Matter of Winterton Props., LLC v Town of MamakatingZoning Bd. of Appeals
2015 NY Slip Op 07734 [132 AD3d 1141]
October 22, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 9, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of Winterton Properties, LLC, Appellant,v Town of Mamakating Zoning Board of Appeals et al., Respondents, et al.,Respondents.

Whiteman, Osterman & Hanna, LLP, Albany (John J. Henry of counsel), forappellant.

Steven N. Mogel, Monticello, for Town of Mamakating Zoning Board of Appealsand others, respondents.

Garry, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (McGuire, J.), entered April3, 2015 in Sullivan County, which partially dismissed petitioner's application, in acombined proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgment,to, among other things, review a determination of respondent Town of MamakatingZoning Board of Appeals interpreting the Town Code of the Town of Mamakating asprohibiting petitioner's proposed development plan.

Petitioner is the owner of real property in the Town of Mamakating, SullivanCounty. The property had previously been used as a day spa, and petitioner proposes toconvert it to use as a mikvah.[FN1] The subject property is located withinan area designated as a Village Center zoning district, and the Town's zoning law permitsproperty in this district to be used for, among other things, "[n]eighborhood places ofworship" (Town of Mamakating Zoning Code, Schedule I). The Town BuildingInspector issued a written determination that the proposed use conformed with thedefinition of a neighborhood place of [*2]worship andwas therefore a permitted use. Following approval of petitioner's site plan by the TownPlanning Board, respondents Donna Matland and Hilmar Maier sought review of theBuilding Inspector's determination by respondent Town of Mamakating Zoning Board ofAppeals (hereinafter ZBA). The ZBA disagreed with the determination of the BuildingInspector, concluding that a mikvah did not constitute a neighborhood place of worshipand disallowing petitioner's proposed use. Petitioner then commenced this combinedCPLR article 78 proceeding and action for a declaratory judgment seeking to annul theZBA's determination, a declaration that the proposed mikvah is a neighborhood place ofworship under the Town's zoning law, and an award of costs. Supreme Court dismissedthe petition and granted costs, disbursements, and counsel fees to respondents. Petitionerappeals.

Petitioner presented numerous submissions to the ZBA, including letters fromreligious scholars, seeking to establish that a mikvah constitutes a neighborhood place ofworship. These materials established that a mikvah is generally housed in a stand alonebuilding set apart from a synagogue and dedicated solely to religious purposes. UnderJewish Law, a mikvah must be built in a new community even before the construction ofa synagogue. Jacob Schacter, a rabbi and professor of Jewish history, explained that anindividual's immersion in the waters of a mikvah is "a basic religious ritual [of OrthodoxJews] for the purpose of restoring spiritual and family purity." According to BinyaminHammer, another rabbi, the ritual is "vital to those who observe Jewish laws." Petitioner'ssubmissions further showed that immersion in a mikvah is generally accompanied by therecitation of blessings or prayers.

The parties agree that the term "neighborhood place of worship" is neither defined inthe Town's zoning law, nor does it appear elsewhere in the Town's ordinances. Thezoning law does provide, however, that "[w]ords not specifically defined shall have theirordinary dictionary meanings" (Town of Mamakating Zoning Code § 199-6[A]). Thus, the pertinent inquiry distills to whether petitioner's proposed mikvahcomports with the dictionary definition of a neighborhood place of worship. Althoughcourts will ordinarily defer to a zoning board's interpretation of a local ordinance, when"the issue presented is one of pure legal interpretation of the underlying zoning law orordinance, deference is not required" (Matter of Albany Basketball & Sports Corp. v City ofAlbany, 116 AD3d 1135, 1137 [2014] [internal quotation marks and citationomitted], lv denied 23 NY3d 907 [2014]; see Matter of Raritan Dev. Corp. vSilva, 91 NY2d 98, 102 [1997]). The issue posed is susceptible to resolution as amatter of law by interpretation of the ordinance terms.

"Neighborhood" is defined as "[t]he immediate vicinity; the area near or next to aspecified place" (Black's Law Dictionary 1200 [10th ed 2014]). A "place" is "a building,location, etc., set aside for a specific purpose" (Random House Webster's UnabridgedDictionary 1478 [2d ed 1998]). "Worship" is defined as "[a]ny form of religiousdevotion, ritual, or service showing reverence, esp[ecially] for a divine being orsupernatural power" (Black's Law Dictionary 1844 [10th ed 2014]). Thus, the dictionarymeaning of neighborhood place of worship—and consequently the definition ofthat term under the Town's zoning law—is a building or location set aside in acertain area for any form of religious devotion, ritual or service showing reverence,especially for a divine being or supernatural power.

As petitioner asserts, the ZBA imposed an additional requirement ofcommunal worship in its interpretation. The terms of the ordinance do notsupport this requirement, nor do we find [*3]it to beeither established or supported by the dictionary definition, as set forth above.[FN2] In interpreting a zoninglaw, a zoning board of appeals "may not insert conditions or criteria into a zoningordinance governing allowable uses in a zoned district that are not contained in thestatutory language adopted" (Matter of Saratoga County Economic Opportunity Council, Inc. vVillage of Ballston Spa Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 112 AD3d 1035, 1037 [2013]).Moreover, respondents' proposed definition would, even if accepted, merely evidence an"ambiguity in the language employed [that] must be resolved in favor of the propertyowner" (Matter of Subdivisions,Inc. v Town of Sullivan, 92 AD3d 1184, 1185 [2012] [internal quotation marksand citation omitted], lv denied 19 NY3d 811 [2012]; see Matter of AlbanyBasketball & Sports Corp. v City of Albany, 116 AD3d at 1137; Matter of Atkinson v Wilt, 94AD3d 1218, 1220 [2012]).

Upon review, we find that the uncontroverted evidence establishes that a mikvahcomports with the definition of a neighborhood place of worship and, thus, constitutesthe same for purposes of the Town's zoning law. Accordingly, Supreme Court erred indismissing the petition to that extent (see Matter of Albany Basketball & SportsCorp. v City of Albany, 116 AD3d at 1139; Matter of Arceri v Town of Islip Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 16AD3d 411, 412-413 [2005]). However, as there is no evidence that the ZBA "actedwith gross negligence or in bad faith or with malice," we reject petitioner's contentionthat an award of costs should be rendered (Town Law § 267-c [2]; seeMatter of Mason v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Clifton Park, 72 AD2d 889,890 [1979]). Further, we vacate the award of costs, disbursements and counsel fees torespondents. In light of this disposition, petitioner's remaining arguments are renderedacademic.

Peters, P.J., McCarthy and Rose, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is modified,on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as (1) dismissed that part of thepetition seeking to annul the determination of respondent Town of Mamakating ZoningBoard of Appeals prohibiting petitioner's proposed development plan, and (2) awardedcosts, disbursements and counsel fees to respondents; said determination annulled, theaward of costs, disbursements and counsel fees vacated, and it is declared that petitioner'sproposed mikvah is a neighborhood place of worship for purposes of the Town ofMamakating Zoning Code; and, as so modified, affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:A mikvah is a bath-likestructure used in certain Jewish religious practices.

Footnote 2:In so holding, we do notoverlook the public hearing statements of a ZBA member regarding a "consensus of adefinition" based upon research that she had performed in an attempt to define the term"place of worship." While the ZBA member concluded that there was a componentinvolving congregations, no clear dictionary authority to this effect has been cited, eitherat that hearing or in the briefs upon appeal.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.