| Skyline Restoration, Inc. v Roslyn Jane Holdings, LLC |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 03998 [95 AD3d 1203] |
| May 23, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Skyline Restoration, Inc., Respondent, v Roslyn JaneHoldings, LLC, et al., Appellants. |
—[*1] Maizes & Maizes, LLP, Bronx, N.Y. (Michael H. Maizes of counsel), forrespondent.
In an action, inter alia, to recover a down payment given pursuant to a contract for the sale ofreal property, the defendants appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Parga,J.), dated August 24, 2011, which granted that branch of the plaintiff's motion which was forsummary judgment on the second cause of action and directed the defendant Wilson Shum torelease to the plaintiff the down payment being held in escrow, and denied that branch of theircross motion which was for summary judgment on their first counterclaim which was for ajudgment declaring that the defendant Roslyn Jane Holdings, LLC, was entitled to retain thedown payment as liquidated damages.
Ordered that the order is affirmed, with costs.
The plaintiff buyer and the defendant seller Roslyn Jane Holdings, LLC (hereinafter RJH),entered into a contract for the sale of real property, pursuant to which the plaintiff made a downpayment which was deposited with RJH's attorney, the defendant Wilson Shum. The contractrequired RJH, inter alia, to provide a certificate of occupancy that was in full force and effect forthe entire premises on the closing date. Additionally, RJH represented in the contract that thepremises did not violate relevant zoning ordinances or regulations.
After the plaintiff and RJH entered into the contract, but before the contractualtime-of-the-essence closing date, the plaintiff was informed by its zoning attorney and architectthat the premises did not comply with the certificate of occupancy and violated local zoningordinances and regulations. Under the contract, RJH was obligated to cure such defects prior toclosing. The plaintiff informed RJH of these defects, and requested it to cure them prior toclosing. RJH refused, asserting, inter alia, that no such defects existed, and insisted that theplaintiff was obligated to tender performance on the time-of-the-essence closing date.
The plaintiff refused to close, and instead commenced this action against the defendantsseeking, in its second cause of action, the return of its down payment. The defendants answeredand counterclaimed, alleging that the plaintiff materially breached the contract by failing totender performance on the time-of-the-essence closing date and that, as a result of the plaintiff'sbreach, RJH was entitled to retain the down payment as liquidated damages. The plaintiff moved,[*2]inter alia, for summary judgment on its second cause ofaction and the defendants cross-moved, among other things, for summary judgment on theircounterclaim. The Supreme Court granted that branch of the plaintiff's motion and denied thatbranch of the defendants' cross motion. The defendants appeal, and we affirm.
The plaintiff established, prima facie, that RJH was in breach of the contract on the closingdate by demonstrating that the premises violated the certificate of occupancy and local zoningordinances and regulations. The plaintiff also established, prima facie, that it was ready, willing,and able to perform on the closing date (see Pesa v Yoma Dev. Group, Inc., 18 NY3d 527 [2012]). Inopposition to the plaintiff's showing, the defendant failed to raise a triable issue of fact.Consequently, the plaintiff is entitled to the return of its down payment (see Kopp v Boyango, 67 AD3d646, 650 [2009]; Waldman v LDKRealty, Inc., 63 AD3d 828, 831 [2009]).
Moreover, the defendants were not entitled to judgment as a matter of law on their firstcounterclaim. Due to RJH's breach, the plaintiff was not required to tender performance or attendthe closing (see Kopp v Boyango, 67 AD3d at 650). Balkin, J.P., Leventhal, Hall andCohen, JJ., concur. [Prior Case History: 2011 NY Slip Op 32345(U).]