Raach v SLSJET Mgt. Corp.
2015 NY Slip Op 09085 [134 AD3d 792]
December 9, 2015
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 11, 2015


[*1]
 Walid Raach et al., Appellants,
v
SLSJETManagement Corp., Also Known as Yellow Cab SLSJET Management Corp.,Respondent.

David Abrams, New York, N.Y., for appellants.

Herrick, Feinstein LLP, New York, N.Y. (Chantelle L. Aris and Susan T. Dwyer ofcounsel), for respondent.

In an action to recover damages for breach of contract, the plaintiffs appeal, aslimited by their brief, from so much of an order of the Supreme Court, Queens County(Weiss, J.), dated November 25, 2014, as granted those branches of the defendant'smotion which were, in effect, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7) to dismiss so muchof the complaint as alleged breach of contract based upon the defendant's allegedimproper retention of monies in excess of the applicable daily lease rate as set forth in theparties' lease agreements and based upon alleged violations of certain provisions of theparties' lease agreements governing the imposition of late fees.

Ordered that the order is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, with costs,and those branches of the defendant's motion which were, in effect, pursuant to CPLR3211 (a) (1) and (7) to dismiss so much of the complaint as alleged breach of contractbased upon the defendant's alleged improper retention of monies in excess of theapplicable daily lease rate as set forth in the parties' lease agreements and based uponalleged violations of certain provisions of the parties' lease agreements governing theimposition of late fees are denied.

The plaintiffs were taxicab drivers who leased cars and taxi medallions from thedefendant. The plaintiffs commenced this action against the defendant to recoverdamages for breach of contract. In the complaint, the plaintiffs alleged that the defendantbreached certain daily lease agreements by improperly retaining monies in excess of theapplicable daily lease rate as set forth in the agreements and by failing to comply withcertain provisions of the agreements governing the imposition of late fees.

The defendant moved pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) to dismiss the complaint. TheSupreme Court, inter alia, granted those branches of the defendant's motion which were,in effect, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7) to dismiss so much of the complaint asalleged breach of contract based upon the defendant's alleged improper retention ofmonies in excess of the applicable daily lease rate as set forth in the parties' leaseagreements and based upon alleged violations of certain provisions of the leaseagreements governing the imposition of late fees. The plaintiffs [*2]appeal from those portions of the order. We reverse theorder insofar as appealed from.

In considering a motion to dismiss a cause of action pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7),"the court must accept the facts as alleged in the complaint as true, accord plaintiffs thebenefit of every possible favorable inference, and determine only whether the facts asalleged fit within any cognizable legal theory" (Sokol v Leader, 74 AD3d 1180, 1181 [2010] [internalquotation marks omitted]; seeNonnon v City of New York, 9 NY3d 825, 827 [2007]; Leon vMartinez, 84 NY2d 83, 87-88 [1994]).

Here, contrary to the Supreme Court's conclusion, the complaint does not seek toprivately enforce the Rules of the City of New York Taxi and Limousine Commission(hereinafter TLC Rules). Rather, the complaint alleged that certain TLC Rules wereexpressly incorporated into the parties' daily lease agreements (cf. Pervaiz v Queens MedallionLeasing, Inc., 107 AD3d 554, 554-555 [2013]; Rashid v B. Taxi Mgt. Inc.,107 AD3d 555, 556 [2013];De La Rosa v All Taxi Mgt., Inc., 107 AD3d 553, 553 [2013]; Desmangles v Woodside Mgt.,Inc., 107 AD3d 551, 552 [2013]). The fact that the contractual provisions atissue may have been inserted in order to comply with TLC Rules does not extinguish theplaintiffs' right to enforce those contractual provisions by asserting a cause of actionalleging breach of contract (accord Cox v NAP Constr. Co., Inc., 10 NY3d 592, 602[2008]; Wright v Wright Stucco, 50 NY2d 837 [1980]; Fata v S.A. HealyCo., 289 NY 401, 406-407 [1943]; Strong v American Fence Constr. Co.,245 NY 48, 53 [1927]; Melissakis v Proto Constr. & Dev. Corp., 294 AD2d342, 342 [2002]). Accordingly, affording the complaint a liberal construction, acceptingall facts as alleged in the complaint to be true, and according the plaintiffs the benefit ofevery possible favorable inference, the plaintiffs stated a cause of action to recoverdamages for breach of contract based upon the defendant's alleged improper retention ofmonies in excess of the applicable daily lease rate as set forth in the parties' leaseagreements and based upon alleged violations of the provisions of the parties' leaseagreements governing the imposition of late fees.

The Supreme Court also erred to the extent that it directed the dismissal of thoseportions of the complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1). Contrary to the defendant'scontention, the arguments raised by the plaintiffs on appeal with respect to this issue areproperly before this Court (seegenerally Spiegel-Porco v Porco, 127 AD3d 847, 848 [2015]).

A motion pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) to dismiss a complaint based ondocumentary evidence may be appropriately granted "only where the documentaryevidence utterly refutes plaintiff's factual allegations, conclusively establishing a defenseas a matter of law" (Goshen v Mutual Life Ins. Co. of N.Y., 98 NY2d 314, 326[2002]; see Jahan v U.S. BankN.A., 127 AD3d 926, 927 [2015]). In opposition to a motion pursuant to CPLR3211 (a), a plaintiff may submit affidavits "to preserve inartfully pleaded, but potentiallymeritorious, claims" (Rovello v Orofino Realty Co., 40 NY2d 633, 635 [1976];see Town of Huntington v LongIs. Power Auth., 130 AD3d 1013, 1015 [2015]).

Here, the defendant failed to establish that the two daily lease agreements that itsubmitted in support of its motion governed the parties' relationships during the periodsalleged in the complaint. Furthermore, the defendant's documentary submissions did not,without more, conclusively refute the plaintiffs' allegation that the parties' writtenagreements were orally modified by the parties (accord Martini v Rogers, 6 AD3d 404 [2004];Expocorp v Hyatt Mgt. Corp. of N.Y., 134 AD2d 234 [1987]; Allied Chem.Corp. v Alpha Portland Indus., 58 AD2d 975, 977 [1977]). Accordingly, thedocumentary evidence relied on by the defendant did not utterly refute the plaintiffs'factual allegations and conclusively establish a defense as a matter of law (seeGoshen v Mutual Life Ins. Co. of N.Y., 98 NY2d at 326; see generally All Is. Media, Inc. vCreative AD Worx, Inc., 79 AD3d 677, 678-679 [2010]; Wild Oaks, LLC v Joseph A.Beehan, Jr. Gen. Contr., Inc., 77 AD3d 924, 926 [2010]; Nwauwa v Mamos, 53 AD3d646, 649 [2008]).

In light of the foregoing, the Supreme Court should have denied those branches ofthe defendant's motion which were, in effect, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7) todismiss so much of the complaint as alleged breach of contract based upon thedefendant's alleged improper retention of monies in excess of the applicable daily leaserate as set forth in the parties' lease agreements and based upon alleged violations ofcertain provisions of the parties' lease agreements governing the imposition of late fees.Rivera, J.P., Dickerson, Miller and Maltese, JJ., concur. [Prior Case History: 2014NY Slip Op 33339(U).]


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.