| Matter of Maurizio XX. v New York State Off. of Children& Family Servs. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 01512 [125 AD3d 1174] |
| February 19, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Maurizio XX., Petitioner, v New YorkState Office of Children and Family Services et al.,Respondents. |
Reynold A. Mauro, Commack, for petitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Kathleen M. Arnold of counsel),for respondents.
Devine, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by orderof the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination ofrespondent Office of Children and Family Services which denied petitioner's applicationto have a report maintained by the Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatmentamended to be unfounded and expunged.
In July 2012, as petitioner was bathing his two-year-old son, he struck the child onthe left buttock with his hand to discipline the child for eating soap. The following day,having realized that the child's buttock was bruised, petitioner explained what hadhappened to the child's day-care provider who, in turn, reported the incident to theCentral Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment. Respondent Suffolk CountyDepartment of Social Services conducted an investigation and the report wassubsequently marked as "indicated" for maltreatment due to inadequate guardianship andexcessive corporal punishment. Petitioner submitted a request to respondent Office ofChildren and Family Services to amend the report from indicated to unfounded, whichrequest was denied. Thereafter, following an administrative hearing conducted pursuantto Social Services Law § 422 (8) (b), the Administrative Law Judgedetermined that the maltreatment allegation was supported by a preponderance of theevidence and that the indicated report may be disclosed to inquiring agencies pursuant toSocial Services Law § 424-a. Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78proceeding seeking to, among other [*2]things, annulrespondents' determination that he engaged in maltreatment.
" 'At an administrative hearing to determine whether a report of child abuseor maltreatment is substantiated, the allegations in the report must be established by a fairpreponderance of the evidence' " (Matter of Timothy G. v New York State Off. of Children &Family Servs., 121 AD3d 788, 789 [2014], quoting Matter of Marie A.P. v NassauCounty Dept. of Social Servs., 100 AD3d 1003, 1003-1004 [2012]; seeMatter of Lee TT. v Dowling, 211 AD2d 46, 49 [1995], affd 87 NY2d 699[1996]). Specifically, " '[t]o establish that maltreatment occurred, the agencymust show that the child's physical, mental or emotional condition has been impaired oris in imminent danger of becoming impaired as a result of the parent's failure to exercisea minimum degree of care' " (Matter of Stephen C. v Johnson, 39 AD3d 932, 933 [2007],lv denied 9 NY3d 804 [2007], quoting Matter of Tonette E. v New York State Off. of Children &Family Servs., 25 AD3d 994, 995 [2006]; see 18 NYCRR 432.1 [b] [1];Matter of Cheryl Z. vCarrion, 119 AD3d 1109, 1110 [2014]). In our consideration of the underlyingdetermination, "our focus is whether the determination is rational and supported bysubstantial evidence" (Matter of Steven A. v New York State Off. of Children &Family Servs., 307 AD2d 434, 435 [2003] [internal quotation marks and citationomitted]; see Matter of Cheryl Z. v Carrion, 119 AD3d at 1110; Matter of Susan XX. v TiogaCounty Dept. of Social Servs., 74 AD3d 1543, 1543-1544 [2010]).
Petitioner testified that, after he spanked the child, the child cried briefly, and thenthe family resumed their normal evening activities. The father explained that theimpression left on the child's buttock had been exacerbated by the sensitivity of thechild's skin to the hot bath water and, further, that the child did not complain of pain orappear to be negatively affected by the incident. The record shows that petitioner wasclearly remorseful and cooperated fully with Department of Social Services investigators.Petitioner attended an anger management workshop and a parenting course, whichpetitioner acknowledged were helpful and encouraged him to adopt age-appropriatemethods of child discipline. Moreover, petitioner's spouse indicated that she had neverobserved petitioner engaged in excessive corporal punishment and that she and petitionernormally placed their children in a "time out" when invoking discipline inside thehome.
A parent is "entitled to use reasonable physical force to promote discipline" (Matter of Collin H., 28 AD3d806, 809 [2006]), however, the application of such force may not "exceed[ ] thethreshold of reasonableness" (Matter of Anthony C., 201 AD2d 342, 342-343[1994]). Although a single instance of excessive corporal punishment can suffice for afinding of maltreatment (see Matter of Vincent KK. v State of N.Y. Off. of Children& Family Servs., 284 AD2d 777, 777 [2001]), here, the record lacks substantialevidence demonstrating that petitioner's conduct "impaired or was in imminent danger ofimpairing [the child's] physical, mental, or emotional condition" (Matter of Hattie G. v MonroeCounty Dept. of Social Servs., Children's Servs. Unit, 48 AD3d 1292,1293-1294 [2008]; see Matterof Matthew WW. v Johnson, 20 AD3d 669, 671 [2005]; compare Matter ofCollin H., 28 AD3d at 808-809; Matter of Castilloux v New York State Off. of Children &Family Servs., 16 AD3d 1061, 1062 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 702[2005]).
Lahtinen, J.P., Garry and Clark, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isannulled, without costs, and petition granted.