Matter of Friends of P.S. 163, Inc. v Jewish Home Lifecare,Manhattan
2017 NY Slip Op 00383 [146 AD3d 576]
January 19, 2017
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 1, 2017


[*1](January 19, 2017)
 In the Matter of The Friends of P.S. 163, Inc., et al.,Respondents,
v
Jewish Home Lifecare, Manhattan, Appellant, et al.,Respondents. In the Matter of Daisy Wright et al., Respondents, v New York StateDepartment of Health et al., Respondents, and Jewish Home Lifecare, Manhattan,Appellant.

Greenberg Traurig, LLP, New York (Steven C. Russo of counsel), for appellant.

Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, New York (René Kathawala ofcounsel), for The Friends of P.S. 163 Inc.; The P.S. 163 School Leadership Team; JoshuaKross; Miles Kross, by his father, Joshua Kross; Stella Kross, by her father, JoshuaKross, Eugenia Fingerman; Elijah Fingerman, by his mother Eugenia Fingerman; GiselleSanchez; Giovanni Feliciano, by his mother, Giselle Sanchez; Lucindy Cuevas; AnneliLopez, by her mother, Lucindy Cuevas; Kevin Richardson; Cameron Richardson, by hisfather, Kevin Richardson; Daniel Webster; Daniel J. Webster by his father, DanielWebster; Daniel Holt; and Rachel Baker-Holt, by her father, Daniel Holt,respondents.

New York Environmental Law & Justice Project, New York (John R. Low-Beerof counsel), for Daisy Wright, Nathaniel Robert Livingston by his parent Daisy Wright,Oliver Wright Livingston by his parent Daisy Wright, Elizabeth Wright, Bernie Wrightby his parent Elizabeth Wright, Vivian Dee, Sonia Garcia, Joan Heitner, PatriciaLoftman, Lillian Pryor, Eileen Salzig, Valeria Spann and Walter Reinhardt,respondents.

Akerman LLP, New York (Richard G. Leland of counsel), for the Real Estate Boardof New [*2]York, Inc., amicus curiae.

Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Susan E. Amron of counsel),for City of New York, amicus curiae.

Sive, Paget & Reisel, P.C., New York (Michael Bogin of counsel), forCaringKind, JCC Manhattan, Services and Advocacy for GLBT Elders, and West SideFederation for Senior and Supportive Housing, amici curiae.

Order and judgment (one paper), Supreme Court, New York County (Joan B. Lobis,J.), entered on or about December 18, 2015, which granted the petitions seeking to annula Findings Statement issued by respondent New York State Department of Health(DOH), dated December 10, 2014, approving respondent Jewish Home Lifecare,Manhattan's (JHL) application to construct a 20-story nursing home facility inManhattan, and remitted the matter to DOH for preparation of an amended FinalEnvironmental Impact Statement (FEIS) to reconsider the findings on the issues of noiseand hazardous materials, reversed, on the law, without costs, the petitions denied, theFindings Statement reinstated, and the proceedings brought pursuant to CPLR article 78dismissed.

It is axiomatic that judicial review of an agency determination under the StateEnvironmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) is limited to whether the agencyprocedures were lawful and "whether the agency identified the relevant areas ofenvironmental concern, took a 'hard look' at them, and made a 'reasoned elaboration' ofthe basis for its determination" (Matter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev.Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986], quoting Aldrich v Pattison, 107 AD2d 258,265 [2d Dept 1985]; Matter ofChinese Staff & Workers' Assn. v Burden, 19 NY3d 922, 924 [2012]).Moreover, "[i]t is not the province of the courts to second-guess thoughtful agencydecisionmaking and, accordingly, an agency decision should be annulled only if it isarbitrary, capricious or unsupported by the evidence" (Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. vPlanning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d 219, 232 [2007]). Since it is theresponsibility of the agency to analyze reports and other documents submitted to it,"it isnot for a reviewing court to duplicate these efforts. As we have repeatedly stated, '[w]hilejudicial review must be meaningful, the courts may not substitute their judgment for thatof the agency for it is not their role to "weigh the desirability of any action or [to] chooseamong alternatives" ' " (id., quoting Akpan v Koch, 75NY2d 561, 570 [1990], quoting Jackson, 67 NY2d at 416). Thus, the court'sprovince is to "assure that the agency itself has satisfied SEQRA, procedurally andsubstantively" (Matter of Jackson, 67 NY2d at 416; Matter of East End Prop. Co. #1,LLC v Kessel, 46 AD3d 817, 820 [2d Dept 2007], lv denied 10 NY3d926 [2008]). In this regard, "[d]issatisfaction with an agency's proposed mitigationmeasures is not redressable by the courts so long as those measures have a rational basisin the record" (Matter of Jackson, 67 NY2d at 421).

"An agency's compliance with its substantive SEQRA obligations is governed by arule of reason and the extent to which particular environmental factors are to beconsidered varies in accordance with the circumstances and nature of particularproposals" (Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d at 570, citing Jackson, 67 NY2d at417; Matter of Gernatt Asphalt Prods. v Town of Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 688[1996]; Matter of Town of Dryden v Tompkins County Bd. of Representatives,78 NY2d 331, 333-334 [1991]). Where "there has been such a reasonable considerationof alternatives, the judicial inquiry is at an end" (id. at 334). "Thus the generalsubstantive policy of the act is a flexible one. It leaves room for a reasonable exercise ofdiscretion and does not require particular substantive results in particular problematicinstances" (Coalition Against [*3]Lincoln W. v Cityof New York, 94 AD2d 483, 492 [1st Dept 1983], affd 60 NY2d 805[1983]).

Furthermore, not every conceivable environmental impact, mitigating measure oralternative must be addressed. "What must be required is that information be consideredwhich would permit a reasoned conclusion" (id.; see also Matter of Residents forReasonable Dev. v City of New York, 128 AD3d 609, 610-611 [1st Dept 2015];Matter of C/S 12th Ave. LLC vCity of New York, 32 AD3d 1, 7 [1st Dept 2006]). "So long as the officials andagencies have taken [a] 'hard look' at environmental consequences . . . thecourt does not seek to impose unreasonable extremes or to interject itself within the areaof discretion of the executive as to the choice of the action to be taken" (NaturalResources Defense Council, Inc. v Morton, 458 F2d 827, 838 [DC Cir 1972][footnote omitted]).

In arriving at its conclusions, "[a]n agency may rely on consultants to conduct theanalyses that support their environmental review of proposed projects. The choicebetween conflicting expert testimony rests in the discretion of the administrative agency"(Matter of Brooklyn BridgePark Legal Defense Fund, Inc. v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 50 AD3d1029, 1031 [2d Dept 2008], lv denied 10 NY3d 714 [2008] [citationsomitted]; Matter of DeFeo vZoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Bedford, 137 AD3d 1123, 1127 [2d Dept2016]; Matter of Thorne vVillage of Millbrook Planning Bd., 83 AD3d 723, 725-726 [2d Dept 2011],lv denied 17 NY3d 711 [2011]).

Here, the motion court determined that DOH took a "hard look" at the issues raisedby petitioners with the exception of two areas of concern: noise mitigation and off-sitemigration of lead-bearing dust.

We find that DOH's determination was not arbitrary and capricious or unsupportedby the evidence (see Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d at 570). DOH took the requisite"hard look" at the project's anticipated adverse environmental impacts, including noiseand hazardous material impacts, and provided a " 'reasoned elaboration' "of its basis for approving the project, including the remedial measures to be employed tomitigate adverse impacts (Matter of Riverkeeper, 9 NY3d at 231-232, quotingMatter of Jackson, 67 NY2d at 417).

With respect to petitioners' objection that the window air conditioning units proposedas an element of noise-mitigating measures at P.S. 163 would not supply adequate freshair, it was not unreasonable for DOH to rely on a type of ventilation already in wide useat the school. DOH also rationally rejected, as unreasonably expensive andtime-consuming, petitioners' request that central air conditioning be installed at theschool. The rough cost estimate for such installation obtained by DOH, though far fromthe result of a detailed study on its feasibility, complied with 6 NYCRR 617.9 (b) (5) (v),which requires consideration of "the range of reasonable alternatives to the action thatare feasible, considering the objectives and capabilities of the project sponsor."

Significantly, the record is clear that the air conditioning units were not the onlynoise mitigation measure required by DOH. It also mandated, among other things, theinstallation of new acoustical windows on the side of the school facing the projectsite.[FN*] As notedabove, the mere fact that DOH did not accept or specifically address in the FEIS all theconclusions and recommendations of petitioners' experts with respect to the issue is nottantamount to a failure to take a "hard look" at this issue (Matter of Brooklyn BridgePark Legal Defense Fund, 50 AD3d at 1030-1031; Coalition Against LincolnW., 94 AD2d at 492).

Moreover, DOH is entitled to rely on the accepted methodology set forth in the City[*4]Environmental Quality Review Technical Manual(CEQRTM) with respect to the allowable temporal duration of elevated noise fromconstruction in making its determination (see Matter of Finn v City of New York, 141 AD3d 436 [1stDept 2016], lv denied 28 NY3d 906 [2016]; see also Matter of ChineseStaff, 88 AD3d at 429). DOH determined that noise levels would exceed theCEQRTM impact criteria in classrooms along the school's eastern facade facing theconstruction site for a total of 14 months. However, the manual also provides that suchincreased noise levels inside the school would not constitute a significant adverse impactif those levels lasted less than two years. DOH also found that the combination ofreplacement acoustical windows and air conditioning units is estimated to reduce noiselevels by 25-30 dBA during the same period of time.

"SEQRA requires an agency 'to list ways in which any adverse effects. . . might be minimized' (ECL 8-0109 [2]), but it does not require an agencyto impose every conceivable mitigation measure, or any particular one. Rather, inaccordance with its balancing philosophy, SEQRA requires the imposition of mitigationmeasures only 'to the maximum extent practicable' 'consistent with social, economic andother essential considerations' (ECL 8-0109 [8])" (Matter of Jackson, 67 NY2d at421-422).

Thus, although petitioners, the motion court and the dissent do not agree with DOH'sfindings, the record supports the conclusion that DOH took the requisite "hard look" atthis issue.

The record also reflects that DOH took the requisite "hard look" at the issue ofcontainment of hazardous dust from the construction site. While it is true that DOHconceded that there is a controversy over whether any level of exposure to lead dust isacceptable, it can base its determination as to mitigating measures on currently acceptedfederal and state mitigating measures. In that respect, DOH reviewed soil sampling fromthe proposed construction site. It found that 38 samples contained lead levels of 290 partsper million (PPM), and three contained levels of over 1,000 PPM. The threshold forchild play areas, as per the National Ambient Air Quality Standards, is 400 PPM. As aresult, DOH mandated certain remedial measures, including a two-foot cap of clean soilover any ground left exposed after construction and dust control measures includingwatering of the soil during demolition, excavation, and soil transport to minimizeairborne dust.

Although some of the petitioners contend that DOH failed to perform adequate soilsampling, even the motion court determined that DOH conducted a "comprehensive anddetailed investigation."

As with the noise mitigation issue, petitioners argue that the reports of their expertsas to proposed mitigation measures were not adequately addressed or considered, andthat DOH should have set forth measures to prevent, not merely mitigate, migration oflead dust from the project site. Of course, mitigation of adverse environmental impacts isthe mandate of SEQRA (ECL 8-0109 [2] [f]). Petitioners' argument again ignores wellsettled precedent, which bears repeating, that the mere fact that an agency accepts its ownconsultants' recommendations over those of petitioners while not specifically addressingall the conclusions and recommendations of petitioners' consultants does not mean thatthe agency failed to take a "hard look" at a particular issue (Matter of BrooklynBridge Park Legal Defense Fund, 50 AD3d at 1031; Coalition Against LincolnW., 94 AD2d at 492).

DOH reasonably relied on federal standards, including National Ambient Air QualityStandards, in determining what measures to employ to mitigate the possibility of off-sitemigration of lead-bearing dust (see Matter of Spitzer v Farrell, 100 NY2d 186,191 [2003]). Its mitigation measures reflect its considered judgment and meets therequired "hard look" under SEQRA.

In short, we find that the motion court erroneously "substituted its analysis for the[*5]expertise of the lead agency" simply because theagency rejected what the court considered to be better measures in mitigation (Matterof South Bronx Clean Air Coalition v New York State Dept. of Transp., 218 AD2d520, 522 [1st Dept 1995], lv denied 87 NY2d 803 [1995], citing CoalitionAgainst Lincoln W., 94 AD2d 483).

We have considered petitioners' remaining arguments, including its contention thatJHL has no right to appeal, and find them unavailing. Concur—Friedman, J.P.,Sweeny and Webber, JJ.

Gesmer, J., dissents in a memorandum as follows: I respectfully dissent, and wouldaffirm the motion court's order and judgment, subject to a small proceduralmodification.

The Department of Health (DOH) approved a proposal by respondent Jewish HomeLifecare, Manhattan (JHL) to construct a nursing home in Manhattan (the project).Petitioners challenged the approval as arbitrary and capricious and inconsistent withDOH's obligations under the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) to takean in-depth look at the environmental consequences of the project. The motion courtrejected petitioners' procedural challenge but found that DOH had failed to comply withthe substantive requirements of SEQRA with regard to two issues. Specifically, it foundthat DOH had failed to take the required "hard look" at the environmental effects of, andappropriate mitigation measures for, the noise and the lead-containing airborne dustparticles that would be generated during the construction of the project, and failed toprovide a reasoned explanation for its findings. Accordingly, the motion court grantedthe petitions to the extent of vacating DOH's approval of JHL's application and remittingthe matter to DOH for the preparation of an amended Final Environmental ImpactStatement (FEIS) to reconsider its findings on the issues of noise and hazardousmaterials.

In reaching this result, the motion court applied the appropriate deferential standardof review. Accordingly, I would affirm the motion court's findings. However, SEQRAdoes not use the term "amended FEIS," but rather requires an agency to issue aSupplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) where the initial FEIS isinadequate (6 NYCRR 617.9 [a] [7]). Accordingly, I would modify the order andjudgment only to the extent of directing DOH to issue a SEIS "limited to the specificsignificant adverse environmental impacts not addressed or inadequately addressed" inthe FEIS (6 NYCRR 617.9 [a] [7]).

In reaching this result, I would find that the motion court properly applied thestatutory standard of review. "The primary purpose of SEQRA is 'to inject environmentalconsiderations directly into governmental decision making' " (Akpan vKoch, 75 NY2d 561, 569 [1990], quoting Matter of Coca-Cola Bottling Co. ofN.Y. v Board of Estimate of City of N.Y., 72 NY2d 674, 679 [1988]). "By requiringstrict adherence to review procedures, the act forces agencies to 'strike a balance betweensocial and economic goals and concerns about the environment' " (Matter ofSpitzer v Farrell, 100 NY2d 186, 190 [2003], quoting Matter of Jackson v NewYork State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 414 [1986]). In reviewing anenvironmental impact statement under SEQRA, we may "first, review the agencyprocedures to determine whether they were lawful. Second, we may review the record todetermine whether the agency identified the relevant areas of environmental concern,took a 'hard look' at them, and made a 'reasoned elaboration' of the basis for itsdetermination. Court review, while supervisory only, insures that the agencies will honortheir mandate regarding environmental protection by complying strictly with prescribedprocedures and giving reasoned consideration to all pertinent issues revealed in theprocess" (Matter of Jackson, 67 NY2d at 417 [citations omitted]). I would findthat, since the agency did not take the required "hard look" and did not make the required"reasoned elaboration," its action was arbitrary and capricious in these two areas and thattherefore the matter must be remanded to the agency for further proceedings. In addition,it is my view that the reversal of the motion court [*6]isinconsistent with our obligation to insure that agencies honor their mandate to protect theenvironment.

Noise

The project is directly adjacent to elementary school P.S. 163. P.S. 163 has classesfrom prekindergarten through fifth grade, and serves approximately 600 studentsbetween the ages of 3 and 11, including students with special needs. At least 14% of thestudents have a learning disability. At every opportunity for public comment on theproject, petitioners Friends of P.S. 163 (Friends) and individual parents raised questionsabout the noise that would be generated by the Project, and the effect on thechildren.

DOH issued a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) on March 21, 2014 thatconcluded that the project "would not result in any significant adverse noiseimpacts."

Friends retained a group of pediatric environmental health experts at the Mount SinaiChildren's Environmental Health Center to comment on the DEIS. They submitted acomment stating that studies have shown that "chronic exposure to increased backgroundnoise results in impaired reading comprehension" for average schoolchildren, andrecommending that ambient noise levels for children with normal speech processing beno more than between 28.5 and 40 dBA, depending on the age group, and, for youngchildren with delayed speech processing, no more than 21.5 dBA. They concluded that"the predicted noise levels during the noisiest 14 months of construction . . .are predicted to be loud enough to potentially interfere with the wellness and the abilityto learn of the school children at P.S. 163," and that "the mitigation measures as outlinedin the EIS may not be sufficient to fully prevent negative impacts on P.S. 163students."

Friends also retained an acoustical engineer to review the DEIS and conductacoustical testing. In his comments submitted on May 19, 2014, the engineer stated that"additional construction noise mitigation measures must include . . .installation of a central air conditioning HVAC system" on the eastern facade of P.S.163. One month later, after learning that DOH was considering requiring the installationof new windows on the east side of P.S. 163, he submitted additional comments, whichexplained that the installation of new windows without central air conditioning would beinsufficient to reduce construction noise to acceptable levels because the unregulatedheating system and inadequate window air conditioners at P.S. 163 result in windowsbeing left open "virtually every day of the academic year." Friends and individual parentssubmitted comparable comments.

In the FEIS, DOH provided that JHL would install new acoustical windows alongthe eastern facade of P.S. 163 and provide new window air conditioning units in each ofthe eastern facade classroom windows without a functioning unit.[FN1] These were among theconsiderations that led to DOH's approval of the project.

However, DOH concluded that, even with these measures in place, for 9 consecutiveand 14 total months of excavation and foundation work, interior noise levels at P.S. 163would exceed 50 dBA. That is above the level of 45 dBA, which, according to the CityEnvironmental Quality Review (CEQR) Technical Manual,[FN2] is the level above which indoor noiseachieves a nuisance level, especially for sensitive populations such aschildren.

[*7] With regard to noise, the motioncourt found that DOH did not adequately address the adverse effects of the elevatednoise levels during construction on the learning abilities and school performance of thechildren at P.S. 163. In reaching this conclusion, the motion court took particular note offour factors: (1) the close proximity of the school to the construction site; (2) DOH'sfinding that CEQR Technical Manual noise level standards would be exceeded during 9consecutive and 14 total months of excavation and foundation work, even with DOH'sproposed mitigation measures, including installation of window air conditioners andacoustical windows in some classrooms; (3) DOH's exclusive reliance on the CEQRguidelines, even though those guidelines do not address the special circumstances ofproximity of a noisy construction site to young children; and (4) DOH's failure to take asufficiently hard look at additional noise mitigation measures, including the installationof a central air conditioning system at P.S. 163.

This conclusion by the motion court is based on its review of the record, pursuant tothe standard of review set forth above, and therefore, I would affirm it. The majority, inreversing the motion court, does not fully address the first three of the factors that themotion court considered with respect to noise. While the majority does address the lastissue, I disagree with its analysis for the reasons set forth below.

First, the majority states that "it was not unreasonable for DOH to rely on a type ofventilation [window air conditioners] already in wide use at the school." However, thesuitability of window air conditioners for ventilation under normal circumstances isentirely irrelevant as to whether they are an appropriate method of noise mitigation.Moreover, DOH failed to respond to the timely comment by petitioner's acousticalengineer that the window air conditioners at P.S. 163 should be removed and replacedwith a central HVAC system. As a result, it is not clear why it was reasonable for DOHto rely on the existing window air conditioners to mitigate noise.

Finally, the majority claims that it was rational for DOH to reject central airconditioning as "expensive and time-consuming." However, DOH did not even addressin the FEIS, much less reject, the proposal by Friends' acoustical engineer regardingcentral air conditioning; rather, it addressed it for the first time in the Findings, issuedone month later. The Findings stated that central air conditioning would be "verydifficult, would take a great amount of time and would be extremely costly" and wastherefore "infeasible." Although the Findings claimed to base this conclusion onconsultation with the New York School Construction Authority (NYSCA), DOH has notproduced any evidence that it received any written communications from NYSCA beforeissuance of the FEIS concerning central air conditioning. Indeed, the writtencommunication from NYSCA that DOH has identified as the basis for its conclusion isemail correspondence from NYSCA to petitioners' counsel containing a "very roughestimate" of the cost of installing central air conditioning at P.S. 163 and a statement thatthe "consensus is that this will be very difficult, will take a great amount of time and isextremely costly." Moreover, the record shows that DOH first saw that email one weekafter issuance of the FEIS.[FN3] Certainly, the motion court could havereasonably concluded that this was not the "hard look" or "reasoned elaboration" calledfor by SEQRA.

Accordingly, I would affirm the motion court's finding that DOH failed to take asufficiently hard look at, and failed to make a reasoned elaboration of the basis for itsdetermination as to, the issue of noise as it may affect the students at P.S. 163, andappropriate noise mitigation measures.

Lead

At every opportunity for public comment on the project, Friends, individual parents,and community members raised questions about airborne toxic substances that would begenerated by the project, and the effect on the children.

[*8] On the issue of airborne toxic substances, the DEISstated that the project would disturb soil containing hazardous materials, but, with theimplementation of a Remedial Action Plan (RAP) and Construction Health and SafetyPlan (CHASP) approved by DOH, "significant adverse impacts related to hazardousmaterials would not be expected."

During the comment period, petitioners submitted comments highlighting the highlevels of lead and the adverse impact it would have on the children nearby. TheEnvironmental Technology Group, an environmental and engineering consulting groupretained by Friends, submitted comments stating that "an enclosed area tent should beutilized during excavation to prevent any particles and odors from emanating from thesite."

With regard to this issue, the FEIS stated that (1) lead is present in the soil testedfrom the project site; (2) construction excavation "can create airborne dust. . . that must be appropriately contained to prevent or minimize inhalationor ingestion" of lead; (3) lead exposure places young children at particular risk oflong-lasting damage, including learning and behavioral difficulties; (4) "there iscontroversy as to whether there is any level of lead exposure that can be considered'safe' "; and (5) there is no reliable technology for real-time measurement ofairborne lead. DOH further stated that the RAP and CHASP it had approved wouldminimize the impact of the soil disturbance. The RAP and CHASP require wetting ofexposed soils, covering trucks with tarpaulins, and air monitoring for small particles, andthat construction workers on the project be provided with Tyvek suits, full face monitorsand respirators. In the sections of the FEIS concerning hazardous substances andconstruction, DOH does not discuss the potential effects of any of the substances on thechildren attending P.S. 163.

Despite the acknowledged uncertainties about safe lead levels and the impossibilityof accurately measuring airborne lead levels, DOH concluded that there is no significantthreat to public health, and that the CHASP and RAP will be adequate to ensure that leadlevels will not exceed the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) of 150parts per million (ppm). In the FEIS, DOH only explicitly responded to the commentsmade by petitioners' experts concerning lead by stating that use of a tent was "notwarranted" and that the RAP and CHASP would be sufficient to address any problemsarising from soil disturbance.

The petitions submitted by the Wright petitioners were accompanied by affidavits bythree experts who had reviewed the FEIS and explained that it did not adequately addressthe environmental effects of toxins and the possible methods to mitigate them. PaulBartlett, an expert on the emission of toxics, stated that the FEIS estimates of exposurefrom toxics is incorrect; that the proposed air monitoring is inadequate; and therefore,that "[t]oxics are present at the site at levels of sufficient concern that a sealed tentprotocol with negative air pressure and continuous air monitoring is needed to containthe toxics and prevent exposure." Dr. David Carpenter stated that lead dust has a toxicand irreversible effect on children; that children should be protected from exposure tolead by preventing migration of contaminants off-site; that soil wetting and airmonitoring are not sufficient to accomplish this; and that migration of the dust must beensured by means of a full containment system. An affidavit containing a similar opinionwas submitted by toxicologist Stephen Lester.

After applying the appropriate standard of review to the facts before it, the motioncourt found that, in light of DOH's own acknowledgment of the controversy as towhether there is any safe level of lead exposure, and the close proximity of theconstruction site to the school, DOH had failed to take "a hard enough look at all relevantmitigation measures or made a reasoned elaboration for its failure to considercontainment measures," including tenting.[FN4]

The majority dismisses this finding, and merely concludes that DOH "reasonablyrelied on federal standards . . . in determining what measures to employ tomitigate the possibility of off-[*9]site migration oflead-bearing dust." However, that statement is not supported by the record, since thechapter of the FEIS that addresses mitigation does not even mention the effects ofmigration of lead-bearing dust. Moreover, the majority fails to acknowledge that DOHfailed to comply with the CEQR Technical Manual, which requires, for example, that apublic health analysis consider the potential for exposure to contamination by vulnerablepopulations, including children. A striking example of its failure to do so is that the RAPrequires that, under the circumstances, construction workers wear protective clothing butthere is no comparable protection for the children attending school next to theconstruction site.

Accordingly, I would vote to affirm the motion court's findings, and to modify itsorder and judgment only to the extent of requiring that DOH adopt a SEIS, rather than an"amended FEIS." [Prior Case History: 51 Misc 3d 1225(A), 2015 NY Slip Op51997(U).]

Footnotes


Footnote *:Respondent was alsorequired by DOH to increase the noise barrier facing the school to 16 feet, double thestandard height. It further required respondent to place noisy machinery away from theschool, to use less noisy electrical equipment, to ensure that the noisiest work does nottake place during the yearly testing period and to make available a construction managerto liaise with P.S. 163 to address any issues as they arise during the construction project.

Footnote 1:In addition, it is not clearwhether JHL's agreement to install window air conditioning units in "classrooms" wouldextend to the school's auditorium, which faces the construction site, has no airconditioning, and is used for classes throughout the school day.

Footnote 2:According to the FEIS,DOH generally used the 2012 CEQR Technical Manual, 2012 edition, revised June 5,2013 "as a guide with respect to environmental analysis methodologies and impactcriteria for evaluating the effects of the Proposed Project, unless . . .determined otherwise."

Footnote 3:It is therefore difficult tounderstand how JHL could claim in its reply brief that DOH "relied heavily" on theopinion and expertise of NYSCA as to central air conditioning when there is no evidencethat it received NYSCA's "very rough cost estimate" until after DOH issued the FEIS.

Footnote 4:Thus, respondent JHL iswrong in stating in its brief that the motion court "accept[ed] the demand of petitionersthat a tent be included as a mitigation measure." Rather, the motion court said that DOHfailed to take a "hard look" at all "relevant mitigation measures," including containment.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.