| Matter of Soto v Central Off. Review Comm. of the Dept. ofCorrections & Community Supervision |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 04819 [118 AD3d 1229] |
| June 26, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Joseph Soto, Petitioner, v CentralOffice Review Committee of the Department of Corrections and CommunitySupervision et al., Respondents. |
Joseph Soto, Coxsackie, petitioner pro se.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondents.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review (1) two determinations ofrespondent Superintendent of Coxsackie Correctional Facility which found petitionerguilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules and (2) a determination of respondentCentral Office Review Committee denying his grievance.
Petitioner, a prison inmate, received a misbehavior report charging him withpossession of contraband and an altered item after a search of his property revealedcooking utensils and an altered electrical device. Petitioner received a secondmisbehavior report the same day charging him with making threats, harassment, creatinga disturbance and interference stemming from a confrontation with a correction officer inthe law library during which he was alleged to have yelled at the officer and pointed athim in a threatening manner. Following separate tier II disciplinary hearings, petitionerwas found guilty of both charges in the first misbehavior report and guilty of interferenceand creating a disturbance with regard to the second misbehavior report. The finding ofguilt with regard to each misbehavior report was affirmed upon administrative appeal.Earlier, petitioner had filed a grievance alleging that he was being denied a job in the lawlibrary for discriminatory and retaliatory reasons. Ultimately, the denial of his grievancewas upheld by respondent Central Office Review Committee. Petitioner thereafter [*2]commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding to challengeboth disciplinary determinations and the denial of his grievance.
With regard to the first misbehavior report, substantial evidence supports the findingof guilt based upon the misbehavior report alone, particularly where petitioner refused topresent evidence, call witnesses or answer the Hearing Officer's question as to whetherthe discovered items belonged to him (see Matter of Green v Bradt, 91 AD3d 1235, 1237 [2012],lv denied 19 NY3d 802 [2012]; Matter of Encarnacion v Bellnier, 89 AD3d 1301, 1302[2011]). Petitioner's remaining claims regarding that misbehavior report were notpreserved as he failed to raise them at the hearing (see Matter of Rosales v Prack, 112 AD3d 1025, 1026[2013], lv denied 22 NY3d 865 [2014]; Matter of Coates v Fischer, 108 AD3d 997, 998 [2013]).Turning to the second misbehavior report, the report itself, along with the testimony ofan inmate witness who related that petitioner had engaged in an argument with acorrection officer about grievances, provide substantial evidence to support the findingof guilt with regard to the charge of creating a disturbance. Petitioner's contention thatthe misbehavior report was issued in retaliation for grievances he had filed raised anissue of credibility to be resolved by the Hearing Officer (see Matter of Toliver v New YorkState Commr. of Corr. & Community Supervision, 114 AD3d 987, 987[2014]; Matter of Quezada vFischer, 113 AD3d 1004, 1004 [2014]). However, neither the report nor anytestimony indicated that petitioner interfered with an employee in any manner and, thus,the determination finding him guilty of that charge must be annulled (see Matter of Fulton v Chase,115 AD3d 1033, 1035 [2014]). However, inasmuch as no loss of good time wasrecommended and petitioner has already served his penalty, the matter need not beremitted for a redetermination of the penalty on the remaining violation (see Matter of Sylvester vFischer, 108 AD3d 951, 952 [2013]).
Turning to the denial of petitioner's grievance, our review is limited to whether suchdetermination was arbitrary and capricious, irrational or affected by an error of law (see Matter of Hutchinson vFischer, 112 AD3d 1245, 1245 [2013], lv denied 23 NY3d 903 [2014];Matter of Jones v Fischer,110 AD3d 1295, 1296 [2013], appeal dismissed 23 NY3d 955 [2014]).Initially, we note that inmates have no statutory, constitutional or precedential right tohold any particular job within the prison (see Matter of Green v Bradt, 69 AD3d 1269, 1270 [2010],lv denied 14 NY3d 710 [2010]; Matter of Henriquez v Department of Corrections, 53 AD3d993, 993 [2008]). Here, the record demonstrates that the denial of petitioner'srequest to work in the law library was based upon his history of circumventing rules andviolating policies and, accordingly, we cannot say that the denial of his grievance wasirrational (see Matter of Cole vFischer, 107 AD3d 1256 [2013]). We have examined petitioner's remainingcontentions and found them to be either unpreserved or without merit.
Peters, P.J., McCarthy, Rose, Egan Jr. and Lynch, JJ., concur. Adjudged that thedetermination with respect to the second misbehavior report is modified, without costs,by annulling so much thereof as found petitioner guilty of interference; petition grantedto that extent and the Superintendent of Coxsackie Correctional Facility is directed toexpunge all references thereto from petitioner's institutional record; and, as so modified,confirmed. Adjudged that the determination with respect to the first misbehavior reportand the [*3]determination denying petitioner's grievanceare confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed to that extent.