People v Mills
2020 NY Slip Op 01644 [181 AD3d 718]
March 11, 2020
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 29, 2020


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
Karmel Mills, Appellant.

Richard L. Herzfeld, New York, NY, for appellant.

Anthony A. Scarpino, Jr., District Attorney, White Plains, NY (William C. Milaccioand Christine DiSalvo of counsel), for respondent.

Appeal by the defendant from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Westchester County(Barry E. Warhit, J.), rendered November 30, 2017, convicting him of murder in thesecond degree, burglary in the first degree, and strangulation in the first degree, upon hisplea of guilty, and imposing sentence.

Ordered that the judgment is affirmed.

The determination of a motion to withdraw a plea of guilty rests within the sounddiscretion of the motion court, and that determination generally will not be disturbedabsent an improvident exercise of discretion (see People v Walker, 169 AD3d 723 [2019]; People v King, 115 AD3d986, 986 [2014]). "Generally, a plea of guilty may not be withdrawn absent someevidence or claim of innocence, fraud, or mistake in its inducement" (People v DeLeon, 40 AD3d1008, 1009 [2007]). "Whether a plea was knowing, intelligent and voluntary isdependent upon a number of factors 'including the nature and terms of the agreement, thereasonableness of the bargain, and the age and experience of the accused' "(People v Garcia, 92 NY2d 869, 870 [1998], quoting People v Hidalgo,91 NY2d 733, 736 [1998]).

We agree with the Supreme Court's determination denying the defendant's motion towithdraw his plea of guilty. During the plea allocution, the defendant indicated that hehad enough time to consult with his attorney and that he entered the plea freely andvoluntarily. Contrary to the defendant's contention, the court made clear that thedefendant was pleading guilty to murder in the second degree, and not manslaughter.Accordingly, the plea of guilty to the crime of murder in the second degree wasknowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently entered (see People v Duart, 144 AD3d 1173 [2016]). There is nomerit to the defendant's contention that he was pressured into accepting the plea (see People v Sparbanie, 158AD3d 942, 944 [2018]; People v Palmer, 174 AD3d 1118 [2019]).

The defendant's contention that his plea of guilty was involuntary because theSupreme Court erroneously refused to assign him new counsel is contradicted by hisstatements made during the plea proceeding that he was satisfied with counsel'srepresentation (see People vTrimble, 137 AD3d 1309 [2016]; People v Bennett, 115 AD3d 973 [2014]; People v Howard, 109 AD3d487, 488 [2013]). To the extent that the defendant contends that he receivedineffective assistance of counsel with respect to the negotiation of the plea, the recordreveals that he received an advantageous plea, and nothing in the record casts doubt uponthe apparent effectiveness of counsel (see People v Henry, 95 NY2d 563, 566[2000]; People vYarborough, 83 AD3d 875, 875 [2011]).

The defendant's remaining contentions were not raised in his motion to withdraw hisplea of guilty and, therefore, are not preserved for appellate review (see People v Stutzman, 158AD3d 1294, 1295 [2018]; People v Miller, 1 AD3d 613, 613 [2003]). In any event,there is no merit to the defendant's contention that the allocution as to the burglary countwas factually deficient, or that the Supreme Court failed to conduct an adequate inquiryinto a potential justification defense to the count of murder in the second degree (seePeople v Lopez, 71 NY2d 662, 667 [1988]; People v Sierra, 256 AD2d 598,599 [1998]; cf. People v Riley, 91 AD2d 671 [1982]). There was nothingin the plea proceedings that triggered the court's duty to inquire into a potentialjustification defense (see Peoplev Colemanorange, 151 AD3d 738 [2017]). Further, the defendant's postpleaassertions regarding a justification defense contradicted the admissions he made underoath at his plea allocution and were insufficient to warrant withdrawal of his plea (see People v Glusko, 114AD3d 701 [2014]; People vDelarosa, 104 AD3d 956 [2013]; People v Dazzo, 92 AD3d 796, 796 [2012]). Dillon, J.P.,Cohen, Duffy and Connolly, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.