| People v Naula |
| 2022 NY Slip Op 50386(U) [75 Misc 3d 1205(A)] |
| Decided on April 28, 2022 |
| Supreme Court, Queens County |
| Johnson, J. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on April 28, 2022
The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff, against Edwin Naula, Defendant. |
Ind. No. 70879/2021
For Defendant: Jessica Bettencourt, Esq., Queens County Legal Aid Society
For the People: ADA Dylan Nesturrick, Queens County District Attorney's Office
Michelle A. Johnson, J.
Recitation, as required by CPLR 2219[a], of the papers considered in the review of thismotion
Papers ConsideredDefendant's n/m (Omnibus), March 23, 2022, Jessica Bettencourt, Esq.,affirm
People's response, March 25, 2022, ADA Dylan Nesturrick, Queens County DistrictAttorney's Office, affirm
People's Certificate of Compliance and Statement of Readinessfiled November 16, 2021
People's Supplemental Certificate of Compliance and Statementof Readiness filed February 8, 2022
By Omnibus motion dated February 23, 2022, defendant moves for the following: (1)Inspection and release of the Grand Jury minutes; (2) Dismissal of the Indictment as defective;(3) Dismissal of the Indictment, or alternatively, reduction of the counts as legally insufficient;(4) Finding Good Cause to allow the filing of this motion; (5) Dismissing the accusatoryinstrument pursuant to CPL §§ 30.30 and 210.20(l)(g); 6) Suppression of IdentificationEvidence (Dunaway/Wade); (7) Pre-trial voluntariness hearing for Un-noticedStatements; (8) Preclusion of Un-Noticed Statement and Identification Evidence; (9)Sandoval Hearing; (10) Severance (CPL § 200.40); (11) Reservation of Rights.
MOTION TO INSPECT AND RELEASE
Defendant's motion to inspect the Grand Jury minutes is granted. Upon inspection,defendant's motion for release of the Grand Jury minutes is denied since the defendant has failedto demonstrate any compelling need for such action and the Court is able to determine the motionwithout assistance (see CPL § 210.30[3]). However, the People are reminded oftheir obligation to disclose all transcript(s) of person(s) who testified before the Grand Jury,unless [*2]subject to a protective order, pursuant to CPL §245.20(l)(b).
MOTION TO DISMISS OR REDUCE
Defendant's motion to dismiss the indictment, or alternatively, to reduce the counts therein,is denied since the evidence adduced before the Grand Jury was legally sufficient to sustain theindictment. Moreover, the district attorney properly instructed the Grand Jury on the relevant law(see People v. Calbud, Inc., 49 NY2d 389 [1980]). Lastly, the presentation of the case tothe Grand Jury was not defective as a matter of law. The minutes reveal that a quorum of theGrand Jurors was present during the submission of evidence and at the time that the districtattorney instructed the Grand Jury on the law. No unauthorized person within the meaning ofCPL § 190.25 was present at any time during the proceedings (see People v.Sayavong, 83 NY2d 702 [1994]). Additionally, no irregularity that would impair the integrityof the Grand Jury occurred (see People v. Adessa, 89 NY2d 677 [1997]; People vHuston, 88 NY2d 400 [1996]).
DISCOVERY COMPLIANCE
The prosecutor and defense counsel (hereafter the parties) are reminded of their continuingduty to diligently confer with each other pertaining to any and all outstanding discoveryissues/disputes, excluding protective orders under CPL § 245.70.
Pursuant to the Administrative Order of the Chief Administrative Judge and in furtherance ofthe fair administration of justice, the parties are hereby reminded and directed to uphold theirconstitutional, statutory, and ethical responsibilities in the above-captioned proceedings asindicated in the attached Order to Counsel in Criminal Cases.
Additionally, the People are ordered to comply with their initial automatic discoveryobligations outlined in CPL §§ 245.10 and 245.20; their continuing discoveryobligations as set forth in CPL § 245.60; and their continuing obligation to provide allBrady material. Finally, defendant and/or defense counsel are ordered to comply withtheir reciprocal discovery obligations pursuant to CPL §§ 245.20(4) and 245.60.
MOTION TO PERMIT LATE FILING FOR GOODCAUSE
The instant motion was filed in-excess of the forty-five (45) days allotted for this purposepursuant to CPL § 255.20. Defense counsel maintains that the delay was caused byCOVID-19, her medical condition, and her engagement on other cases. Accordingly, this Court,in its discretion, finds good cause for the late filing pursuant to CPL § 250.20(3).
Defendant moves to dismiss the instant indictment pursuant to CPL § 30.30(l)(a) andCPL § 210.20(l)(g) on ground that the People's Statement of Readiness, filed on November16, 2021, was illusory due to the People's failure to file a valid Certificate of Compliance withthe requisite disclosure mandates pursuant to CPL § 245.20; namely, the grand juryminutes.
Procedural History
Defendant was arraigned on thefelony complaint on May 12, 2021, during the Governor's suspension of the speedy trial statute asreferenced herein. The case was adjourned to June 14, 2021, for Grand Jury action. Followingtwo (2) more adjournments for Grand Jury Action, on June 14th and September 16, 2021, thePeople obtained an indictment against defendant on November 15, 2021. Immediately thereafter,on November 16, 2021, the People filed the indictment, Certificate of Compliance (hereafterCOC), and a Statement of Readiness (hereafter SOR) for trial. Notably, the People represented inthe COC that the Grand Jury minutes were not yet available to them.
The case was first scheduled on the Supreme Court calendar for defendant's arraignment[*3]on the indictment on December 3, 2021. Defendant did notappear due to his hospitalization. The court stayed a bench warrant and adjourned the case toDecember 8, 2021, for defendant's arraignment on the indictment. Meanwhile, on the same date,the People served the Grand Jury minutes on defendant via email (People's Response, pg 2).
On December 8, 2021, defendant was arraigned on the indictment. The People affirmed itsreadiness based on the previous off-calendar filing of the COC and SOR; and the court set amotion schedule. The case was adjourned to February 16, 2022, for decision on Omnibusmotions. In the interim, off-calendar on February 8, 2022, the People filed a Supplemental COCand SOR which included its disclosure of the Grand Jury minutes to defendant. In theSupplemental COC, the People represented that it had "obtained material or information that wasnot in existence/created when the People previously certified compliance." (People's COC filed2/8/2022, pg 1).
PEOPLE'S STATEMENT OF READINESS FILED NOVEMBER 16,2021
The defendant contends that the People failed to meet its automatic discovery obligationspursuant to CPL § 245.20 (1) which rendered the SOR filed on November 16, 2021, invalid.CPL § 245.20 (1) provides that,
The Prosecution shall disclose to the defendant all items and information thatrelates to the subject matter of the case and are in the possession, custody, or control of theprosecution or persons under the prosecution's direction or control.
CPL§ 245.20 (7) directs this Court to apply a presumption in favor of disclosure wheninterpreting the statutory text of CPL §§ 245.10, 245.25, and 245.20. All items andinformation related to the prosecution of a charge in the possession of any New York State orlocal police department or law enforcement agency are explicitly deemed to be in the prosecutor'spossession, custody, or control (CPL § 245.20 [2]). The statute further imposes anautomatic and affirmative duty upon the prosecutor to make diligent, good-faith efforts todetermine the existence of material and/or information to be available for discovery where itexists but is not (emphasis added) within the prosecutor's possession, custody, or control(CPL § 245.20 [7]). Where, despite diligent, good faith efforts and reasonable inquiry, thePeople are unable to secure and disclose mandated discoverable material within the statutorilyallotted time periods, the law prescribes that the People make an application to the court toenlarge the time to comply with its disclosure requirements (CPL § 245.70 [2]).
The statute goes on to enumerate a non-exhaustive list of materials subject to theprosecution's automatic disclosure mandate (Id.); and specifically includes Grand Juryminutes within the mandate of automatic discovery (CPL § 245.20 [l] [b]). The statutefurther provides,
If in the exercise of reasonable diligence and due to the limited availability oftranscription resources, a transcript is unavailable for disclosure within the time period specifiedin subdivision one of section 245.10 such time period may be stayed by up to anadditional thirty calendar days without need for a motion pursuant to subdivision two ofsection 245.70 of this article; except that such disclosure shall be made as soon aspracticable and not later than thirty calendar days before the first scheduled trial date, unless anorder is obtained pursuant to section 245.70 of this article
The newdiscovery statute imposes an affirmative and ongoing duty for the People to obtain and discloseadditional material and information that is subject to automatic mandatory discovery pursuant toCPL § 245.20 (see CPL § 245.60). Moreover, the new law now directly linksthe People's compliance with its automatic discovery obligations, as a condition precedent, [*4]to the validity of its Statement of Readiness (SOR) and speedy trialcalculations.
To be sure, notwithstanding the provisions of any other law, CPL § 245.50(3) providesthat absent an individualized finding of special circumstances by the court before which a chargeis pending, the prosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial pursuant to CPL § 30.30 untilit has filed a proper Certificate of Compliance pursuant to CPL § 245.50(1). Similarly, CPL§ 30.30(5) requires that any statement of trial readiness must be accompanied or precededby a certification of good faith compliance with the disclosure requirements of CPL §245.20.
In order for the People to file a valid SOR, the People must first: (1) file a COC uponsatisfaction of its discovery obligations under CPL § 245.20(1), except for discovery that islost or destroyed, or any items or information that are the subject of a protective order pursuant toCPL § 245.70; (2) affirm that it has disclosed and made available all known material andinformation subject to discovery after having exercised due diligence and making reasonableinquiries to ascertain the existence of such material and information; and (3) must include a listidentifying the discovery materials provided (CPL § 245.50[1]). If additional discovery issubsequently provided or required prior to trial, the statute provides for a supplemental certificatewhich shall be served upon the defendant and filed with the court identifying the additionalmaterial and information provided (CPL § 245.60). No adverse consequence to theprosecution or the prosecutor shall result from the filing of a certificate of compliance in goodfaith and reasonable under the circumstances; but the court may grant a remedy or sanction for adiscovery violation as provided in CPL § 245.80.
Clearly, Grand Jury minutes are automatically discoverable pursuant to CPL §245.20(1)(b); and the People were required to disclose such materials to the defendant in order tosatisfy its obligations under CPL § 245.20(1). Despite the clear mandate of the statute, thePeople filed a COC on November 16, 2021, wherein the People affirm that it had disclosed . . .all existing known material and information subject to discovery [emphasis added],except . . . items or information subject to a protective order under section 245.70 of the CriminalProcedure Law (People's COC filed 11/16/2021, pg 1). The People further posit that the GrandJury minutes, which they knew to exist at the conclusion of the grand jury presentment, were notyet available to them (Id.). The People's COC averments are flawed in this regard. First,unlike a lab test or DNA analysis that had yet to be conducted or completed at the time of a COCfiling, the minutes of a Grand Jury proceeding are recorded in real time and exist upon theconclusion of the presentment. That the grand jury minutes had not yet been transcribed does notnegate the veracity of its existence. Second, unlike a test or report conducted by an entity outsideof the People's control, as in the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner for example, Grand Jurystenographers throughout New York City are employed by the prosecutor's office (seeJudiciary Law § 321).[FN1]Hence, the grand jury minutes and the transcription of said grand jury minutes are directly underthe prosecutor's custody and control.
In promulgating the new discovery statute, the legislature anticipated a circumstance [*5]where the prosecutor may be deemed ready for trial, despitenon-compliance with its automatic discovery obligations; and recognized that unavoidable delaysmay prevent a diligent prosecutor from attaining full compliance despite its best efforts to obtainall relevant material in a timely manner (People v. Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518, 146 NYS3d 906 [ NY Crim Ct.2021]; People v. Adrovic, 69 Misc3d 563, 130 NYS.3d 614 [NY Cty Crim Ct. 2020]; People v. Diaz, —NYS.3d —, 2022 NY Slip Op. 22083, [Bx Cty Crim Ct. 2022]; People v. Henry, 74 Misc 3d1230[A], 2022 NY Slip Op 50265[U] [Richmond Cty Sup Ct. 2022] [the only purpose ofa certificate of compliance is to serve as a necessary prerequisite to a valid statement of readinessfor purposed of CPL § 30.30]). In such case, amongst the available statutory options,the People may seek a judicial ruling authorizing its filing of a SOR based on an individualizedfinding of special circumstances pursuant to CPL § 245.50(3) (Id.).
In this case, the People failed to move the court for "an individualized finding of specialcircumstances" to file a SOR despite their awareness of the existence of grand jury minutes; norhave they demonstrated any impediments or obstacles to having the grand jury minutestranscribed for disclosure that might constitute an exceptional circumstance under CPL §30.30[4][g]. The People do not allege that the grand jury minutes were either lost or destroyed, orthat such information was the subject of a protective order pursuant to CPL § 245.70. Infact, the People have failed to put forth any argument in support of a statutory exception thatwould authorize its filing of a SOR under the circumstances presented here.
Instead, in an apparent effort to stop the speedy trial clock, given the almost six (6) monthdelay in securing an indictment, the People filed a COC and SOR erroneously affirming that "allknown materials and information subject to discovery" had, in fact, been "disclosed." To acceptthe People's SOR under these circumstances, would, in effect, vitiate the underlying legislativeintent of the statute which mandates full compliance with discovery as a prerequisite to thePeople's declaration of readiness for trial (see Androvic, supra [the People can't file aCertificate of Compliance claiming they have disclosed all known discovery if they have notactually done so without the express permission of the court]; People v. Quinlan, 71 Misc 3d 266, 142 NYS3d 305 [NY Crim Ct.2021]; see also People ex rel. Ferro v.Brann, 197 AD3d 787 [2d Dept. 2021] [the People's filing of a certificate ofcompliance pursuant to CPL § 30.30(5) cannot be complete until all material andinformation subject to discovery was actually disclosed to defendant pursuant to CPL §245.50(1)]).
Accordingly, whereas here, the People cannot point to a statutory exception exemptingnon-disclosure of the grand jury minutes or authorizing a declaration of readiness for trial in spiteof such missing discovery, I find that the SOR filed on November 16, 2021, was neitheraccompanied and/or preceded by the requisite good faith certification of compliance with thedisclosure requirements of CPL § 245.20 (See CPL § 245.50[3] and 30.30[5]);and is therefore illusory.
Speedy Trial Calculations:
Since thedefendant was charged with one or more offenses, at least one of which is a felony, the Peoplemust announce ready for trial within six (6) calendar months from the date of commencement,absent a showing of excludable time (CPL § 30.30[1][b]). Defendants were arraigned on thefelony complaints on May 12, 2021, thereby commencing the action. Hence, the six-monthspeedy trial clock expires on November 12, 2021, absent excludable time. In this case, the six (6)month period is the equivalent of one hundred and eighty-four (184) days.
In determining whether the People have satisfied their obligation to be ready for trial [*6]under Criminal Procedure Law § 30.30, this Court mustcalculate the time between the filing of the first accusatory instrument and the People'sdeclaration of readiness, then subtract any statutorily excludable periods of delay, and finally addany periods of post-readiness delay that are attributable to the People for which statutoryexclusions apply (see People v. Cortes, 80 NY2d 201 [1992). Once the defendant hasshown the existence of a delay greater than the statutory period, the burden rests on the people toshow any pre-readiness exclusions, and on the defendant to show any post-readiness inclusions(People v. Chavis, 91 NY2d 500, 504-505 ([1998]). The People also bear the burden ofproducing a record of the proceedings sufficient for the court to reach "an informed decision"regarding what time may be excludable (People v. Stirrup, 91 NY2d 424 [1998];People v. Cortes, supra, at 215 [1992]).
The prosecution accurately concedes that it had accrued a total of 176 days of chargeabledelay from commencement of the criminal action to the date it filed the aforementionedSOR.
As is relevant here, beginning March 20, 2020, New York State's Governor issued anExecutive Order suspending and tolling speedy trial calculations pursuant to the CriminalProcedure Law as a result of a global pandemic (See Governor's Executive Order 202.8effective 3/20/20). Thereafter, the Governor issued multiple successive Executive Orders whichcontinued to extend the suspension and tolling of speedy trial time under the Criminal ProcedureLaw through and including May 23, 2021, for unindicted felonies (See Executive Orders202.67, 202.87, and 202.106). On May 24, 2021, the speedy trial limitations of CPL § 30.30resumed for all pending felony matters (See Executive Order 202.106).
May 12, 2021 to May 23, 2021:Defendant argues that thistime period is chargeable to the People because the Governor's Executive Order No. 202.87,issued on December 30, 2020, tolled CPL §§ 30.30 and 190.80 " to the extentnecessary [emphasis added] to toll any time periods contained therein for the period duringwhich the criminal action is proceeding on the basis of a felony complaint through arraignmenton the indictment or on a superior court information and thereafter shall not be tolled." Thedefendant avers that because grand juries were operating at the time, the People must establishthat they were unable to indict the case due to a condition caused by the global pandemic in ordertoll speedy trial accruals during this time. To that end, the People contend that while grand juriesconvened during this period, grand jurors were being quarantined; only a limited number ofgrand juries were sitting at a time; and given such limitations, the prosecutor prioritized indictingcases of incarcerated defendants over defendants at liberty pending prosecution (People'sResponse, pg. 2). Notably, defendant was at liberty pending prosecution of these charges (Courtfile). Under the circumstances, I find that the People's ability to present defendant's case to agrand jury during this time period was impacted by the ongoing COVID-19 Global Pandemic. Assuch, the eleven (11) day period from May 12th to May 23rd is excluded. {Total of 0 days ofdelay chargeable to the People}
On May 24, 2021, the speedy trial provisions of CPL § 30.30 resumed again for allpending felony matters (see Executive Order 202.106). Between May 24th and November15, 2021, the case remained in pending grand jury action status on the felony complaint. OnNovember 16, 2021, the People served and filed the instant indictment; Certificate ofCompliance pursuant to CPL § 245.20; and Statement of Readiness for trial pursuant toCPL § 30.30. Thus, the People accrued one hundred and seventy-six (176) days of delayfrom May 24th to November 15, 2021. {Total of 176 days of delay chargeable to thePeople}
As decided herein, the Court finds the People's SOR filed on November 16, 2021, to be[*7]illusory and therefore invalid to stop the speedy trial clock.The People filed a Supplemental Certificate of Compliance and Statement of Readiness onFebruary 8, 2022. The People's Supplemental COC affirmed that the People had met itsdiscovery obligations by disclosing the outstanding grand jury minutes to defendant incompliance with CPL § 245.20.[FN2]Therefore, I find that the People's Supplemental COC to be proper; and Statement of Readinessfiled on February 8, 2022, to be valid. Hence, the People accrued eighty-four (84) days of delayfrom November 16, 2021, to February 7, 2022. {Total of 260 days of delay chargeable to thePeople}
For the aforementioned reasons, this Court calculates that as of February 8, 2022, the Peoplehave accrued a total of two hundred and sixty (260) chargeable days of delay sincecommencement of this action. Accordingly, defendants' motion to dismiss on ground of astatutory speedy trial violation is GRANTED in its entirety.
In light of the above ruling, the remaining branches of defendant's Omnibus Motion arerendered moot.
The foregoing constitutes the opinion, decision, and order of the court.
Dated: April 28, 2022
Kew Gardens, New York
MICHELLE A. JOHNSON,J.S.C.
Footnote 1:In the county of Queens, it shallbe lawful for the district attorney of said county to appoint ten stenographers, each of whom shallhave authority to take and transcribe the testimony given before the grand juries in the saidcounty of Queens, and such appointments shall be in writing, under the hand and seal of suchdistrict attorney, and shall be filed in the county clerk's office of said county of Queens (Jud Law§ 321[f]).
Footnote 2:On December 3, 2021, thePeople emailed the necessary grand jury minutes to defense counsel but neglected tosimultaneously file the Supplemental COC and valid SOR until February 8, 2022. Even assumingthe People had filed a Supplemental COC and SOR on December 3, 2021, they would haveaccrued an additional sixteen (16) days of delay; well over the 8 days of delay remaining in thiscase. As a result, dismissal on statutory speedy trial grounds would have been granted in anyevent.