| Red Zone LLC v Cadwalader, Wickersham & TaftLLP |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 04570 [118 AD3d 581] |
| June 19, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| Red Zone LLC, Respondent, v Cadwalader,Wickersham & Taft LLP, Appellant. |
Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, New York (David R. Marriott of counsel), forappellant.
Jeffrey A. Jannuzzo, New York, for respondent.
Amended order and judgment (one paper), Supreme Court, New York County(Melvin L. Schweitzer, J.), entered May 5, 2014, awarding plaintiff $17.2 million,unanimously affirmed, without costs. Appeals from orders, same court and Justice,entered May 24, 2013, September 3, 2013 and October 11, 2013, unanimously dismissed,without costs, as subsumed in the appeal from the judgment.
Plaintiff commenced this action for legal malpractice against defendant law firmbased on the alleged negligent drafting of an agreement (side agreement) that wasintended to memorialize an oral agreement between plaintiff and nonparty UBSSecurities LLC (UBS) to cap at $2 million the amount of fees UBS was to receive foracting as plaintiff's exclusive financial advisor in its effort to acquire control of nonpartySix Flags, Inc., unless plaintiff acquired more than 51% of the voting shares of Six Flags.Prior to the instant lawsuit, UBS successfully sued plaintiff for $10 million in fees inconnection with the Six Flags transaction. In the course of that lawsuit, we rejectedplaintiff's argument that the side agreement, read in tandem with the main agreement(engagement agreement), capped UBS's fee at $2 million (UBS Sec. LLC v Red ZoneLLC, 77 AD3d 575 [1st Dept 2010], lv denied 17 NY3d 706 [2001] [UBS decision]).
In this action, defendant moved for leave to amend its answer to assert the defense ofassumption of the risk. In support of its motion, defendant submitted an affidavit from apartner at the firm who averred that he had warned plaintiff that the side agreement wasambiguous. This statement directly contradicts his earlier deposition testimony in theUBS litigation that the side agreement unambiguously capped plaintiff's fees and wasimproperly raised for the first time in opposition to plaintiff's motion (see e.g. Ostrov v Rozbruch, 91AD3d 147, 154 [1st Dept 2012]). Contrary to defendant's contentions, this defensewas not previously raised in its answer or motion papers, as those documents merelybroadly deny that defendant acted negligently. The motion was properly denied since theproposed amendment is patently devoid of merit (see Bishop v Maurer, 83 AD3d 483, 484-485 [1st Dept2011]).
The motion court also properly denied defendant's motion to renew the motion forleave [*2]to amend its answer. The motion was not basedon new facts that were unavailable on the original motion (Chelsea Piers Mgt. vForest Elec. Corp., 281 AD2d 252 [1st Dept 2001]). Nor is there any basis to findthat the interest of justice and substantial fairness warrant granting renewal.
The motion court properly concluded that the continuous representation doctrineapplies to toll the statute of limitations on plaintiff's legal malpractice claim. Althoughdefendant drafted the side agreement in 2005, it provided legal advice throughout theUBS litigation from 2007 through late 2010. Although plaintiff was represented by othercounsel in the UBS litigation, plaintiff and its trial counsel continued to confer withdefendant and share privileged documents regarding its defense strategy. In doing so,defendant apparently sought to rectify its earlier alleged malpractice, namely to preventUBS from demanding more than $2 million when the side agreement was intended tolimit UBS's fee. In such cases, the continuous representation doctrine applies (seeLuk Lamellen U. Kupplungbau GmbH v Lerner, 166 AD2d 505, 506-507 [2d Dept1990]; N&S Supply v Simmons, 305 AD2d 648, 649-650 [2d Dept 2003]).There is no basis to find that the earlier "gap" in representation from roughly 2005 to2007 ended defendant's prior representation. There was simply no need to consultdefendant during that time, and defendant never communicated to plaintiff that its priorrepresentation had ended (see Shumsky v Eisenstein, 96 NY2d 164, 170-171[2001]).
Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment on its legal malpractice claim was alsoproperly granted. Notably, defendant does not dispute that the side agreement wasintended to cap UBS's fees at $2 million. Given our prior finding in the UBS litigationthat the side agreement failed to do just that (UBS Sec. LLC, 77 AD3d 575),summary judgment is warranted. Accordingly, no expert opinion evidence was necessarybefore granting the motion (seeNorthrop v Thorsen, 46 AD3d 780, 782 [2d Dept 2007]). There are no triableissues as to whether defendant, as opposed to plaintiff or its trial counsel in the UBSlitigation, caused plaintiff's injuries. But for defendant's drafting of the side agreement,UBS would not have prevailed in its lawsuit seeking $10 million (see Rudolf v Shayne, Dachs,Stanisci, Corker & Sauer, 8 NY3d 438, 442 [2007]).
Regarding plaintiff's motion to dismiss defendant's affirmative defenses, havingconcluded that the action was timely commenced, the motion court properly dismissedthe laches defense (Cadlerock,L.L.C. v Renner, 72 AD3d 454, 454 [1st Dept 2010]). Plaintiff did not waive itsclaims by attempting to defend the terms of the side agreement in the UBS litigation.Thus, the waiver defense was also properly dismissed.
In addition, the motion court properly dismissed the defense of failure to mitigatedamages. Contrary to defendant's argument that plaintiff could have mitigated itsdamages by avoiding gaining control of Six Flags, the side agreement was intended tolimit plaintiff's liability in the event that it acquired control. Defendant further argues thatplaintiff could have invested more resources to adequately defending the UBS litigation,but it does not detail what [*3]strategies should havebeen pursued to persuade the trial court or this Court to look beyond the plain andunambiguous terms of the side agreement.
We have considered defendant's remaining contentions and find them unavailing ornot properly before this Court. Concur—Tom, J.P., Moskowitz, DeGrasse,Manzanet-Daniels and Clark, JJ.