further recognition of the People's lack ofdue diligence and good faith in filing their Certificate of Compliance, the court would note thefollowing observation in People v. Williams, supra.:

In CPL Article 245, the Legislature provided numerous opportunities for thePeople to seek accommodation or relief regarding untenable discovery difficulties in anyparticular case. For example, CPL 245.10 (1)(a) allows for extension of time to provide initialdiscovery where materials are exceptionally voluminous. In some circumstances, CPL 245.50 (3)allows for trial readiness when discoverable evidence is unavailable. CPL 245.70 (2) allows formodification of discovery periods for good cause shown. CPL 245.70 (1) allows for protectiveorders that might deny, restrict, condition, or defer disclosure of any discovery. In addition, CPL30.30 (4)(g) allows for exclusion of time chargeable to the People for delay caused byunavailability of evidence that the People have diligently attempted to obtain anddisclose.



"By following the prescribed procedure and upon thegranting of the motion the People would get additional time to disclose these hard-to-obtainitems without penalty." People v.Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d 563, 130 N.Y.S.3d 614 (Crim. Ct. Kings Co. 2020)

While the People could have availed themselves of any or all of the foregoing opportunities,in a truly diligent and good faith effort to fulfill their discovery obligations prior to filing theirCertificate of Compliance, they, instead, chose to do "[w]hat the People my not do [-] file aCertificate of Compliance in which they claim to have exercised due diligence and turned over'all known material and information,' C.P.L. § 245.50(1), while at the same time not actuallyturning over all known material and information, without express permission of the court."People v. Adrovic, supra. "As succinctly stated by Judge Egan, '[t]he People maynot withhold known material and information subject to automatic discovery and expect the courtto [*8]accept a certificate of compliance and statement of trialreadiness' (People v. Cooper, supra. 7)." People v. Haymon,supra.

Accordingly, the court finds the People's Certificate of Compliance and Certificate ofReadiness illusory and invalid.



SPEEDY TRIAL

With the People's Certificate of Compliance having been found illusory, the Defendantargues that, "the People could not be ready for trial on December 29, 2020 and their Statement ofReadiness is thus also invalid. As a result, the time which elapsed between December 29, 2020and April 20, 2021 is not excludable and must be charged to the people, resulting in chargeabletime well over 90 days and prejudice to the Defendant, requiring the dismissal of this action."(Zeitlin Affirmation, 5/5/21, ¶ 18)

The Defendant clearly labors under the misapprehension that the People are automaticallycharged with all time which transpires in a case until a proper Certificate of Compliance is filed.The Defendant overlooks the fact that, the enactment of CPL Article 245 notwithstanding, theexclusionary periods set forth in CPL § 30.30(4), with some amendment not relevant herein,remain intact. See: People v.Cada, 69 Misc 3d 882, 133 N.Y.S.3d 425 (Crim. Ct. Queens Co. 2020); People v.Dobrzenski, 69 Misc 3d 333, 130 N.Y.S.3d 238 (City Ct. Oneida 2020); People v. Otero, 70 Misc 3d 526,135 N.Y.S.3d 621 (City Ct. Albany 2020)

In opposition to this branch of the Defendant's motion, the People argue that "the suspensionof Article 245 remained in effect at the time the People filed the certificate of compliance.Executive Order 202.67-202.101." (Greenberg Affirmation, 7/6/21, ¶ 3) ThePeople's reliance on the Governor's Covid related executive orders is misplaced. As this courtdetailed in People v.Gonzalezyunga, 71 Misc 3d 1210, 143 N.Y.S.3d 863 (Dist. Ct. Nassau Co. 2021),Executive Order 202.8 (9 NYCRR 8/202/8), which suspended, inter alia, "anyspecific time limit for the, filing, or service of any legal action, notice, motion, or otherprocess or proceeding, as prescribed by the procedural laws of the state, including but not limitedto the criminal procedure law" (Bold added), did not affect the time within which the Peoplewere required to file a Certificate of Compliance and declare their readiness for trial. That timelimitation is set forth in CPL § 30.30, the tolling of which was lifted effective October 5,2020, pursuant to Executive Order 202.67, (9 NYCRR 8.202.67).

The enactment of Article 245, and the Governor's executive orders notwithstanding, speedytrial determinations are to be made, as they have always has been made. As the court pointed outin People v. Percell, 67 Misc 3d190, 119 N.Y.S.3d 731 (Crim. Ct. NY Co. 2020):

'Whether the People have satisfied [their CPL § 30.30] obligation is generallydetermined by computing the time elapsed between the filing of the first accusatory instrumentand the People's declaration of readiness, subtracting any periods of delay that are excludableunder the terms of the statute and then adding to the result in any post readiness periods of delaythat are actually attributable to the People and are ineligible for exclusion.' (People v.Cortes, 80 NY2d 201, 208, 590 N.Y.S.2d 9, 604 N.E.2d 71[1992]).

With this in mind, the court shall review the pertinent dateswhich affect the Defendant's speedy trial motion. Given the fact that the only periods of time theDefendant mentions in his [*9]motion are the dates between June6, 2020 [FN3]and April 20, 2021, the court will only address the adjournments which occurred between thosedates, as that appears to be the period of time in question.



May 8, 2020 to November 18, 2020

During this period of time, this matter appeared on the court's calendar four times, May 8,2020, June 26, 2020, August 10, 2020 and September 30, 2020.

The Defendant concedes that "all pertinent time limits were tolled on March 20, 2020 byGovernor Andrew Cuomo's Executive Order 202.8. The tolling of CPL § 30.30 wasexpressly concluded on October 4, 2020 by Executive Order 202.67." (ZeitlinAffirmation 5/5/21, ¶ 11) Accordingly, the People should not be charged with any timebetween May 8, 2020 and October 4, 2020, inclusive.

The matter appeared on the court's calendar on September 30, 2020 for pre-trial hearings. Asindicated, in addition the tolling of CPL § 30.30 at that time, the parties consented to theadjournment of pre-trial hearings to November 18, 2020. As such, in addition to the time fromSeptember 30, 2020 to October 4, 2020 being excludable time, the time from October 5, 2020until the adjourn date of November 18, 2020 is excludable. CPL § 30.30(4)(b)

In addition thereto, applying the principles set forth in People v. Cada, 69 Misc 3d 882, 129 N.Y.S.3d 293 (Sup. Ct. NYCounty 2020), the balance of the adjournment on September 30, 2020 is also excludable due tothe fact that the adjournment, which began on September 30, 2020 was, at that time, excludabledue to the continuing effect of Executive Order 202.8. Since the toll of CPL § 30.30 wasstill in effect when the adjournment began, the speedy trial clock could not begin to run again forthe entire adjournment period, notwithstanding the lifting of the CPL § 30.30 toll, effectiveOctober 5, 2020, until the adjourned date.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with zero (0) days for the period of timefrom May 8, 2020 to November 18, 2020.



November 18, 2020 to January 5, 2021

On November 18, 2020 the matter appeared on the court's calendar for pre-trial hearings. Thematter was adjourned, at the Defendant's request, until January 5, 2021.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with zero (0) days for this period of time.CPL § 30.30(4)(b)



January 5, 2021 to February 17, 2021

On January 5, 2021 the matter appeared on the court's calendar for pre-trial hearings. Thematter was adjourned, at the Defendant's request, until February 17, 2021.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with zero (0) days for this period of time.CPL § 30.30(4)(b)



February 17, 2021 to March 22, 2021

On February 17, 2021 the matter appeared on the court's calendar for pre-trial hearings. Thematter was adjourned to March 22, 2021 for pre-trial hearings.

It being unclear as to the reason for the adjournment and it being the People's burden ofproving that certain periods of time should be excluded, See: People v.Berkowitz, 50 NY2d 333, [*10]428 N.Y.S.2d 927 (1980),this time is to be charged to the People.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with thirty-three (33) days for this periodof time.



March 22, 2021 to April 20, 2021

On March 22, 2021 the matter appeared on the court's calendar for pre-trial hearings. ThePeople were not ready to proceed with the hearing at that time. The matter was adjourned toApril 20, 2021 for pre-trial hearings.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with twenty-nine (29) days for this periodof time.



April 20, 2021 to Date

As discussed hereinabove, on April 20, 2021, the Defendant requested that the pre-trialhearings in this matter be adjourned so that the Defendant could bring the instant motion. Themotion was filed on May 10, 2021 and ultimately submitted for decision on July 30, 2021.

Accordingly, the People shall be charged with zero (0) days for this period of time.CPL § 30.30(4)(a)

Based upon the foregoing, the People are presently charged with a total of sixty-two(62) days.



CONCLUSION

That branch of the Defendant's motion seeking an order striking the People's Certificate ofCompliance and Certificate of Readiness is granted; and it is

ORDERED, that the People's Certificate of Compliance and Certificate ofReadiness are hereby vacated; and, it is further

ORDERED, that in accordance with CPL § 245.35(3), any future Certificate ofCompliance the People may file shall "state[] that the prosecutor and/or an appropriate namedagent has made reasonable inquiries of all police officers and other persons who haveparticipated in investigating or evaluating the case about the existence of any favorable evidenceor information within paragraph (k) of subdivision one of section 245.20 of this article, includingsuch evidence or information that was not reduced to writing or otherwise memorialized orpreserved as evidence, and has disclosed any such information to the defendant[.]"

That branch of the Defendant's motion seeking an order dismissing the accusatoryinstruments is denied.

This constitutes the decision and order of the court.



Dated: August 20, 2021

Hempstead, New York

ANDREWM. ENGEL

J.D.C.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:Brady v. Maryland, 373U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194 (1963)

Footnote 2:Giglio v. United States,405 U.S. 150, 92 S.Ct. 763 (1972)

Footnote 3:The court notes that there was nocalendar date in this matter for June 6, 2020. For this reason, the court will begin reviewing datescommencing with May 8, 2020, the last calendar date before June 6, 2020.




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.