AJMRT, LLC v Kern
2017 NY Slip Op 07038 [154 AD3d 1288]
October 6, 2017
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 29, 2017


[*1]
 AJMRT, LLC, Respondent,
v
Linda L. Kern et al.,Appellants.

Leclair Korona Vahey Cole LLP, Rochester (Paul L. Leclair of counsel), fordefendants-appellants.

Underberg & Kessler, LLP, Rochester (Alina Nadir of counsel), forplaintiff-respondent.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Monroe County (Matthew A. Rosenbaum, J.),entered May 16, 2016. The order, among other things, granted plaintiff a preliminary injunctionand denied the cross motion of defendants to dismiss the complaint.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.

Memorandum: Plaintiff is the lessee of property located at 2080 East Ridge Road in theTown of Irondequoit (property). Defendant Linda L. Kern acquired the property in 2008 and, in2016, she sold it to defendant 2080 East Ridge Rd LLC. Plaintiff subsequently commenced thisaction seeking, inter alia, specific performance of a right of first refusal to purchase the propertypursuant to a lease agreement executed in 1971 by the alleged predecessors in interest of plaintiffand Kern (1971 lease). Plaintiff alleges that, in March 2003, Kern's predecessor in interest andplaintiff executed an "Extension of Lease" (March 2003 extension), which assigned the 1971lease to plaintiff and extended the term of that lease. Plaintiff moved for, inter alia, a temporaryrestraining order and preliminary injunction enjoining defendants from altering or transferring theproperty, or taking any other action with respect to the property that may be adverse to plaintiff'sinterest during the pendency of this action. Defendants cross-moved for, inter alia, an orderdismissing the complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1), (3) and (7) on the ground that plaintiffdid not have a right of first refusal inasmuch as the 1971 lease is not the operable lease for theproperty, and that the March 2003 extension extended the term of a lease of the property datedMarch 27, 2003 (March 27, 2003 lease). Supreme Court, inter alia, granted that part of plaintiff'smotion seeking a preliminary injunction and denied defendants' cross motion. We affirm.

We conclude that the court properly granted that part of plaintiff's motion seeking apreliminary injunction. "In order to prevail on a motion for a preliminary injunction, the movingparty has the burden of demonstrating, by clear and convincing evidence, (1) a likelihood ofsuccess on the merits, (2) irreparable injury in the absence of injunctive relief, and (3) a balanceof equities in its favor" (Eastman KodakCo. v Carmosino, 77 AD3d 1434, 1435 [2010]; see John G. Ullman & Assoc., Inc. v BCK Partners, Inc., 139AD3d 1358, 1358 [2016], lv dismissed 28 NY3d 943 [2016]).

With respect to the first element, we conclude that plaintiff established by clear andconvincing evidence that there was a likelihood of success on the merits with respect to whetherthe March 2003 extension was an agreement to extend the term of the 1971 lease. While theMarch 2003 extension does not specifically refer to the 1971 lease and does make reference to alease dated March 27, 2003, plaintiff avers that the March 27, 2003 lease was never drafted,executed or recorded, and defendants were unable to locate a copy of the March 27, 2003 lease.Moreover, plaintiff submitted evidence that plaintiff and Kern acted with the understanding thatthe March 2003 extension extended the 1971 lease inasmuch as plaintiff made, and defendant[*2]Kern accepted, rental and tax payments in accordance withthe terms of the 1971 lease, and Kern gave plaintiff notice of the bona fide offer to purchase theproperty, as required under the right of first refusal clause found in the 1971 lease.

We further conclude that plaintiff established by clear and convincing evidence that it will beirreparably harmed in the absence of injunctive relief. We reject defendants' contention that thecourt improperly considered evidence submitted in plaintiff's reply papers with respect to thatissue (see Ryan Mgt. Corp. v Cataffo, 262 AD2d 628, 630 [1999]). In its moving papers,plaintiff submitted evidence that it leased the property for several years with the understandingthat the 1971 lease, which included a right of first refusal clause, was in effect. Plaintiff alsosubmitted evidence that it exercised its right of first refusal pursuant to the terms of the 1971lease. It was only after defendants submitted their opposition to plaintiff's motion that plaintiffbecame aware that defendants contended that the 1971 lease was inoperative. In reply, plaintiffmade a "direct response to [the] allegations raised by . . . defendant[s] in [their]opposition papers" (id.), by asserting that it had previously attempted to purchase theproperty but that its offer was rejected, and that it had been waiting to purchase the propertypursuant to the right of first refusal clause in the 1971 lease because the property is unique, has aprime location and holds value to the family of plaintiff's members.

With respect to the third element, we conclude that the balance of equities favors grantingthat part of plaintiff's motion seeking a preliminary injunction (see Felix v Brand Serv. Group LLC,101 AD3d 1724, 1726 [2012]). Although defendants may suffer a delay in altering ortransferring the property should they prevail on the merits, plaintiff's interest will be permanentlyaffected if the property is altered or transferred while this action is pending.

Finally, we conclude that the court properly denied defendants' cross motion to dismiss thecomplaint (see generally EBC I, Inc. vGoldman, Sachs & Co., 5 NY3d 11, 19 [2005]). Present—Whalen, P.J.,Peradotto, Lindley, NeMoyer and Curran, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.