Matter of Walczyk v Lewis Tree Serv., Inc.
2015 NY Slip Op 09577 [134 AD3d 1364]
December 24, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 11, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of the Claim of Robert Walczyk,Respondent, v Lewis Tree Service, Inc., Respondent, and Zurich American InsuranceCompany, Appellant. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

Conway & Goren, Melville (Frank Malagreca of counsel), for appellant.

Grey & Grey, LLP, Farmingdale (Brian P. O'Keefe of counsel), for RobertWalczyk, respondent.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Steven Segall of counsel),for Workers' Compensation Board, respondent.

Lynch, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filedFebruary 14, 2014, which ruled that claimant was entitled to a schedule loss of use awardpayable in a lump sum.

Claimant, while employed as a tree service worker for the employer, filed a claim fora back injury in 2005 for which he was awarded compensation. It was ultimatelydetermined in 2009 that he had a resulting permanent partial disability for which hethereafter received continuing disability benefits. Claimant also filed a claim in 2007 forwork-related bilateral carpel tunnel syndrome, which was established as an occupationaldisease. A Workers' Compensation Law Judge determined in 2013 that claimant had apermanent partial disability [*2]with a 15% schedule lossof use of each hand as a result of the carpel tunnel syndrome. Applying the applicablestatute, claimant's schedule loss of use award would be $29,280, based upon 73.2 weeksof compensation (see Workers' Compensation Law § 15 [3][c]).[FN1] TheWorkers' Compensation Law Judge concluded, however, that in order to stay within themaximum statutory weekly compensation of $400 (see Workers' CompensationLaw § 15 [6]), since claimant continued to be concurrently paidcompensation for the back injury at a rate of $380 per week (from Apr. 10, 2007 to May10, 2008) and at a rate of $360.16 thereafter, the loss of use award for bilateral carpeltunnel syndrome should be paid at a weekly rate of $39.84 (when added to the $360.16per week for the back injury equals $400 weekly) for the statutory 73.2 weeks. As aresult, claimant would receive a total schedule loss of use award of only $2,916 ($39.84weekly x 73.2 weeks = $2,916). The Workers' Compensation Board modified, bydetermining that claimant is entitled to be paid the full schedule loss of use award (i.e.,$29,280) in a lump sum pursuant to Workers' Compensation Law § 25 (1)(b). The employer's carrier appeals.

We affirm. The Board correctly held that Workers' Compensation Law§§ 15 (3) (u) and 25 (1) (b), as amended in 2009 (see L 2009,ch 351, §§ 1, 2), authorize the payment of the schedule loss of useaward in a lump sum. The purpose of a schedule loss of use award for a permanentpartial disability is "to compensate for loss of earning power" (Matter of LaCroix v SyracuseExec. Air Serv., Inc., 8 NY3d 348, 353 [2007] [internal quotation marks andcitation omitted]). That is, it "is not given for an injury, but for the residual physical andfunctional impairments" (Matterof Empara v New Rochelle Sch. Dist., 130 AD3d 1127, 1129 [2015], lvdenied 26 NY3d 911 [2015]). Whether a schedule loss award or continuing disabilitybenefits is warranted is a question of fact for the Board to resolve (see id.), andthe parties do not dispute the propriety here of a schedule loss award, which is allowedwhere "there is no continuing need for medical treatment and the medical condition isessentially stable" (Matter ofLevitsky v Garden Time, Inc., 126 AD3d 1264, 1264 [2015] [internal quotationmarks omitted]). Although, for purposes of calculating permanent partial disabilityawards, Workers' Compensation Law § 15 (3) "assigns . . . afixed number of lost weeks' compensation according to the bodily member injured"(Matter of LaCroix v Syracuse Exec. Air Serv., Inc., 8 NY3d at 353; accord Matter of Schmidt v FallsDodge, Inc., 19 NY3d 178, 181 [2012]), "the weekly rate and number of weeksin the schedule are merely the measure by which an award is calculated . . .and payment of the schedule award is not allocable to any . . .period of disability" (Matterof Cruz v City of N.Y. Dept. of Children's Servs., 123 AD3d 1390, 1391 [2014],lv denied 26 NY3d 905 [2015] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citationsomitted; emphasis added]).

Under established precedent, where an injured worker is receiving nonscheduledaward payments and periodic schedule loss of use award payments for differentinjuries, the concurrent payments may not exceed the statutory cap of $400 per week inbenefits, as provided by Workers' Compensation Law § 15 (6) (a) (see Matter of Schmidt v FallsDodge, Inc., 19 NY3d 178, 183 [2012]; Matter of Sciame v Airborne Express, Inc., 101 AD3d1419, 1420 [2012], lv denied 20 NY3d 860 [2013]). As relevant here,however, under Workers' Compensation Law §§ 15 (3) (u) [*3]and 25 (1) (b), as amended in 2009, where there is apermanent partial loss of use of more than one member or body part, the award "shall befully payable in one lump sum upon the request of the injured employee" (Workers'Compensation Law § 15 [3] [u]).[FN2] These statutory amendments were aresponse to existing precedent holding that, contrary to Board policy, the Workers'Compensation Law precludes payment of schedule loss of use awards for a permanentpartial disability as a lump sum (see Matter of LaCroix v Syracuse Exec. Air Serv.,Inc., 8 NY3d at 351, 354; Assembly Mem in Support, 2009 McKinney's SessionLaws of NY at 1720-1721).

In view of the foregoing, we find that the Board correctly ordered the schedule lossof use award to be paid in a lump sum as an authorized alternative to periodic payments,which did not violate the maximum disability rate provisions of Workers' CompensationLaw § 15 (6). Contrary to the carrier's argument, in Matter of Schmidt vFalls Dodge, Inc. (19 NY3d at 183), the Court of Appeals expressly declined toaddress the implications of the 2009 amendments, and nothing in that decision precludesthe Board's award to claimant of a schedule loss of use award in one lump sum.

Garry, J.P., Rose, Devine and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision isaffirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:That figure was arrivedat by multiplying the loss of use percentage by the number of weeks of compensationpayable for the loss of each hand (15% x 244 weeks for each hand equals 36.6 weeks foreach hand, or 73.2 weeks for both hands) (see Workers' Compensation Law§ 15 [3] [c], [s]), and multiplying that number of weeks by the maximumweekly compensation allowed, $400 per week (see Workers' Compensation Law§ 15 [6]), for a total award of $29,280 (73.2 weeks x $400 per weekmaximum = $29,280).

Footnote 2:Prior to the 2009amendments, the Board also possessed the authority to commute periodic payments to alump-sum payment in the interest of justice (see Workers' Compensation Law§ 25 [5] [b]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.