| Matter of Buttenschon v Salatino |
| 2018 NY Slip Op 05988 [164 AD3d 1588] |
| September 7, 2018 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1](September 7, 2018)
| In the Matter of Donald S. Buttenschon et al.,Respondents, v Christopher J. Salatino, Appellant, et al., Respondents. (Appeal No.1.) |
Donald R. Gerace, Utica, for respondent-appellant.
Bouvier Law LLP, Buffalo (Jeffrey T. Bochiechio of counsel), forpetitioners-respondents.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Herkimer County (Charles C. Merrell, J.), datedAugust 17, 2018 in a proceeding pursuant to Election Law article 16. The order, inter alia,invalidated the Working Families Party designating petition of respondent Christopher J.Salatino.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Petitioners commenced these proceedings pursuant to Election Law§ 16-102 with separate petitions seeking to invalidate designating petitions pursuantto which Christopher J. Salatino (respondent) sought to be placed on the primary election ballotsfor the Working Families Party and Democratic Party as a candidate for the office of New YorkState Assembly, 119th Assembly District. In appeal No. 1, respondent appeals from an order that,inter alia, granted the petition seeking to invalidate the Working Families Party designatingpetition and, in appeal No. 2, he appeals from an order that, inter alia, granted the petitionseeking to invalidate the Democratic Party designating petition.
In appeal No. 1, respondent contends that Supreme Court erred in determining that threesignatures on the Working Families Party designating petition were invalid on the ground that thesignatories had addresses in the Town of Whitestown and their signatures were witnessed byrespondent in his capacity as commissioner of deeds for the City of Utica inasmuch as petitionersfailed to submit evidence establishing that those signatures were not made in the City of Utica.That contention is raised for the first time on appeal and is therefore not properly before us (see Matter of Davis v Czarny, 153AD3d 1556, 1557 [4th Dept 2017]; Crowner v King, 151 AD3d 1858, 1858 [4th Dept 2017]; Cook v Peterson, 137 AD3d 1594,1599 [4th Dept 2016]).
Contrary to respondent's contention in appeal No. 2, the court properly invalidated hisDemocratic Party designating petition on the basis of fraud. "As a general rule, a candidate'sdesignating petition will be invalidated on the ground of fraud only if there is a showing that theentire designating petition is permeated with that fraud" (Matter of Perez v Galarza, 21 AD3d 508, 508 [2d Dept 2005],lv denied 5 NY3d 706 [2005]). "Even when the designating petition is not permeatedwith fraud, however, when the candidate has participated in or is chargeable with knowledge ofthe fraud, the designating petition will generally be invalidated" (id. at 509). Here,petitioners established that multiple subscribing witnesses, including respondent, attested falselythat they had witnessed certain signatures on the designating petition inasmuch as they hadallowed third-parties to sign the petition on behalf of the person named as the signatory on thedesignating petition (see Matter ofValenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d 1056, 1058 [3d Dept 2011]), and that respondent attested tocertain signatures although he was not "in the presence of the signatories when [they] signed the[designating] petition" (Matter of McHale v Smolinski, 133 AD2d 520, 520 [4th Dept1987]; see Election Law § 6-132 [2]; Matter of Tani v Luddy, 32Misc 2d 53, 55 [Sup Ct, Westchester County 1961]). Thus, the court properly determined thatrespondent's participation in fraudulent acts warranted invalidating the designating petition forthe Democratic Party (see Matter of Flower v D'Apice, 104 AD2d 578, 578 [2d Dept1984], affd 63 NY2d 715 [1984]). Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, DeJoseph,Troutman and Winslow, JJ.
Petitioners having moved, by order to show cause, to dismiss the appeals taken herein fromorders of the Supreme Court entered in the Office of the Clerk of the County of Herkimer onAugust 23, 2018, on the ground that appellant failed to include and serve necessary parties, andfor other relief, now, upon reading and filing the affirmation of Jeffrey T. Bochiechio, Esq., datedSeptember 4, 2018, the proposed order to show cause, the supporting papers therein with proof ofservice thereof, and the affidavit of Donald R. Gerace, Esq., sworn to September 5, 2018, anddue deliberation having been had thereon, it is hereby ordered that the motion is denied.