| Matter of Haygood v Hardwick |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 06803 [110 AD3d 931] |
| October 17, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Abraham C. Haygood et al.,Respondents, v Andrew Hardwick, Appellant, et al.,Respondent. |
—[*1]
In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate anindependent nominating petition nominating Andrew Hardwick as the candidate of theWe Count Party for the public office of County Executive, Nassau County, in the generalelection to be held on November 5, 2013, Andrew Hardwick appeals from a final orderof the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Winslow, J.), entered October 11, 2013, whichdenied his motion to dismiss the petition to invalidate pursuant to CPLR 3016 (b) and,after a hearing, granted the petition to invalidate and invalidated his independentnominating petition.
Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.
The petitioners commenced this proceeding to invalidate alleging, inter alia, thatcertain signatures on the independent nominating petition of Andrew Hardwick(hereinafter the candidate) were invalid because they had been forged or were otherwisefraudulent. The candidate moved pursuant to CPLR 3016 (b) to dismiss the petition toinvalidate, contending that the allegations of fraud and forgery set forth in the petition toinvalidate were not sufficiently specific. Contrary to the candidate's contention, thepetition to invalidate incorporated by reference specific objections filed by the petitionerswith the Nassau County Board of Elections (hereinafter the Board of Elections) prior tothe commencement of this proceeding (see Election Law §§ 1-106[1]; 6-154 [2]; Matter of Bush v Salerno, 51 NY2d 95, 99 [1980]). Thus, thecandidate received adequate notice of the allegations supporting the claims that certainsignatures had been forged or were otherwise fraudulent (see Matter of La Marca vQuirk, 110 AD3d 808 [2d Dept 2013]; Matter of Mazza v Board of Elections ofCounty of Albany, 196 AD2d 679 [1993]; Matter of Oberle v Caracappa,133 AD2d 202, 203 [1987]; Matter of Cohen v Moss, 97 AD2d 644 [1983]).Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly denied the candidate's motion to dismiss thepetition.
Upon denying the candidate's motion, and after a hearing, the Supreme Courtproperly granted the petition to invalidate the independent nominating petition. Acandidate's designating petition or independent nominating petition "will be invalidatedon the ground of fraud if there is a showing that the entire petition is permeated withfraud" (Matter of Felder vStorobin, 100 AD3d 11, 15 [2012]; see Matter of Lavine v Imbroto, 98 AD3d 620, 620[2012]; Matter of Valenti vBugbee, 88 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2011]). "Absent permeation with fraud, adesignating [or independent nominating] petition may be invalidated where the candidatehas participated in or is chargeable with knowledge of the fraud" (Matter of Felder vStorobin, 100 AD3d at 15-16; see Matter of Lavine v Imbroto, 98 AD3d at620; Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1057). Here, the facts adduced atthe hearing [*2]warranted the Supreme Court'sdetermination that the candidate, who "was inextricably intertwined in the petitioningprocess," was chargeable with knowledge of the fraudulent manner in which certainsignatures were procured (Matter of Villafane v Caban, 104 AD2d 579, 580[1984]; see Matter of Cirillo vGardiner, 65 AD3d 638, 639 [2009]; Matter of Buchanan v Espada, 230AD2d 676, 678-679 [1996]; Matter of MacDougall v Board of Elections of City ofN.Y., 133 AD2d 198 [1987]; Matter of Adams v Klapper, 182 Misc 2d 51,53 [1999], affd 264 AD2d 696 [1999]).
Evidence adduced before the Supreme Court established that at least one subscribingwitness, Jonathan Clark, was paid for collecting signatures before he was registered tovote in the State. Although this evidence was not expressly addressed in the final order, itwas presented and argued to the Supreme Court and this Court, and permits the inferencethat Clark collected and witnessed signatures prior to registering to vote, in violation ofElection Law § 6-140 (1) (b). Additionally, the dates on pages containingsignatures witnessed by Clark were altered so as to falsely indicate that he witnessednumerous signatures on dates after he was registered to vote. The candidate testified thathe was not aware that Clark, in his capacity as a campaign worker, did anything otherthan collect signatures. Subscribing witness Priscilla Collins was paid a full week's salaryfor the collection of signatures on the date she first registered to vote, and testified thatshe, like Clark, collected and witnessed signatures prior to being registered to vote.Moreover, the dates inscribed next to several signatures witnessed by Collins also appearto have been altered to post-date the subscribing witness's eligibility to collect signatures.Crucially, the candidate conceded that he reviewed the pages containing signatureswitnessed by Collins, and noticed incorrect dates, but nonetheless filed those pages withthe Board of Elections. The petitioners also presented the testimony of seven signatories,who testified that signatures purportedly obtained from them by two subscribingwitnesses, Susan Forenza and Keith Rigby, were not their signatures. The evidenceshows that the candidate, among other things, personally supervised the campaignworkers' payments and assignments, verified their voter registration status, conductedmeetings to educate them about the petitioning process, and received and reviewed pageswith the signatures they had collected. Moreover, in light of the evidence of irregularitiesand fraudulent practices as to signatures on the pages attested to by Clark and Rigby, thepetitioners were entitled to an inference that Clark and Rigby, who were presumed to beunder the candidate's control and failed to appear at the hearing, would have testifiedadversely to the candidate's position (see Matter of Haas v Costigan, 14 AD2d809, 810-811 [1961]; Matter of Adams v Klapper, 182 Misc 2d at 52-53).
Although a subscribing witness testified that he was paid to collect signatures on aper-signature basis, in violation of Election Law § 17-122 (4), we conclude that,even without this evidence, the petition to invalidate the independent nominating petitionwas properly granted, since the candidate was chargeable with knowledge of theforgeries and the otherwise fraudulent manner in which several signatures were procured,and he approved of such methods (see Matter of Cirillo v Gardiner, 65 AD3d at639).
The parties' remaining contentions either are without merit, are not properly beforethis Court, or need not be reached in light of our determination. Dickerson, J.P.,Leventhal, Chambers and Hall, JJ., concur.