Matter of Lord v New York State Bd. of Elections
2012 NY Slip Op 05971 [98 AD3d 622]
August 15, 2012
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 26, 2012


In the Matter of Kathleen M. Lord et al.,Respondents,
v
New York State Board of Elections, Respondent, and Nan Hayworth,Appellant. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Nan Hayworth, Appellant, v Bruce Yablow et al.,Respondents, and Kathleen M. Lord et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No.2.)

—[*1]

In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate a petitiondesignating Nan Hayworth as a candidate in a primary election held on June 26, 2012, for thenomination of the Independence Party as its candidate for the public office of Representative inCongress from the 18th Congressional District, and a related proceeding pursuant to ElectionLaw § 16-102, inter alia, to validate the designating petition, Nan Hayworth appeals from afinal order of the Supreme Court, Westchester County (Walker, J.), dated May 18, 2012, which,after a hearing, granted the petition, inter alia, to invalidate the designating petition, invalidatedthe designating petition, denied the petition, inter alia, to validate the designating petition, ineffect, dismissed that proceeding, and directed the Westchester County Board of Elections torefrain from placing the name of Nan Hayworth on the ballot.

Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

Initially, we note that this appeal has not been rendered academic. Although the relevantprimary election was held on June 26, 2012, the appellant was the only person who filed adesignating petition for the nomination of the Independence Party as its candidate for the publicoffice of Representative in Congress from the 18th Congressional District. Thus, if thedesignating petition were found to be valid, the appellant's name could be placed on the ballot inthe general election to be held on November 6, 2012 (see Matter of Hackett v Egan, 196AD2d 870 [1993]).

The Supreme Court correctly invalidated those signatures that were inscribed in print ratherthan script form on the appellant's designating petition, since the alleged signatories had signedtheir registration forms in script and the appellant submitted no credible evidence from thesignatories or from any of the subscribing witnesses attesting to fact that the individuals whosigned the registration forms were the same individuals whose signatures appeared on thedesignating petition (see Election Law §§ 5-210 [5] [k] [xi]; 6-134 [5], [13];Matter of Henry v Trotto, 54 AD3d [*2]424, 426 [2008];Matter of Jaffee v Kelly, 32 AD3d485 [2006]; Matter of Rabadi v Galan, 307 AD2d 1014 [2003]). To prevent fraudand allow for a meaningful comparison of signatures when challenged, a signature on adesignating petition should be made in the same manner as on that signatory's registration form(see Election Law § 6-134 [10]; Matter of Henry v Trotto, 54 AD3d at426).

The appellant's contention that the Supreme Court failed to afford notarized signatures apresumption of regularity is raised for the first time on appeal and, therefore, is not properlybefore this Court (see Matter ofMuscarella v Nassau County Bd. of Elections, 87 AD3d 645, 646-647 [2011]; see Matter of Romaine v Suffolk CountyBd. of Elections, 65 AD3d 993, 994 [2009]; Matter of Leroy v Board of Elections in City of N.Y., 65 AD3d645, 646 [2009]).

The appellant's contentions concerning the Supreme Court's calculation of the number ofvalid signatures, the appellant's failure to paginate the last sheet of the designating petition, andthe sequencing of dates inscribed by certain signatories next to their signatures are without merit.

The Supreme Court erred in finding that certain signatures inscribed in script on thedesignating petition were invalid because the particular signature on the designating petition didnot match the signature on record with the Westchester County Board of Elections. The identitiesof those signatories as registered voters were established by a comparison of the signatures on thedesignating petition with those of persons whose names appeared in the registration poll ledgers(see Election Law § 6-134 [5]; Matter of Romaine v Suffolk County Bd. ofElections, 65 AD3d at 995). The addition of those signatures, however, does not bring thetotal number of valid signatures on the appellant's designating petition up to the number requiredfor designation (see Election Law § 6-136 [2] [g]). Moreover, even if that totalwere to be increased by the addition of certain signatures that were invalidated as a consequenceof the alleged alteration of the address of the subscribing witness on one sheet of the designatingpetition, the designating petition would not contain the required number of signatures.Accordingly, we need not reach the appellant's contention with respect to the alleged alteration ofthat address.

In light of the foregoing, the petition, inter alia, to invalidate was properly granted, thepetition, inter alia, to validate was properly denied, and the proceeding, inter alia, to validate wasproperly, in effect, dismissed. Leventhal, J.P., Chambers, Roman and Miller, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.