Aretakis v Cole's Collision
2018 NY Slip Op 07028 [165 AD3d 1458]
October 18, 2018
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 28, 2018


[*1]
  John Aretakis, Respondent,
v
Cole's Collision,Appellant.

Lippes Mathias Wexler Friedman LLP, Albany (Thomas D. Latin of counsel), forappellant.

John Aretakis, Troy, respondent pro se.

Mulvey, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (R. Sise, J.), entered September 21,2017 in Saratoga County, which denied defendant's motion for summary judgment dismissing thecomplaint.

On March 1, 2011, an automobile owned by plaintiff's wife was struck from behind byanother vehicle, propelling it into the vehicle in front of it and causing significant damage. Thevehicle, ownership of which was later transferred to plaintiff, was thereafter brought todefendant's body shop to be repaired. Dissatisfied with the repair work, plaintiff commenced thisaction against defendant for breach of contract and fraud. Defendant's motion to dismiss the fraudcause of action was granted and, following joinder of issue and discovery, defendant moved forsummary judgment dismissing the remaining breach of contract claim. Supreme Court denied themotion, and defendant appeals.

We affirm. "On a motion for summary judgment, the movant must establish its prima facieentitlement to judgment as a matter of law by presenting competent evidence that demonstratesthe absence of any material issue of fact. Only when the movant satisfies its obligation does theburden shift to the nonmovant to present evidence demonstrating the existence of a triable issueof fact" (Smero v City of SaratogaSprings, 160 AD3d 1169, 1170 [2018] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted];see Jacobsen v New York City Health& Hosps. Corp., 22 NY3d 824, 833 [2014]; Roemer v Allstate Indem. Ins. Co., 163 AD3d 1324, 1325 [2018]).On such a motion, we must view the evidence in the light most favorable to the nonmoving partyand accord such party the benefit of every reasonable inference that can be drawn therefrom (see De Lourdes Torres v Jones, 26NY3d 742, 763 [2016]; Roemer v Allstate Indem. Ins. Co., 163 AD3d at 1325).

In support of its motion, defendant primarily relied on the affidavit of Josh Jewett, its generalmanager at the time plaintiff's vehicle was repaired. Based upon his review of the damageestimates prepared by defendant, Jewett addressed the state of the vehicle following the accident,the repairs performed and the condition of the vehicle when it was released to plaintiff. WhileJewett averred that all work performed on plaintiff's vehicle was done in a professional andworkmanlike manner, nowhere in the affidavit does Jewett state that he performed any of thework or ever personally inspected the vehicle (see McGrath v George Weston Bakeries, Inc., 117 AD3d 1303,1305 [2014]; Madalinski vStructure-Tone, Inc., 47 AD3d 687, 688 [2008]; Monge v Home Depot, 307AD2d 501, 502 [2003]; Connor v Tee Bar Corp., 302 AD2d 729, 730-731 [2003];Montuori v Town of Colonie, 277 AD2d 643, 645 [2000]; Fernandez v MHP LandAssoc., 188 AD2d 417, 418 [1992]; see generally JMD Holding Corp. v Congress Fin. Corp., 4 NY3d373, 384-385 [2005]). Further, other evidence submitted by defendant established that, afterthe repair work was completed, the driver's side door of the vehicle suffered from, among otherthings, improperly aligned hinges. Thus, defendant failed to establish its prima facie entitlementto judgment as a matter of law by eliminating all material issues of fact as to the adequacy of therepairs performed (see generally Powersv 31 E 31 LLC, 24 NY3d 84, 92-93 [2014]; Winegrad v New York Univ. Med.Ctr., 64 NY2d 851, 853 [1985]). Even had defendant sustained its initial burden, theevidence proffered by plaintiff in opposition to the motion—including his own affidavitdescribing the multiple problems that he experienced with the vehicle following the completionof the repair work—raised triable issues of fact precluding an award of summaryjudgment.

Contrary to defendant's further contention, plaintiff is not precluded from pursuing his breachof contract claim based on the release executed in the separate action that he commenced againstthe driver of the other vehicle and her insurer. The release provides that "[plaintiff] reserves all ofhis rights, claims and causes of action against any other person, entity, or company other than[third-party defendants], involved in, or with respect to, the inspection and appraisal and repair of[plaintiff's vehicle]." While it is true that the common-law collateral source rule—whichprecludes the reduction of a damages award by the amount of any compensation that the injuredperson may receive from another source—does not apply to breach of contract claims(see Inchaustegui v 666 5th Ave. Ltd. Partnership, 96 NY2d 111, 116 [2001]), the releasehere does not itemize or otherwise specify the damages covered by the settlement figure.Moreover, at this point, a triable issue of fact exists as to whether damages suffered as a result ofthe alleged breach are greater than the funds received from the settlement (see Blanche, Verte & Blanche, Ltd. vJoseph Mauro & Sons, 79 AD3d 1082, 1083-1084 [2010]; Dweck v Bridge Transp., Inc., 12AD3d 560, 561 [2004]).

Finally, given the unresolved factual issues regarding the adequacy of the repairs performedand the fact that plaintiff's remaining cause of action is grounded in breach of contract, ratherthan negligence, we find no basis upon which to dismiss that portion of the complaint that seeksdamages for the diminution in value of the vehicle caused by the allegedly faulty repairs (compare Angielczyk v Lipka, 132AD3d 1380, 1381 [2015]; Parkoff vStavsky, 109 AD3d 646, 647 [2013], lv denied 22 NY3d 864 [2014]).

Egan Jr., J.P., Clark, Aarons and Pritzker, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,with costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.