| Matter of Circle T Sterling, LLC v Town of Sterling Zoning Bd. ofAppeals |
| 2020 NY Slip Op 05348 [187 AD3d 1542] |
| October 2, 2020 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Circle T Sterling, LLC,Appellant, v Town of Sterling Zoning Board of Appeals, Respondent. Virginia M.Fichera et al., Intervenors-Respondents. |
Costello, Cooney & Fearon, PLLC, Syracuse (Nadine C. Bell of counsel), forpetitioner-appellant.
Camardo Law Firm, P.C., Auburn (Kevin M. Cox of counsel), forrespondent-respondent.
Neil M. Gingold, Fayetteville, for intervenors-respondents.
Appeal from a judgment (denominated order) of the Supreme Court, Cayuga County (MarkH. Fandrich, A.J.), entered May 31, 2019, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78. Thejudgment, among other things, denied the petition.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Petitioner appeals from a judgment that, inter alia, denied its CPLR article 78petition seeking, among other things, to annul respondent's determination denying petitioner'sapplication for an area variance. We affirm.
Petitioner owns a gravel mine. The prior owners of the mine previously sought and obtainedthe permits necessary to operate the mine. Their plan was to use two access roads to allow fortrucks to travel to and from the mine. The access roads, however, did not comply with a localzoning regulation that requires a 1,000-foot setback from existing residences. The proposed areavariance would provide relief from that regulation. A public hearing was held on April 27, 2015,at which time respondent's members unanimously approved the application for the area variance.One of the reasons for approval expressed by respondent's members was that noise emanatingfrom the mine would be equivalent to that of farming activities prevalent throughout thecommunity. An amended area variance, which eliminated one of the two access roads, wasapproved on September 24, 2015. In a prior related appeal, we vacated the determinationsapproving the area variances based on a jurisdictional defect, and we remitted the matter torespondent for a new determination (Matter of Fichera v New York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 159AD3d 1493, 1496 [4th Dept 2018]). In our decision in that appeal, we concluded that theappellants impermissibly relied on documents and reports, such as a Traffic and Noise Review,which were generated after respondent's determinations (id. at 1497).
A new public hearing was held on remittal. The record of the hearing included the Trafficand Noise Review, in which intervenors' engineer considered, inter alia, the frequency withwhich trucks would pass nearby residences under petitioner's proposed project. Furthermore, theengineer opined that the information provided to the Department of Environmental Conservationconcerning the noise generated by the project was not developed by persons qualified to conductsound testing or modeling, was not performed according to internationally accepted standards,and omitted critical sources of potential noise. In addition, several residents expressed concernsthat the mine would destroy the "peace and quiet" in the neighborhood, with houses located onlya few hundred feet from the access road experiencing noise, odor, and dust from passing trucks.Three of respondent's members expressed concern over potential noise. In the lengthy writtendetermination denying petitioner's application, respondent stated, inter alia, that the "quiet andserene neighborhood would experience the noise of a truck entering or exiting the access roadwith acceleration and braking every 6 minutes" during the 58-hour work week for a projected20-year period.
Petitioner contends that the determination denying the area variance is arbitrary andcapricious because respondent was required either to reach the same result as in its prior twodeterminations or to explain its reasons for reaching a different result. We reject that contention."[A] decision of an administrative agency which neither adheres to its own prior precedent norindicates its reasons for reaching a different result on essentially the same facts is arbitrary andcapricious" (Matter of Tall Trees Constr. Corp. v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town ofHuntington, 97 NY2d 86, 93 [2001] [internal quotation marks omitted]; see Matter ofCharles A. Field Delivery Serv. [Roberts], 66 NY2d 516, 520 [1985]). However, becauserespondent's prior determinations were vacated and thus are "null and void" (Fichera, 159AD3d at 1496), those determinations have no precedential value.
Contrary to petitioner's further contention, respondent's determination denying the areavariance and its reasoning in support thereof are supported by substantial evidence. " 'Arecord contains substantial evidence to support an administrative determination when reasonableminds could adequately accept the conclusion or ultimate fact based on the relevantproof' " (Matter of Bounds vVillage of Clifton Springs Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 137 AD3d 1759, 1760 [4th Dept2016]; see Matter of B.P. Global Funds,Inc. v New York State Liq. Auth., 169 AD3d 1506, 1506 [4th Dept 2019]). Although theadministrative record on the prior determinations contained largely unrefuted assertions that theproposed mining project would create only de minimis levels of increased noise, theadministrative record on the present determination, which denied the area variance, casts seriousdoubt on those representations. Further, the minutes of respondent's proceedings reflect that theissue of increased noise was a factor that respondent's members weighed heavily in reaching theirdetermination. The duty of weighing the conflicting evidence rested solely with respondent(see Bounds, 137 AD3d at 1760; see also Matter of Thomas v Town of Southeast, N.Y., 168 AD3d955, 957 [2d Dept 2019]), and we perceive no basis for disturbing its determination.
We have considered petitioner's remaining contentions and conclude that none warrantsreversal or modification of the judgment. Present—Peradotto, J.P., Lindley, NeMoyer,Troutman and DeJoseph, JJ.