Matter of Harry's Nurses Registry, Inc. (Commissioner ofLabor)
2019 NY Slip Op 03114 [171 AD3d 1410]
April 25, 2019
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 29, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Harry's Nurses Registry, Inc., Doing Businessas Harry's Home Care, Appellant. Commissioner of Labor,Respondent.

Raymond Nardo, Mineola, for appellant.

Letitia James, Attorney General, New York City (Dawn A. Foshee of counsel), forrespondent.

Lynch, J.P. Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedFebruary 7, 2017, as superceded by a decision filed September 6, 2018, which assessed Harry'sNurses Registry, Inc. for additional unemployment insurance contributions.

Harry's Nurses Registry, Inc., doing business as Harry's Home Care (hereinafter HNR), is astaffing agency that provides health care services to its clients, which consist of hospitals, nursinghomes and private patients. To provide these services to its clients, HNR retains the services ofregistered nurses, licensed practice nurses, certified home health aides and personal care aides(hereinafter collectively referred to as health care workers). Following an audit for the years2008, 2009 and 2010, the Department of Labor issued an initial determination that assessed HNRfor additional unemployment contributions based upon remuneration paid to its health careworkers. HNR objected to the determination, and, following hearings, an Administrative LawJudge, among other things, sustained the objection, overruling the Department's assessment ofunemployment insurance contributions for the at-issue period. Upon administrative review, theUnemployment Insurance Appeal Board, in a February 2017 decision, reversed theAdministrative Law Judge's decision and upheld the Department's initial determination assessingunemployment insurance contributions, and this appeal ensued.

In May 2018, while this appeal was pending, the Board sua sponte reopened its February2017 decision pursuant to Labor Law § 534 "to reconsider all issues," and, uponrequest, this appeal was held in abeyance pending the Board's further proceedings. In aSeptember 2018 decision, the Board rescinded its prior February 2017 decision, reversed thedecision of the Administrative Law Judge and sustained the Department's initial determination.In so doing, the Board found that the health care workers were employees of HNR and, further,that the Board was not bound by a prior unappealed Administrative Law Judge decision fromJune 1999 that found HNR's health care workers that it had retained to be independentcontractors. This appeal was subsequently restored to the Court's calendar, and supplementalbriefing ensued.[FN1]

We affirm. HNR's sole contention on appeal is that the Board's September 2018 decision wasimproper because it is bound by the prior unappealed Administrative Law Judge decision from1999 finding that, for the audit years 1993, 1994 and 1995, HNR's health care workers wereindependent contractors.[FN2] We disagree. The Board is not" 'required to conform to the precedent established in [a] prior unappealed decision [of anAdministrative Law Judge] or offer a rational explanation for not doing so' " (Matter of Ingle [Mechanical Secretary,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 129 AD3d 1424, 1426 [2015], quoting Matterof Bull [Yansick Lbr. Co.—Sweeney], 235 AD2d 722, 723 [1997], lvdismissed 90 NY2d 913 [1997]; see generally Labor Law § 621 [3]).Moreover, the underlying determination under review covered a different audit period, and theBoard articulated its reasons for deciding this matter differently—to wit, that this casepresented additional factors or indicia of control over important aspects of the work performed bythe health care workers that were not present or identified in the prior 1999 decision of theAdministrative Law Judge (see Matter of Charles A. Field Delivery Serv. [Roberts], 66NY2d 516, 520 [1985]; Matter of Ingle [Mechanical Secretary, Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 129 AD3d at 1426; Matter of McKenna [Can Am RapidCourier—Sweeney], 233 AD2d 704, 705 [1996], lv denied 89 NY2d 810[1997]). Accordingly, we discern no basis upon which to disturb the determination of theBoard.

Clark, Mulvey, Aarons and Rumsey, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:We note that the merits of theBoard's September 6, 2018 decision are reviewable by this Court on the pending appeal, as HNRis aggrieved by that decision in essentially the same manner as it was by the appealed-fromdecision (see Matter of Tracy[Commissioner of Labor], 145 AD3d 1218, 1219 and n [2016]; Matter of McCauley [Commissioner ofLabor], 104 AD3d 973, 973 [2013]).

Footnote 2:We do not consider HNR'sargument that the record does not contain substantial evidence to support the Board'sdetermination that HNR's health care workers are employees for purposes of the unemploymentinsurance law. "This contention was improperly raised for the first time in [HNR's supplementalreply memorandum of law] to this [C]ourt" (People v Ford, 69 NY2d 775, 777 [1987]; see Matter of Jay's Distribs., Inc. vBoone, 148 AD3d 1237, 1241 [2017], lv denied 29 NY3d 918 [2017]; seegenerally Rules of App Div, All Depts [22 NYCRR] § 1250.8 [b], [d]) and wasalso not raised in HNR's supplemental brief submitted to this Court.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.