Matter of Wooster v Queen City Landing, LLC
2017 NY Slip Op 03671 [150 AD3d 1689]
May 5, 2017
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 28, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Margaret Wooster et al.,Appellants-Respondents,
v
Queen City Landing, LLC, Respondent-Appellant, et al.,Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Buffalo Niagara Riverkeeper, Inc.,Appellant-Respondent, v City of Buffalo, Respondent, and Queen City Landing, LLC,Respondent-Appellant. (Proceeding No. 2.) (Appeal No. 1.)

Arthur J. Giacalone, Buffalo and Lippes & Lippes, forpetitioners-appellants-respondents.

Hopkins Sorgi & Romanowski PLLC, Buffalo (Marc A. Romanowski of counsel) andDuke Holzman Photiadis & Gresens LLP, for respondent-respondent-appellant.

Timothy A. Ball, Corporation Counsel, Buffalo (Jessica M. Lazarin of counsel), forrespondents-respondents.

Appeals and cross appeal from a judgment (denominated order and judgment) of theSupreme Court, Erie County (Donna M. Siwek, J.), entered October 11, 2016 in theseproceedings pursuant to CPLR article 78. The judgment denied the motions of respondents todismiss the petition and amended petition for lack of standing, and granted the motions ofrespondents to dismiss the petition in proceeding No. 2 and the amended petition in proceedingNo. 1, except insofar as it alleged that respondents violated the performance bond provisions ofGeneral City Law §§ 27-a (7) and 33 (8) (a).

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.

Memorandum: Petitioners Margaret Wooster, Clayton S. "Jay" Burney, Jr., Lynda K.Stephens, and James E. Carr (collectively, Wooster petitioners) and Buffalo NiagaraRiverkeeper, Inc. (Riverkeeper) commenced these CPLR article 78 proceedings seeking, amongother things, to annul the negative declaration issued by respondent City of Buffalo PlanningBoard (Planning Board) under the State Environmental Quality Review Act ([SEQRA] ECL art8) with respect to the proposed construction of Queen City Landing (project) in Buffalo's OuterHarbor area. Respondent Queen City Landing, LLC (QCL), the developer of the project, plans toconstruct a mixed-use facility that will include a 23-story tower containing nearly 200 residentialunits. In appeal No. 1, petitioners appeal and QCL cross-appeals from a judgment that deniedrespondents' motions to dismiss Riverkeeper's petition and the Wooster petitioners' amendedpetition for lack of standing, and granted respondents' motions to dismiss the petition andamended petition except insofar as the Wooster petitioners claimed that respondents violated theperformance bond provisions of General City Law §§ 27-a (7) and 33 (8) (a).In appeal No. 2, the Wooster petitioners appeal from a judgment that granted those parts ofrespondents' motions to dismiss the Wooster petitioners' performance bond claim. We affirm inboth appeals.

Addressing first the cross appeal in appeal No. 1, we reject QCL's contention that petitionersdo not have standing to challenge the SEQRA determination. The allegations in the affidavits ofpetitioners Wooster, Burney and Carr, read in the context of the amended petition (see Matter of Sierra Club v Village ofPainted Post, 26 NY3d 301, 311 n 4 [2015]), establish that they engage in "repeated, notrare or isolated use" of the Outer Harbor for recreation, study and enjoyment, thereby showingthat the threatened environmental and ecological harm to that area, which includes aquatic andterrestrial wildlife habitats and two nature preserves, "will affect them differently from 'the publicat large' " (Matter of Save thePine Bush, Inc. v Common Council of City of Albany, 13 NY3d 297, 305 [2009]; see Matter of Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy.,Inc. v Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commn., 113 AD3d 853, 856[2014]). Contrary to QCL's contention, the alleged injuries are " 'real and different fromthe injur[ies] most members of the public face' " (Sierra Club, 26 NY3d at 311,quoting Save the Pine Bush, Inc., 13 NY3d at 306). Furthermore, the threatenedenvironmental and ecological harm to the area caused by the development of the project fallswithin the zone of interests sought to be protected by SEQRA (see Society of Plastics Indus. vCounty of Suffolk, 77 NY2d 761, 773 [1991]; Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy., Inc., 113AD3d at 856). Inasmuch as at least one of the Wooster petitioners has standing, it is notnecessary to address QCL's challenges to any other individual petitioner (see Matter of Humane Socy. of U.S. vEmpire State Dev. Corp., 53 AD3d 1013, 1017 n 2 [2008], lv denied 12 NY3d701 [2009]; see also Saratoga County Chamber of Commerce v Pataki, 100 NY2d 801,813 [2003], cert denied 540 US 1017 [2003]). Contrary to QCL's further contention,Supreme Court properly concluded that Riverkeeper, through the affidavits of its members, metthe requirements to establish organizational standing (see generally Society of PlasticsIndus., 77 NY2d at 775; Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy., Inc., 113 AD3d at 856).

On the merits, however, we conclude that the court properly dismissed the petition andamended petition. Contrary to petitioners' contention in appeal No. 1, the Planning Board wasproperly designated as the lead agency (see generally 6 NYCRR 617.2 [u]; Matter ofCoca-Cola Bottling Co. of N.Y. v Board of Estimate of City of N.Y., 72 NY2d 674, 680[1988]). There is a conflict between that part of the Buffalo City Code providing that respondentCity of Buffalo Common Council (Common Council) had an "[a]utomatic designation of leadagency" for actions that, like this project, are undertaken within the Buffalo Coastal SpecialReview District (Buffalo City Code § 168-7 [A] [2] [d]), and that part of theBuffalo City Code automatically designating the Planning Board as lead agency for actionsundertaken for subdivision developments and site plan review (see § 168-7[A] [1] [a], [b]). Although arguably either the Common Council or the Planning Board couldhave been designated as the lead agency, the Planning Board had oversight of subdivisionapproval and site plan review, and was responsible for preparing a report of recommendations tothe Common Council on QCL's application for a "restricted use permit" describing"considerations involving air and water quality, coastal management, flood hazards andenvironmental impact of the proposed uses" (§ 511-67 [A] [4]; see§ 511-55 [C]). Under these circumstances, the Planning Board was properlydesignated lead agency (see Matter of Schodack Concerned Citizens v Town Bd. of Town ofSchodack, 148 AD2d 130, 134 [1989], lv denied 75 NY2d 701 [1989]; cf. Matter of Price v Common Council ofCity of Buffalo, 3 Misc 3d 625, 629-632 [2004]; see also ECL 8-0111 [6]).

Contrary to petitioners' further contention, the court properly concluded that the PlanningBoard did not abdicate its responsibilities as lead agency. Although members of the strategicplanning department from respondent City of Buffalo (City) filled out part of the fullenvironmental assessment form and prepared the negative declaration, the Planning Board wasentitled to rely on the information provided by such experts, and the record establishes that it"fully retained and exercised its role as the lead agency assessing the environmental impact of the[project]" (Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561, 575 [1990]; see Matter of Mombaccus Excavating, Inc. v Town of Rochester, N.Y.,89 AD3d 1209, 1211-1212 [2011], lv denied 18 NY3d 808 [2012]). We rejectpetitioners' contention that the Planning Board improperly deferred its review of sitecontamination to other agencies (cf. Matter of Penfield Panorama Area Community v Townof Penfield Planning Bd., 253 AD2d 342, 349-350 [1999]).

We also reject petitioners' contention that the Planning Board failed to comply with therequirements of SEQRA in issuing the negative declaration. The record establishes that thePlanning Board took the requisite hard look and provided a reasoned elaboration of the basis forits determination regarding the potential impacts of the project on aesthetic resources andcommunity character, particularly with respect to the height of the building (see Matter of Frigault v Town of RichfieldPlanning Bd., 107 AD3d 1347, 1350 [2013]; Matter of Schweichler v Village of Caledonia, 45 AD3d 1281, 1283[2007], lv denied 10 NY3d 703 [2008]); migratory birds, especially in light of theproject's conformance with accepted governmental guidelines to mitigate bird impacts (cf. Matter of Wellsville Citizens forResponsible Dev., Inc. v Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 140 AD3d 1767, 1769 [2016]; see generally Matter of Granger Group vTown of Taghkanic, 77 AD3d 1137, 1142-1143 [2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 781[2011]; Matter of East End Prop. Co. #1,LLC v Kessel, 46 AD3d 817, 822 [2007], lv denied 10 NY3d 926 [2008]); andtraffic (see Wellsville Citizens for Responsible Dev., Inc., 140 AD3d at 1768-1769; Matter of Schaller v Town of New PaltzZoning Bd. of Appeals, 108 AD3d 821, 823 [2013]). The Planning Board'sconsideration of the contaminant remediation and stormwater management components of theproject, which would minimize pollutants running off into the lake, supports its determinationthat "[n]o other potentially significant impacts to plants or animals were identified," which wouldinclude impacts on aquatic wildlife. Furthermore, to the extent that the project's potential impactson aquatic wildlife were not specifically discussed in the negative declaration, it is wellestablished that " 'the lead agency need not consider every conceivable [environmental]impact' " (Matter of Ellsworth vTown of Malta, 16 AD3d 948, 950 [2005]; see Save the Pine Bush, Inc., 13NY3d at 307; Matter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417[1986]). The record thus establishes that the Planning Board complied with the requirements ofSEQRA in issuing the negative declaration and, contrary to petitioners' further contention, weconclude that the "designation as a type I action does not, per se, necessitate the filing of anenvironmental impact statement . . . , nor was one required here" (Matter ofMombaccus Excavating, Inc., 89 AD3d at 1211).

Petitioners also contend that the rezoning of the project site from industrial to commercialuse was arbitrary and capricious because QCL unreasonably delayed for eight years beforecomplying with the June 2008 conditional rezoning resolution that provided that the rezoningwould not be effective until QCL filed a certified copy of the resolution with the Erie CountyClerk's Office. We reject that contention. Here, the resolution did not specify a time forcompliance, and QCL has not sought nor received an open-ended exemption from the condition(cf. Matter of Gjerlow v Graap, 43AD3d 1165, 1168 [2007]). Rather, in conjunction with its present plan for the project, QCLcomplied with the condition by filing a certified copy of the resolution with the Erie CountyClerk in April 2016. Petitioners' contention provides no basis upon which to conclude that therezoning was affected by an error of law, was arbitrary and capricious, or an abuse of discretion(see generally CPLR 7803 [3]).

We further conclude that, contrary to petitioners' contention, the Common Council's issuanceof the restricted use permit to QCL, which is entitled to great deference, has a rational basis, isnot arbitrary and capricious, and is supported by substantial evidence (see Buffalo CityCode § 511-55; see also §§ 511-41 [A]; 511-67 [A], [C];see generally Matter of North ShoreF.C.P., Inc. v Mammina, 22 AD3d 759, 759-760 [2005]). Petitioners also contend thatthe restricted use permit for a 23-story building violated the City's "Green Code," i.e., the UnifiedDevelopment Ordinance (UDO), which was enacted during the pendency of this appeal, andprovides that the project is situated in a zone that does not permit towers and has a maximumbuilding height of six stories. We reject that contention. The ordinance provides that where, ashere, a previously granted approval was lawfully issued prior to the effective date of the UDO,the action authorized thereby may be undertaken.

Finally, contrary to the contention of the Wooster petitioners in appeal No. 2, we concludethat the court properly dismissed their claim that respondents violated the performance bondprovisions of General City Law §§ 27-a (7) and 33 (8) (a).Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, Centra, Peradotto and Scudder, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.