Matter of Rosenfelder (Community First Holdings,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor)
2016 NY Slip Op 01888 [137 AD3d 1438]
March 17, 2016
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 27, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of the Claim of Nancy B. Rosenfelder,Respondent. Community First Holdings, Inc., Doing Business as Lockport Union Sun& Journal, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent.

Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC, Syracuse (Peter A. Jones of counsel) and TheZinser Law Firm, PC, Nashville, Tennessee (L. Michael Zinser admitted pro hac vice),for appellant.

Michelle I. Rosien, Philmont, for Nancy B. Rosenfelder, respondent.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Steven Koton of counsel),for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.

Satterlee Stephens Burke & Burke LLP, New York City (Mark A. Fowler ofcounsel), for New York News Publishers Association, amicus curiae.

McCarthy, J.P. Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance AppealBoard, filed May 21, 2014, which ruled, among other things, that Community FirstHoldings, Inc. was liable for unemployment insurance contributions on remunerationpaid to claimant and others similarly situated.

Community First Holdings, Inc. (hereinafter CFHI) prints and publishes a dailynewspaper. In January 2012, claimant entered into a contract with CFHI to delivernewspapers within designated geographic routes using her own vehicle. When claimantbecame unable to service the routes due to vehicle problems, she ended her contract andapplied for unemployment insurance benefits. The Department of Labor issued initialdeterminations finding that she was [*2]eligible toreceive benefits and that CFHI was liable for additional unemployment insurancecontributions on remuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated. CFHIobjected and, following lengthy hearings, an Administrative Law Judge overruled theinitial determinations and found that claimant was an independent contractor, not anemployee of CFHI. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board disagreed and ruled,among other things, that an employment relationship existed between CFHI andclaimant, and that CFHI was liable for unemployment insurance contributions onremuneration paid to her and others similarly situated. CFHI now appeals.

The existence of an employment relationship is a factual issue for the Board toresolve and its decision in this regard will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence(see Matter of Concourse Ophthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736[1983]; Matter of Hunter[Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 125 AD3d 1166, 1167[2015]). The pertinent inquiry is whether the purported employer exercised "control overthe results produced or the means used to achieve those results . . . with thelatter being more important" (Matter of Joyce [Coface N. Am. Ins. Co.—Commissioner ofLabor], 116 AD3d 1132, 1134 [2014] [internal quotation marks and citationomitted]; see Matter of Armison[Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 122 AD3d 1101, 1102[2014], lv dismissed 24 NY3d 1209 [2015]).

Here, claimant responded to a newspaper advertisement soliciting motor routecarriers and was retained by CFHI after meeting with its district manager. Claimantsigned an independent contractor distributor agreement that (1) assigned her specificroutes, (2) required her to furnish her own vehicle with proof of insurance, (3) set forthspecific rates governing her compensation, (4) required her to deliver newspapers in adry condition by specified times, (5) imposed a penalty upon her if CFHI had to make adelivery due to a subscriber complaint, and (6) provided for termination of the contractby CFHI in the event that claimant received more than 10 subscriber complaints.Although no formal training was provided by CFHI, its district manager reviewed achecklist with claimant containing detailed information that she needed to know toperform her duties. In addition, CFHI provided claimant with optional property damageand personal injury insurance for purchase through an independent carrier, madeavailable supplies, such as rain bags and rubber bands, for claimant to purchase,prohibited claimant from placing any inserts or other materials in the newspapers to bedelivered and fielded customer complaints before referring them to claimant. As in manyof the other newspaper delivery carrier cases, the record as a whole contains substantialevidence to support the conclusion that CFHI retained a sufficient indicia of control overthe performance of claimant's duties to establish the existence of an employmentrelationship (see Matter of Hunter [Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 125 AD3d at 1167-1168; Matter of Isaacs [Speedy Media Assoc.,LLC—Commissioner of Labor], 125 AD3d 1077, 1078-1079 [2015];Matter of Armison [Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 122AD3d at 1102-1103; see also Matter of Gray [Glens FallsNewspapers—Roberts], 134 AD2d 791, 791-792 [1987]). Furthermore, thereis no indication that the Board ignored the Department of Labor's guidelines in reachingits decisions (see Matter ofTravis [Gannett Satellite Info. Network, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 127AD3d 1349, 1349 [2015]; Matter of Armison [Gannett Co.,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 122 AD3d at 1103). CFHI's remainingcontentions were raised for the first time in its reply brief and are therefore not properlybefore us (see Schulz vCuomo, 133 AD3d 945, 948 [2015], appeal dismissed 26 NY3d 1139[2016]).

Egan Jr., Rose, Devine and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.