| Matter of Thomas v Condon |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 04237 [128 AD3d 528] |
| May 19, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Michael P. Thomas,Appellant, v Richard J. Condon, Special Commissioner of Investigation for theNew York City School District, et al., Respondents. |
Michael P. Thomas, appellant pro se.
Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Elizabeth S. Natrella ofcounsel), for respondent.
Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Frank P. Nervo, J.), enteredSeptember 30, 2014, to the extent appealed from, denying the petition to compel thedisclosure of documents pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (Public OfficersLaw art 6) (FOIL), and dismissing the proceeding brought pursuant to CPLR article 78,unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs, and the matter remanded for furtherproceedings consistent herewith.
Petitioner seeks materials pertaining to the investigation of two complaints filed byhim and another person with the Office of the Special Commissioner of Investigation forthe New York City School District (SCI) concerning whether a speech that was given byan employee of the New York State Department of Education (DOE) at a public highschool and later reproduced on DOE's website violated New York City Department ofEducation Chancellor's Regulations D-130 (I) (B) (2) and (8) and (C) (1). Theseregulations govern the use of school buildings by political candidates, officials andorganizations and the conduct of school employees and officers with respect to politicalcampaigns and elections.
Supreme Court improperly suggested that petitioner had the burden to establish thatrespondents' denial of his FOIL request was "arbitrary and capricious," "an abuse ofdiscretion," "irrational," or "unlawful." The appropriate standard of review is whether thedetermination "was affected by an error of law" (CPLR 7803 [3]; Mulgrew v Board of Educ. of theCity School Dist. of the City of N.Y., 87 AD3d 506, 507 [1st Dept 2011], lvdenied 18 NY3d 806 [2012]). Moreover, the burden is on respondents to establish"that 'the material requested falls squarely within the ambit of one of the[ ] statutoryexemptions' " from disclosure (Matter of Town of Waterford v New York State Dept. of Envtl.Conservation, 18 NY3d 652, 657 [2012]; see Public Officers Law§ 87 [2]). Under the circumstances of this case, the application of animproper legal standard is reversible error since it resulted in substantial prejudice topetitioner (cf. Mulgrew, 87 AD3d at 507 [no remand necessary sincedetermination that requested materials should be released was proper]; Matter of Miller v New York StateDiv. of Human Rights, 122 AD3d 431 [1st Dept 2014] [no remand necessarysince determination that requested materials need not be released was proper]).
Respondents failed to establish that disclosure of the materials at issue would"constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy under the provisions of [section89 (2)]" (Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [b]). They do not claim that anypersonal privacy category enumerated in section 89 (2) is applicable. Therefore, we mustdetermine whether any invasion of personal privacy would be unwarranted "by balancingthe privacy interests at stake against the public interest in disclosure of the information"(Matter of New York Times Co.v City of N.Y. Fire Dept., 4 NY3d 477, 485 [2005]). The speech at issueexcoriated unspecified candidates in the 2013 mayoral election who had taken certainpositions on education policy. Notwithstanding that the speech did not name anyindividual candidate or political party, the complaints to SCI raised serious questionsabout the propriety of the speech and its publication on DOE's website. We find thatthere is a[*2]"significant public interest" in the requestedmaterials, which may shed light on whether this matter was adequately investigated (see Matter of Thomas v New YorkCity Dept. of Educ., 103 AD3d 495, 497 [1st Dept 2013]). Respondents failedto establish that the claimed privacy interests outweigh this public interest (see Matter of Asian Am. LegalDefense & Educ. Fund v New York City Police Dept., 125 AD3d 531, 532[1st Dept 2015]). They assert that the materials contain personally identifyinginformation such as home addresses, dates of birth, and Social Security numbers.However, that information can be redacted and does not provide a basis for withholdingentire documents (see Matter ofData Tree, LLC v Romaine, 9 NY3d 454, 463-464 [2007]; see alsoPublic Officers Law § 89 [2]).
Respondents also failed to demonstrate the applicability of the inter- or intra-agencyexemption, since some or all of the materials may constitute "factual tabulations or data"or "final agency . . . determinations," which do not fall within thisexemption (Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [g] [i], [iii]; see Matter ofGould v New York City Police Dept., 89 NY2d 267, 276-277 [1996]).
Accordingly, we direct that defendant produce the requested information to theextent it constitutes factual data or final agency determinations. Personal identifyinginformation such as names, home addresses, dates of birth and Social Security numbersmay be redacted. All other requested materials shall be provided to the court for an incamera inspection.
Petitioner's request for litigation costs pursuant to Public Officers Law§ 89 (4) (c) is premature. Any determination of whether such costs arewarranted must await the court's in camera inspection. Concur—Sweeny, J.P.,Moskowitz, Manzanet-Daniels and Gische, JJ.