Matter of Truscott v City of Albany Bd. of Zoning Appeals
2017 NY Slip Op 05785 [152 AD3d 1038]
As corrected through Wednesday, August 30, 2017


[*1]
1 In the Matter of Timothy C. Truscott et al., Appellants, v Cityof Albany Board of Zoning Appeals et al., Respondents.

Oliver Law Office, Albany (Lewis B. Oliver Jr. of counsel), for appellants.

William G. Kelly Jr., Interim Corporation Counsel, Albany (Valerie A. Lubanko of counsel),for respondents.

Clark, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Hartman, J.), entered March 3, 2016in Albany County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLRarticle 78, to review a determination of respondent City of Albany Board of Zoning Appealsdenying petitioners' request for, among other things, an area variance.

Petitioners own real property in the City of Albany that includes a residence and a backyardstorage shed. This shed deteriorated over time, and, in 2013, petitioner Timothy C. Truscottobtained a building permit to repair two of the shed's four walls. Due to an allegedmiscommunication with his contractor, however, all four walls were torn down, and the structurewas replaced in its entirety. As a result, respondent Department of Buildings and RegulatoryCompliance of the City of Albany issued a stop work order, and Truscott's subsequentapplication for a new building permit was denied because the rebuilt shed failed to comply withthe applicable setback requirements. Truscott unsuccessfully sought an area variance fromrespondent City of Albany Board of Zoning Appeals and then commenced this CPLR article 78proceeding seeking review of the determination of the Board of Zoning Appeals. Supreme Courtdenied the petition, and petitioners now appeal.

After the appeal was perfected, the City adopted a new zoning ordinance that eliminated[*2]the applicable setback requirements for petitioners'shed.[FN*] At both oralargument and in a postargument submission, respondents contend that the enactment of the newzoning ordinance has rendered this appeal moot. Respondents are no longer seeking thedemolishment or removal of petitioners' shed. They concede that, under the new ordinance,petitioners' shed is now a conforming structure and that an area variance is no longer required(see Code of City of Albany § 375-4 [A] [2] [a] [iv] [B]).

"[T]he power of a court to declare the law only arises out of, and is limited to, determiningthe rights of persons which are actually controverted in a particular case pending before thetribunal" (Matter of Hearst Corp. v Clyne, 50 NY2d 707, 713 [1980]; accord Matter of Kagan v New York StateDept. of Corr. & Community Supervision, 117 AD3d 1215, 1216 [2014]). "Ingeneral[,] an appeal will be considered moot unless the rights of the parties will be directlyaffected by the determination of the appeal and the interest of the parties is an immediateconsequence of the judgment" (Matter of Hearst Corp. v Clyne, 50 NY2d at 714; see Matter of Ballard v New York SafetyTrack LLC, 126 AD3d 1073, 1075 [2015]; Matter of Lilly Pad, LLC v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Vil. of E.Hampton, 120 AD3d 686, 687 [2014]). If, as here, "a change in circumstances preventsa court from rendering a decision that would effectively determine an actual controversy, [then]the claim must be dismissed" (Matter of Ballard v New York Safety Track LLC, 126AD3d at 1075 [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Hearst Corp. vClyne, 50 NY2d at 713-714; Matterof Czajka v Dellehunt, 125 AD3d 1177, 1180 [2015]). Inasmuch as petitioners' rightsare no longer "actually controverted" and a determination of their appeal would not affect therights of the parties, the appeal must be dismissed as moot (Matter of Hearst Corp. vClyne, 50 NY2d at 713; see Cornell Univ. v Bagnardi, 68 NY2d 583, 592 [1986];Matter of Spaziani v City of Oneonta, 302 AD2d 846, 847 [2003]; Matter of Freihoferv Lake George Town Bd., 147 AD2d 865, 867-868 [1989]). Petitioners' contention that a livecontroversy remains because a related code enforcement proceeding still remains pending againstthem is unavailing. Simply put, that separate and distinct proceeding is not before us on thisappeal and does not affect our mootness finding.

McCarthy, J.P., Garry, Egan Jr. and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal is dismissed,as moot, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Although the newly adoptedzoning ordinance is not included in the record on appeal, we take judicial notice of it (seeCPLR 4511 [a]; St. David's AnglicanCatholic Church, Inc. v Town of Halfmoon, 11 AD3d 874, 876 [2004]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.