Matter of Town of Mamakating v Village of Bloomingburg
2019 NY Slip Op 05732 [174 AD3d 1175]
July 18, 2019
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 4, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Town of Mamakating et al.,Appellants,
v
Village of Bloomingburg et al., Respondents.

Jacobowitz and Gubits, LLP, Walden (J. Benjamin Gailey of counsel), for appellants.

Alex Smith, Middletown, for Village of Bloomingburg and others, respondents.

Whiteman Osterman & Hanna LLP, Albany (Robert S. Rosborough IV of counsel), forSullivan Farms II, Inc., respondent.

Aarons, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Mott, J.), entered March 9, 2018in Ulster County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a combined proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgment, to review, among other things, adetermination of respondent Village of Bloomingburg Planning Board reaffirming subdivisionand site plan approval for a development.

Respondent Sullivan Farms II, Inc. sought approval to construct a townhouse complex in theVillage of Bloomingburg, Sullivan County. An environmental impact statement under the StateEnvironmental Quality Review Act (see ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) was preparedand, in July 2009, respondent Village of Bloomingburg Board of Trustees adopted the findings ofthe SEQRA findings statement for the project. Later that month, respondent Village ofBloomingburg Planning Board adopted the findings of the Village Board of Trustees as its own.In 2010, the Village Planning Board granted subdivision and site plan approval to SullivanFarms, and construction began in 2012.

In 2016, however, petitioner Town of Mamakating Planning Board, acting pursuant to anintermunicipal agreement that gave it the powers, authority and responsibilities of the VillagePlanning Board, rescinded the 2010 subdivision and site plan approval. Sullivan Farms thereafteramended its subdivision and site plan application and proposed to widen the roads to be inaccordance with the applicable codes. Sullivan Farms also requested in its amended applicationthat the Village Board of Trustees reaffirm the 2009 SEQRA findings and that the VillagePlanning Board reaffirm the 2010 subdivision and site plan approval. In January 2017, theVillage Board of Trustees and the Village Planning Board took such requested action.[FN1]

Petitioners commenced this combined CPLR article 78 proceeding and declaratory judgmentaction seeking, among other things, to annul the determination by the Village Board of Trusteesto reaffirm the 2009 SEQRA findings and the determination by the Village Planning Board toreaffirm the 2010 subdivision and site plan approval. Petitioners thereafter moved for apreliminary injunction. Prior to answering, Sullivan Farms cross-moved to dismiss the petitionon the basis of lack of standing. Respondent Village of Bloomingburg, the Village PlanningBoard and the Village Board of Trustees also made a pre-answer cross motion and joinedSullivan Farms' claim regarding lack of standing. In an October 2017 order, Supreme Courtdenied petitioners' motion and partially granted the cross motions. Following joinder of issue, thecourt, in a March 2018 judgment, dismissed the petition/complaint. Petitioners appeal. Weaffirm.

As an initial matter, to the extent that respondents argue, as an alternative ground foraffirmance, that the Town Planning Board lacked the authority to rescind the 2010 subdivisionand site plan approval, such argument is not properly before us. In addition to submitting anamended subdivision and site plan application, Sullivan Farms commenced a combined CPLRarticle 78 proceeding and declaratory action seeking, among other things, annulment of the TownPlanning Board's rescission determination on the basis that the Town Planning Board had noauthority to take such action. In a February 2017 judgment, Supreme Court dismissed SullivanFarms' petition/complaint to the extent that it sought such relief. We subsequently dismissedSullivan Farms' appeal therefrom as moot based on the action taken by the Village PlanningBoard in reaffirming the 2010 subdivision and site plan approval (Matter of Sullivan Farms II, Inc. v Town ofMamakating Planning Bd., 165 AD3d 1447, 1449-1450 [2018]). In view of ourdecision, respondents cannot, in this appeal, reassert their contention that the Town PlanningBoard's rescission determination was unlawful.

Assuming, without deciding, that petitioners have standing to bring thisproceeding/action,[FN2] wefind that Supreme Court correctly dismissed the petition/complaint. Petitioners argue that theVillage Planning Board lacked the authority to reaffirm the 2010 subdivision and site planapproval. We disagree. "Despite the lack of statutory authority, a planning board may reconsidera determination if there has been a material change of circumstances since its initial approval ofthe plat or new evidence is presented" (Matter of 1066 Land Corp. v Planning Bd. of Town ofAusterlitz, 218 AD2d 887, 887 [1995] [citations omitted]). Given that the record disclosesthat the Village Planning Board was presented with new information in the amended subdivisionand site plan, we find that it was authorized to reaffirm the approval notwithstanding the fact thatit had been previously rescinded.

We reject petitioners' contention that the reaffirmation of the 2010 subdivision and site planapproval by the Village Planning Board was arbitrary and capricious. The record discloses thatvarious data and information were examined before reaffirming the approval. As part of itsrequest that the Village Planning Board consider an amendment to its subdivision and site planapproval, Sullivan Farms submitted analyses from engineering experts examining the potentialstormwater impacts and increased water usage due to the proposed expansions of the road.Sullivan Farms also submitted an analysis contesting the Town Planning Board's conclusions asto water usage and negative effects of increased traffic. The Village Engineer, after reviewingthis material, recommended approving the amended subdivision and site plan application. TheVillage Planning Board reviewed and considered the foregoing information and, therefore, wecannot say that its determination to reaffirm the 2010 subdivision and site plan approval wasarbitrary and capricious (see Matter ofEdscott Realty Corp. v Town of Lake George Planning Bd., 134 AD3d 1288, 1290-1291[2015]). Furthermore, although petitioners offered competing expert opinions, the VillagePlanning Board was entitled to credit the information submitted by Sullivan Farms as opposed tothat of petitioners (see Matter of Duganv Liggan, 121 AD3d 1471, 1473 [2014]). In addition, contrary to petitioners' claim, theVillage Planning Board was not required to refer the revised subdivision and site plan approval tothe applicable county planning department because "the particulars of the amendment wereembraced within the original referral" (Matter of Benson Point Realty Corp. v Town of E. Hampton, 62 AD3d989, 992 [2009], lv dismissed 13 NY3d 788 [2009]).

Petitioners' assertion that the Village Board of Trustees lacked jurisdiction to act as theSEQRA lead agency is without merit inasmuch as the Village Board of Trustees served as theoriginal lead agency and, therefore, had a continuing duty to evaluate the new evidence presentedby Sullivan Farms (see Mobil Oil Corp. v City of Syracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 224AD2d 15, 23 [1996], appeal dismissed 89 NY2d 860 [1996], lv denied 89 NY2d811 [1997]). Nor do we find merit in petitioners' claim that the Village Board of Trustees failedto comply with SEQRA or that its determination not to direct a supplemental environmentalimpact statement was arbitrary and capricious. The record discloses that the Village Board ofTrustees reviewed and considered various information, including the recommendation,resolutions and SEQRA findings of the Village Planning Board, a report from the Village'sengineer and information provided by Sullivan Farms concerning water and sewage use andincreased traffic. In our view, the Village Board of Trustees took the requisite hard look at therelevant areas of concern and satisfied the requirements of SEQRA in determining that asupplemental environmental impact statement was not necessary (see Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v PlanningBd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d 219, 231-232 [2007]; Matter of Gabrielli v Town of NewPaltz, 116 AD3d 1315, 1318 [2014]; Matter of Eadie v Town Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 47 AD3d1021, 1024-1025 [2008]; Matter ofBasha Kill Area Assn. v Planning Bd. of Town of Mamakating, 46 AD3d 1309, 1312[2007], lv denied 10 NY3d 712 [2008]). Furthermore, even if we agreed with petitionersthat the reasoning provided by the Village Board of Trustees was not sufficiently elaborate, the"record is adequate for us to exercise our supervisory review to determine that [it] strictlycomplied with SEQRA procedures" (Matter of Ellsworth v Town of Malta, 16 AD3d 948, 950 [2005]).Accordingly, we cannot say that the Village Board of Trustees' determination in this regard wasarbitrary and capricious.

We are unpersuaded by petitioners' argument that a conflict of interest existed such that thedetermination to reaffirm the SEQRA findings by the Village Board of Trustees must beannulled. "In determining whether a disqualifying conflict exists, the extent of the interest atissue must be considered and[,] where a substantial conflict is inevitable, the public officialshould not act" (Matter of Parker v Town of Gardiner Planning Bd., 184 AD2d 937, 938[1992], lv denied 80 NY2d 761 [1992]). It is undisputed that two of the three members ofthe Village Board of Trustees rented homes from a company affiliated with the principal ofSullivan Farms. This mere relationship, however, does not give rise to an instance where asubstantial conflict would be inevitable. Moreover, petitioners failed to tender any proofindicating how the subject members gained any benefit or advantage by their votes. As such, wefind that no conflict of interest existed (see Matter of Schupak v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town ofMarbletown, 31 AD3d 1018, 1021 [2006], lv denied and dismissed 8 NY3d 842[2007]). Petitioners' remaining contentions have been considered and are unavailing.

Garry, P.J., Lynch, Clark and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:In reaffirming the 2009 SEQRAfindings, the Village Board of Trustees also determined that a supplemental environmentalimpact statement was unnecessary.

Footnote 2:Respondents also contend as analternative ground for affirmance that Supreme Court should have granted their respectivepre-answer cross motions to dismiss for lack of standing in their entirety.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.