Stein v Anderson
2014 NY Slip Op 08890 [123 AD3d 1322]
December 18, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 28, 2015


[*1]
  Richard Stein, Respondent, v Richard L. Anderson,Appellant.

Law Office of Carman Garufi, Binghamton (Alena E. Van Tull of counsel), forappellant.

Coughlin & Gerhart, LLP, Binghamton (Mark Rappaport of counsel), forrespondent.

Lynch, J. Appeal from an order of the County Court of Tioga County (Keene, J.),entered November 21, 2013, which affirmed a judgment of the Justice Court of the Townof Owego in favor of plaintiff.

In June 2006, defendant suffered the loss of his truck and certain equipment in aflood. In July 2006, plaintiff, who was defendant's friend, allegedly transferred $9,899.38to defendant. According to plaintiff, a portion of the money was intended to pay forgoods that he had purchased from defendant and the remaining funds were a loan to helpdefendant remain in business after the flood losses. Plaintiff commenced this action inJustice Court to recover the unpaid balance of the loan. Following a trial, plaintiff wasawarded the sum of $3,000, an amount slightly less than the amount that plaintiff claimedremained unpaid, plus costs. County Court affirmed the judgment upon defendant'sappeal. Defendant appeals.

"Appellate review of small claims is limited to determining whether 'substantialjustice has not been done between the parties according to the rules and principles ofsubstantive law' " (Rowe v Silver & Gold Expressions, 107 AD3d 1090,1091 [2013], quoting UCCA 1807). Applying this standard, we will overturn a decisiononly if it is clearly erroneous (see Kelsey v McNally, 77 AD3d 1230, 1231 [2010], lvdismissed 16 NY3d 853 [2011]). Here, plaintiff testified before Justice Court that heloaned $7,677 to defendant to help him stay in business after the flood. He explained thatthe loan was made via a check in the amount of $9,899.38 that was intended to coverboth the loan and payment of "a little over $2,000" for materials he had purchased.Plaintiff claimed that defendant acknowledged the loan at the time that it was made,[*2]stating that he appreciated it and would pay him back"as soon as [he could]." Defendant paid plaintiff $3,500 sometime later in 2006 and, in2008, plaintiff began to write to defendant seeking repayment of the sum that remaineddue. In response to the first letter in August 2008, defendant told plaintiff that he wasseeking grant money. Plaintiff testified that after subsequent requests, defendant madethree $100 payments, thus reducing the debt to $3,877. For his part, defendant testifiedthat while he recalled plaintiff giving him a check to purchase materials, he did not recallany extra payment. In apparent contradiction, he also testified that he appreciatedplaintiff's "generosity," but denied that he ever asked for plaintiff's help.

We reject defendant's claims that the terms of the agreement were too indefinite to beenforceable. The issues presented raised credibility issues that were for the court toresolve (see Rowe v Silver & Gold Expressions, 107 AD3d at 1091;Pierce v Pastorello, 255 AD2d 622, 622 [1998]). Plaintiff testified as to the oralagreement and the amount of the loan. While defendant denied recollection of the details,his conduct could be construed as an acknowledgment of the existence and nature of thedebt, and we perceive no error in Justice Court's determination to disregard defendant'sclaims to the contrary (see Burnside v Foglia, 208 AD2d 1085, 1085-1086[1994]). Although the oral agreement did not provide for the term of the loan, the effectof such omission is that the loan was payable upon demand (see ABKCO Music &Records, Inc. v Montague, 90 AD3d 402, 403 [2011]). We agree with CountyCourt that Justice Court's determination that the payment was a loan and not a gift and tocredit defendant's payments to reduce the debt payable was not clearly erroneous, andsubstantial justice was done.

Peters, P.J., Lahtinen, Garry and Rose, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,with costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.