LaMarca v Quirk
2013 NY Slip Op 06573 [110 AD3d 808]
October 9, 2013
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 27, 2013


Richard LaMarca, Respondent-Appellant,
v
JohnB. Quirk III, Appellant-Respondent, et al., Respondent.

—[*1]

In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate anindependent nominating petition nominating John B. Quirk III as a candidate of theLibertarian Party for the public office of Nassau County Legislator, 18th LegislativeDistrict, in a general election to be held on November 5, 2013, John B. Quirk III appealsfrom a final order of the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Diamond, J.), dated September26, 2013, which, after a hearing, granted the petition and invalidated his independentnominating petition, and the petitioner cross-appeals from the same final order.

Ordered that the cross appeal is dismissed, without costs or disbursements, as thepetitioner is not aggrieved by the final order (see CPLR 5511); and it is further,

Ordered that the final order is affirmed on the appeal by John B. Quirk III, withoutcosts or disbursements.

John B. Quirk III filed an independent nominating petition with the Nassau CountyBoard of Elections (hereinafter the Board of Elections) containing 1,672 signatures,seeking to become the candidate of the Libertarian Party for the Public Office of NassauCounty Legislator, 18th Legislative District. Richard LaMarca filed objections andspecifications of objections with the Board of Elections, challenging numeroussignatures on a variety of grounds. LaMarca thereafter commenced this proceeding toinvalidate the independent nominating petition. LaMarca's petition sought to invalidatenumerous signatures on several grounds and alleged, among other things, that theindependent nominating petition was "potentially fraudulent," in that it containedsignatures procured by fraud, forgery, deceit, and treachery. The Supreme Court held theproceeding in abeyance pending the completion of proceedings before the Board ofElections.

The two-member Board of Elections invalidated 440 signatures, "split" on 166signatures (i.e., one Commissioner voted to invalidate the signatures while the otherCommissioner voted not to invalidate the signatures, effectively permitting the signaturesto remain valid), and did not rule on approximately 100 signatures that were the subjectof allegations of possible forgery. Since 1,232 signatures were deemed by the Board ofElections to be valid, the Board of Elections concluded that the independent nominatingpetition was sufficient.[*2]

Upon the resumption of the instant proceeding, aspecial referee conducted a line-by-line examination of the Board of Elections' "splits,"and invalidated an additional 83 signatures, but concluded that, since 1,149 validsignatures remained, the independent nominating petition still contained a sufficientnumber of valid and qualifying signatures.

The Supreme Court thereafter conducted a hearing with respect to thoseapproximately 100 remaining signatures that were the subject of allegations of possibleforgery. The Supreme Court invalidated an additional 44 signatures, thus leaving 1,105valid signatures on the independent nominating petition, one signature short of the 1,106valid signatures required (see Election Law § 6-136 [2]). At the close ofthe hearing, LaMarca orally requested, in the alternative, to invalidate the independentnominating petition on the ground that it was permeated with fraud. The Supreme Courtreserved decision with respect to that application.

In a final order dated September 26, 2013, the Supreme Court granted the petition toinvalidate, and thereupon invalidated the independent nominating petition, due to theinsufficient number of valid signatures submitted by Quirk to the Board of Elections. TheSupreme Court denied LaMarca's alternative application to invalidate the independentnominating petition, which was made on the ground that the independent nominatingpetition was permeated with fraud. Quirk appeals, and LaMarca cross-appeals, from thefinal order.

Initially, only an aggrieved party or a person substituted for him or her may appealfrom an appealable judgment, order, or final order (see CPLR 5511; Swazey v Pathmark Stores,Inc., 74 AD3d 786, 787 [2010]). "Where a party obtains the relief [he or she]seeks from the Supreme Court, [that party] is not aggrieved" (AMS Prods., LLC v Signorile,66 AD3d 929, 929 [2009]; see Matter of Brown v Smith, 76 AD3d 939 [2010]). Here,the final order appealed from granted LaMarca's petition to invalidate Quirk'sindependent nominating petition. Therefore, LaMarca is not aggrieved by the final order,and the cross appeal must be dismissed (see AMS Prods., LLC v Signorile, 66AD3d at 929).

On appeal, Quirk contends, inter alia, that the petition to invalidate should have beendismissed pursuant to CPLR 3016 (b), arguing that the allegations in the petition toinvalidate, made in connection with the claim of fraud, were not sufficiently specific toapprise him of the claim of fraud. Quirk further contends that, since LaMarca did notattach, to the petition to invalidate, the objections and specifications of objections that hefiled with the Board of Elections, that pleading failed to meet the specificity requirementof CPLR 3016 (b). Quirk also contends that the Supreme Court erred in invalidating 22specific signatures. Quirk's contentions are without merit.

Here, the petition to invalidate alleged, inter alia, that certain signatures were invalidbecause they had been forged or were fraudulent, and the petition to invalidateincorporated by reference the specific objections raised before the Board of Elections.Those specific objections identified the specific challenged signatures set forth on theindependent nominating petition. Thus, Quirk received adequate notice of the allegationssupporting the claims that certain signatures had been forged or were fraudulent (seeCPLR 3016 [b]; Matter of Oberle v Caracappa, 133 AD2d 202 [1987];see also Matter of Mazza v Board of Elections of County of Albany, 196 AD2d679 [1993]; Matter of Cohen v Moss, 97 AD2d 644 [1983]).

Moreover, the Supreme Court properly invalidated the 22 signatures that Quirkcontends on appeal were valid. Voters' signatures on designating or independentnominating petitions that do not meaningfully compare with the signatures on the samevoters' registration forms should be invalidated (see Matter of Quercia v Bernstein, 87 AD3d 652, 653[2011]; Matter of Rabadi v Galan, 307 AD2d 1014 [2003]). Furthermore, theSupreme Court correctly invalidated those signatures that were inscribed in print ratherthan script form on Quirk's independent nominating petition, since the alleged signatorieshad signed their registration forms in script, and Quirk submitted no credible evidencefrom the signatories or from any of the subscribing witnesses attesting to the fact that theindividuals who signed the registration forms were the same individuals whosesignatures appeared on the independent nominating petition (see Election Law§§ 5-210 [5] [k] [xi]; 6-134 [5], [13]; Matter of Lord v New York State Bd. of Elections, 98 AD3d622, 623 [2012]; Matter ofHenry v Trotto, 54 AD3d 424, 426 [2008]; Matter of Jaffee v Kelly, 32 AD3d 485 [2006]; Matterof Rabadi v Galan, 307 AD2d 1014 [2003]). To [*3]prevent fraud and allow for a meaningful comparison ofsignatures when challenged, a signature on an independent nominating petition should bemade in the same manner as on that signatory's registration form (see ElectionLaw § 6-134 [10]; Matter of Lord v New York State Bd. of Elections, 98AD3d at 623; Matter of Henry v Trotto, 54 AD3d at 426).

Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly granted LaMarca's petition to invalidateQuirk's independent nominating petition.

In light of our determination, LaMarca's contention that the Supreme Court shouldhave invalidated additional signatures, which he raised as an alternative ground foraffirmance, has been rendered academic. LaMarca's remaining contention is not properlybefore this Court. Dillon, J.P., Chambers, Cohen and Miller, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.