| Matter of Rochester Eastside Residents for Appropriate Dev., Inc. v Cityof Rochester |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 03665 [150 AD3d 1678] |
| May 5, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Rochester Eastside Residents for AppropriateDevelopment, Inc., et al., Appellants, v City of Rochester et al.,Respondents. |
Knauf Shaw LLP, Rochester (Alan J. Knauf of counsel), for petitioners-appellants.
Brian F. Curran, Corporation Counsel, Rochester (Maureen K. Gilroy of counsel), forrespondents-respondents City of Rochester, City of Rochester Zoning Board of Appeals,Rochester City Planning Commission and City of Rochester Director of Planning andZoning.
Woods Oviatt Gilman LLP, Rochester (Reuben Ortenberg of counsel), forrespondents-respondents Aldi, Inc., Crlyn Acquisitions, LLC and Cbl, LLC.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Monroe County (Thomas A. Stander, J.),entered May 24, 2016 in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78. The judgment dismissed theamended petition.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously reversed on the lawwithout costs and the amended petition is granted.
Memorandum: Petitioners commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking, inter alia, toannul the negative declaration issued by respondent City of Rochester Director of Planning andZoning under the State Environmental Quality Review Act ([SEQRA] ECL art 8) with respect tothe proposed construction of an ALDI supermarket. We agree with petitioners that SupremeCourt should have granted the amended petition.
As a threshold matter, we agree with petitioners that the court erred in determining that theylack standing to bring this proceeding. The record establishes that petitioner Igatopsfy, LLC ownsproperty that is less than 300 feet from the property line of the proposed construction project, andthus Igatopsfy is "arguably within the zone of interest to be protected by [SEQRA]. . . and [has] standing to seek judicial review without pleading and proving specialdamage, because adverse effect or aggrievement can be inferred from the proximity" (Matter of Ontario Hgts. Homeowners Assn.v Town of Oswego Planning Bd., 77 AD3d 1465, 1466 [2010] [internal quotation marksomitted]; see Matter of Shapiro v Townof Ramapo, 98 AD3d 675, 677 [2012], lv dismissed 20 NY3d 994 [2013]). Therecord further establishes that petitioner Rochester Eastside Residents for AppropriateDevelopment, Inc. (RERAD) has "associational or organizational standing" (Society ofPlastics Indus. v County of Suffolk, 77 NY2d 761, 775 [1991]). Two members of RERADown property that is less than 500 feet from the property line of the proposed constructionproject, and thus they have standing to sue (see Shapiro, 98 AD3d at 677; OntarioHgts. Homeowners Assn., 77 AD3d at 1466; see generally Society of Plastics Indus.,77 NY2d at 775), and RERAD established the other two requirements for associational ororganizational standing set forth in Society of Plastics Indus. (see generally id. at775).
We further agree with petitioners that the negative declaration did not contain a" 'reasoned elaboration' of the basis for [the] determination" (Matter of Jackson vNew York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986]). "It is well settled thatSEQRA's procedural mechanisms mandate strict compliance, and anything less will result inannulment of the lead agency's determination of significance" (Matter of Dawley v Whitetail 414,LLC, 130 AD3d 1570, 1571 [2015]; see Matter of King v Saratoga County Bd. ofSupervisors, 89 NY2d 341, 347 [1996]). The lead agency must "set forth its determination ofsignificance in a written form containing a reasoned elaboration and providing reference to anysupporting documentation" (6 NYCRR 617.7 [b] [4]; see generally Jackson, 67 NY2d at417). The purpose of that regulation "is to focus and facilitate judicial review and. . . to provide affected landowners and residents with a clear, written explanation ofthe lead agency's reasoning at the time the negative declaration is made" (Dawley, 130AD3d at 1571). Here, despite the undisputed presence of preexisting soil contamination on theproject site, the negative declaration set forth no findings whatsoever with respect to thatcontamination. The document containing the purported reasoning for the lead agency'sdetermination of significance, which was prepared subsequent to the issuance of the negativedeclaration, does not fulfill the statutory mandate (see id.; cf. Matter of Hartford/North BaileyHomeowners Assn. v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Amherst, 63 AD3d 1721, 1723[2009], lv denied in part and dismissed in part 13 NY3d 901 [2009]). Contrary torespondents' contention, the developer's promise to remediate the contamination beforeproceeding with construction did not absolve the lead agency from its obligations under SEQRA(see generally Matter of Penfield Panorama Area Community v Town of Penfield PlanningBd., 253 AD2d 342, 349-350 [1999]).
We therefore reverse the judgment and grant the amended petition, thereby annulling thenegative declaration and vacating the variances granted by respondent City of Rochester ZoningBoard of Appeals and the special use permit granted by respondent Rochester City PlanningCommission. In light of our determination, we do not reach petitioners' remaining contentions.Present—Whalen, P.J., Carni, NeMoyer, Curran and Troutman, JJ.