Matter of South Shore Press, Inc. v Havemeyer
2016 NY Slip Op 01191 [136 AD3d 929]
February 17, 2016
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 23, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of South Shore Press, Inc.,Appellant,
v
Fred Havemeyer et al., Respondents.

J. Lee Snead, Bellport, NY, for appellant.

Tiffany S. Scarlato, Town Attorney, Southampton, NY, for respondents.

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to compel the production of certaindocuments pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law art 6) andfor an award of an attorney's fee and litigation costs, the petitioner appeals from so muchof a judgment of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Whelan, J.), entered February 7,2012, as, upon an order of the same court dated June 9, 2011, denied that branch of thepetition which was for an award of an attorney's fee and litigation costs.

Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, withcosts, that branch of the petition which was for an award of an attorney's fee andlitigation costs is granted, and the matter is remitted to the Supreme Court, SuffolkCounty, for a determination of the amount of the attorney's fee and litigation costs to beawarded to the petitioner and, thereafter, the entry of an amended judgment.

On May 28, 2010, the petitioner made a request to the Trustees of the Freeholdersand Commonalty of the Town of Southampton (hereinafter the Town Trustees) pursuantto the Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law art 6) (hereinafter FOIL)seeking certain of the Town Trustees' banking and financial records. Pursuant to PublicOfficers Law § 89 (3) (a), the Town Trustees were required to provide awritten acknowledgment of the petitioner's FOIL request within five business days of itsreceipt. The petitioner's FOIL request was received on June 1, 2010. The Town Trustees,however, did not acknowledge the petitioner's FOIL request within the statutory timeperiod. As a result, the petitioner submitted a FOIL appeal, requesting an explanation forthe constructive denial of its FOIL request. In a letter dated June 30, 2010, the TownTrustees' counsel acknowledged receipt of the FOIL request, and informed the petitionerthat the FOIL request "may be an unduly broad or voluminous request," and "wouldinterfere with the day-to-day operations of an already heavily burdened department," andrequested additional time to continue compiling responsive documents. Theacknowledgment did not provide the approximate date when the FOIL request would begranted in whole or part, as required by Public Officers Law § 89 (3)(a).

In September 2010, the petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceedingseeking, inter alia, to compel the respondents to comply with its FOIL request, as well asan award of an attorney's fee and costs pursuant to Public Officers Law§ 89 (4) (c). The Supreme Court concluded that the respondents'contentions that the requested documents fell within the statutory exemptions of PublicOfficers Law § 87 (2) (b) and (i) were "general and conclusory" and,therefore, [*2]insufficient. The court further found thatthe respondents' other reasons for denying access, the voluminous nature of the requestand failure to exhaust administrative remedies, were either contrary to the mandates ofFOIL or otherwise without merit. The court granted that branch of the petition which wasto direct the respondents to comply with the FOIL request, and denied that branch of thepetition which was for an award of an attorney's fee and costs. The petitionerappeals.

A court may award a reasonable attorney's fee and other litigation costs to apetitioner in a proceeding to review the denial of a FOIL request where the petitioner has"substantially prevailed" in the proceeding, and "(i) the agency had no reasonable basisfor denying access; or (ii) the agency failed to respond to a request or appeal within thestatutory time" (Public Officers Law § 89 [4] [c]). The award of attorney'sfees is intended to " 'create a clear deterrent to unreasonable delays and denials ofaccess [and thereby] encourage every unit of government to make a good faith effort tocomply with the requirements of FOIL' " (Matter of New York Civ. Liberties Union v City of SaratogaSprings, 87 AD3d 336, 338 [2011], quoting Senate Introducer Mem in Support,Bill Jacket, L 2006, ch 492 at 5). Here, all of the statutory prerequisites for such an awardhave been satisfied (see Public Officers Law § 89 [4] [c]).Moreover, an award of an attorney's fee and costs pursuant to FOIL is particularlyappropriate in this proceeding in order to promote the purpose of and policy behindFOIL. Specifically, in enacting FOIL, the legislature declared that "government is thepublic's business" and expressly found that "a free society is maintained whengovernment is responsive and responsible to the public, and when the public is aware ofgovernmental actions" (Public Officers Law § 84). Accordingly, we remitthis matter to the Supreme Court, Suffolk County, for a determination of the amount ofthe attorney's fee and costs to be awarded to the petitioner and, thereafter, the entry of anamended judgment (see Matterof Bottom v Fischer, 129 AD3d 1604, 1605 [2015]; Matter of Legal Aid Socy. v NewYork State Dept. of Corr. & Community Supervision, 105 AD3d 1120,1122 [2013]). Balkin, J.P., Dickerson, Hall and Roman, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.